http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-golden13apr13,1,4786388.column?coll=la-utilities-business

Privacy Statutes Need to Catch Up
Michael Hiltzik
LA Times

April 13, 2006


On whether the Bush administration's claim that its once-secret program of 
domestic eavesdropping is legal and constitutional, there will be endless 
debate — in coffeehouses, courtrooms, and, it is to be hoped, in Congress.

But a public interest group's recent lawsuit charging AT&T Inc. with 
willing complicity in the program should wake us all up to how our casual 
reliance on new technology has turned privacy into an increasingly fragile 
principle.

In the federal class action filed in January in U.S. District Court in San 
Francisco, the Electronic Frontier Foundation alleges that AT&T helped the 
government intercept the private communications of millions of Americans 
whose data — phone calls, e-mails, Internet transmissions, and Lord knows 
what else — happened to pass over the company's network. (Many of the 
foundation's allegations derive from newspaper reports, including articles 
by my colleagues Josh Meyer and Joseph Menn.)

Earlier this month, EFF filed a statement by Mark Klein, a retired AT&T 
employee, describing the construction of a "secret room" at a company 
facility in San Francisco, purportedly so data moving over its fiber-optic 
lines could be split off and fed into the National Security Agency loop.

Klein's declaration, as well as some internal documents he provided to EFF, 
were filed with the court under seal, but according to a version his 
attorneys made public last week, the room housed a "semantic traffic 
analyzer." This is a machine that can thumb through digital bits looking 
for target patterns — words, phrases, even routings.

Klein said he understood that similar rooms were being installed in other 
cities. In a statement he made earlier to one of my Times colleagues, he 
added, "These installations enable the government to look at every 
individual message on the Internet and analyze exactly what people are 
doing" — whether it's transmitting e-mail, Web surfing, what have you. AT&T 
declined to discuss the case, and Klein's lawyers say he's not making any 
further statements for the moment.

It's plain that the necessary ingredients for a surveillance program on 
such a scale are the will and the technology. The law no longer matters, 
because technology has left it in the dust.

The limits of permissible search and seizure evolved from the 4th Amendment 
in an era when one's personal papers typically remained within the confines 
of one's own house. Mail was transmitted under seal; over time, the rules 
covering the government's access to outside-the-envelope information such 
as addresses became liberalized, but what was inside remained inviolate 
without a search warrant based on probable cause.

But sealed mail is no longer the issue in high-tech surveillance; instead, 
we communicate via streams of digital bits that, to the average person, 
still feel like a form of first-class mail. But they're very different.

Most of today's rules dictating the government's rights to view personal 
electronic records derive, one way or another, from the federal Electronic 
Communications Privacy Act. This statute was enacted in 1986 largely in 
response to case law from the 1970s. In today's fast-moving world, it's a 
rare law that can go without regular updating, and ECPA is hopelessly 
superannuated.

"The law has been marching in place and, unfortunately, the technology has 
been marching ahead," Deirdre Mulligan, director of the Samuelson Law, 
Technology & Public Policy Clinic at UC Berkeley's law school, told me this 
week.

The problem is evident if one considers how "electronic communications" 
were defined in 1986. As Mulligan observed in a 2004 article for the George 
Washington Law Review, e-mail then was a communications medium for limited 
business and professional communities. The first commercial online bulletin 
board, the WELL, had appeared in 1985 but served fewer than 2,000 members. 
The commercial e-mail services MCI Mail and CompuServe didn't appear until 
1989, and the World Wide Web not until 1991.

Only after online banking and shopping a la Amazon showed up in the late 
1990s did Americans become acclimated to transmitting our account numbers, 
credit card codes, addresses and other personal details over the Web.

But then our qualms faded rapidly. Internet phone services appeared, along 
with network applications allowing us to store on some commercial entity's 
servers a mind-boggling range of personal info — lists of our financial 
assets, and journals and diaries containing our most private thoughts. 
Meanwhile, the websites we viewed or traded with accumulated information 
about our habits and routines linked to Internet addresses traceable to our 
very desktops.

Very few people are aware that much of this data can be snorted up by 
government authorities with subpoenas issued merely on the assertion that 
the information may be "relevant" to an investigation, and often without 
notice to the individual who sent it. Even fewer realize that while an 
e-mail kept on their own computer can't be seized without a search warrant, 
the same message kept on Google or Yahoo's mail system can be seized 
without one.

So we've become dangerously blase about what we allow other people to keep 
or read. Google's Gmail service discourages subscribers from ever deleting 
anything — with 3 gigabytes of storage for every user, why put anything in 
the trash, it asks, treating as a virtue the eternal life of a personal 
e-mail located somewhere in cyberspace. What Google doesn't tell its 
customers is that any message left on that server, even unread, for more 
than six months can be accessed by the government's prying eyes with very 
little legal ceremony.

The NSA's vacuuming of terabytes of personal data from AT&T's network is an 
example of the government aggressively taking advantage of a tattered 
fabric of privacy protection. The Electronic Frontier Foundation says it's 
convinced the feds and the company crossed the line: "AT&T is not supposed 
to allow the government to engage in wiretapping without a search warrant," 
says EFF attorney Kevin Bankston, who is involved in the case. "There's no 
ambiguity in how electronic search statutes govern your commerce with other 
people."

I wish I were as confident that matters were so clear-cut. The statutes are 
old and worn, and the one thing the NSA program tells us is that they need 
to be brought into the 21st century, fast.


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu



Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_____________________________

MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to