Correct url http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/02/online-legal-publishers-squabble-over-the-right-to-copyright-the-law/
On Thu, Feb 11, 2016 at 11:40 PM, George Antunes <[email protected]> wrote: > Online legal publishers squabble over the right to copyright the law Do > private online publishers own the law, or does it belong to the people? > > *Feb 11, 2016 1:05pm CST* > > > *by David KravetsMultichannel News* > > http://www.multichannel.com/news/content/cbs-all-access-considering-ad-free-service/402539 > > Well, it's OK to copy the actual law. But if you copy the state-ordered > summaries... > > Two big-name legal research companies are battling in federal court over > the right to exclusively publish the law—in this case, the Georgia > Administrative Rules and Regulations. > > The lawsuit > <http://ia801500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.0.pdf> > (PDF) > comes as states across the nation partner with legal research companies to > offer exclusive publishing and licensing deals for digitizing and making > available online the states' reams of laws and regulations. The only > problem is that the law is not copyrightable—or so says one of the > publishers involved in the Georgia litigation. In this instance, District > of Columbia-based legal publisher Fastcase wants a judge to fend off a > cease-and-desist demand from rival Virginia-based Lawriter, which has been > designated as the exclusive publisher > <http://ia601500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.1.pdf> > (PDF) > of Georgia's compilation > <http://ia601500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.2.pdf> > (PDF) > of the rules and regulations of its state agencies. The lawsuit says: > > The Georgia Regulations are binding law—a broad-ranging collection of > rules and regulations governing areas from consumer protection to banking > to elections. The Georgia Regulations are promulgated by public agencies of > the State of Georgia, and published for the benefit of the public by the > Georgia Secretary of State, as required by O.C.G.A. § 50-13-7. Defendant > Lawriter purports to have exclusive rights to publish the Georgia > Regulations. Consistent with this claim of exclusive rights, Lawriter has > sent Plaintiff Fastcase a demand that Fastcase remove the Georgia > Regulations from its legal research service, which is provided as a free > member benefit to members of the State Bar of Georgia. The Georgia > Regulations are public law published under statutory mandate and are in the > public domain. Defendant cannot claim any exclusive right in, to, or in > connection with, the Georgia Regulations. Thus, Fastcase seeks declaratory > judgment that Lawriter has no basis from which to prohibit Fastcase from > publishing the Georgia Regulations in its subscription legal research > service. > > Fastcase also says Lawriter "cannot claim a valid copyright or an > exclusive license to a valid copyright. It is well established in American > law that state laws, including administrative rules and regulations, are > not copyrightable, and must remain public as a matter of due process." > > In Lawriter's demand letter, Lawriter says Fastcase has been illegally > offering its customers access to the "Georgia Administrative rules and > Regulation Electronic Files." > > "According to Lawriter's records, however, Fastcase has not entered into a > subscription with Lawriter for the Electronic Files and therefore appears > to be offering the Electronic Files without Lawriter's consent or > authorization, and in violation of Lawriter's legal rights." The demand > letter > <http://ia801500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.3.pdf> > (PDF) > requests that Fastcase cease the online publishing of Georgia's law or > "purchase a subscription." The letter also demands "Fastcase immediately > provide a written response substantiating its rights to its use of the > Electronic Files." Instead, Fastcase sued. > > Fastcase CEO Ed Walters told Ars by e-mail: "This case deals with a small > library, but the issues are larger and very important. The law is the last, > great walled garden on the Internet, at a time when access to justice is a > greater problem than ever. From here, things could go either way. This > could be the beginning of an age of open government—or states could partner > with private publishers who copyright or paywall the law. We're not going > to sit back and watch this happen. When Lawriter threatened to sue us for > using public law, it was time to stand up." > > Georgia has already defended its right to license the law and is suing > <http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/georgia-sues-legal-rebel-for-posting-states-copyrighted-law-online/> > legal rebel Public.Resource.org <https://public.resource.org/>, based in > California, for publishing the Peach State's laws. That case is pending. > > "It's a big deal," Carl Malamud, who runs Public.Resource.org, said in an > e-mail to Ars. He said the Fastcase-Lawriter litigation "presents the same > issues as our case: Can you speak the law without a license from the state? > We say anybody can read and speak the law in America because the people own > the law." >
_______________________________________________ Medianews mailing list [email protected] http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net
