http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-altfuels16apr16,1,5077384.story?coll=la-headlines-business

A Future Without Oil?
Proponents of alternative fuels are seeing a rare convergence of 
technology, money, political will and motivated motorists.
By Elizabeth Douglass
LA Times Staff Writer

April 16, 2006


Jon Spallino drives a $1-million car to work.

Banish any thought of a flashy red Ferrari. Since June, the Redondo Beach 
resident has been tooling around in a rather pedestrian-looking, two-door 
Honda FCX.

What matters is on the inside: hope for a future without oil. The Honda 
runs on electricity from a hydrogen-powered fuel cell tucked under the seats.

"I was sure I would be giving up something in terms of utility or comfort 
or performance," Spallino said. "As it turns out, I haven't given up anything."

Spallino is part of an accelerating push toward alternative forms of 
energy. Researchers and investors — and President Bush — are talking 
hopefully about powering cars and trucks with hydrogen and fuels made from 
corn, prairie grass, even French fry grease. Despite scientific advances, 
increased investment and unprecedented political backing, plenty of 
potholes remain.

The most daunting of those is the magnitude of the task. Cars, trucks, 
trains, planes and other vehicles account for 7 of every 10 barrels of oil 
consumed in the U.S.

With such a deep reliance on oil, the transportation world has been nearly 
impervious to change. Electric-hybrid vehicles are barely a blip, 
alternative fuels have made only tiny inroads, and a push for more 
fuel-efficient cars has stalled under the Bush administration.

"In the transportation sector, we've essentially made no progress in the 
last 25 years," said Daniel Sperling, director of the Institute of 
Transportation Studies at UC Davis.

Bush's Advanced Energy Initiative, which he promoted in a February tour of 
research sites, would inject badly needed money into alternative-fuel programs.

Critics say the commitment is paltry. Bush's fiscal 2007 budget seeks about 
$150 million for biofuels and $290 million for hydrogen-related research. 
By comparison, the government spends an estimated $150 million a day in Iraq.

But proponents believe the decades of inertia could be broken by a rare 
convergence of technology, money, political will and motivated motorists.

"I see a broader base of interest and support now than ever before," said 
James Boyd, a member of the California Energy Commission.

Even the president, a onetime oilman, shifted his stance by declaring in 
January's State of the Union speech that the country was "addicted to oil" 
and that it should "move beyond a petroleum-based economy."

Renewable fuels such as ethanol and biodiesel hold the greatest promise of 
immediately reducing oil consumption because they are available today for 
use in existing vehicles.

Ethanol is made from organic material such as grain crops, wood chips and 
agricultural waste. A distillation and fermentation process, similar to 
what goes on in a brewery, converts corn kernels and the like into ethanol.

The fuel is made from renewable sources, boosts octane levels and pollutes 
the air less than gasoline does. Regular vehicles can run on gasoline 
blends of as much as 10% ethanol without changing anything, and the 
nation's more than 5 million so-called flex-fuel vehicles can use gasoline 
blends with as much as 85% ethanol.

Government subsidies help keep the cost of ethanol close to that of 
gasoline, and last year, oil companies blended ethanol into about one-third 
of the nation's car fuel. In California, ethanol has been widely used as a 
component of cleaner-burning gasoline since 2004, when the state banned the 
use of methyl tertiary butyl ether because it contaminates groundwater.

About 4 billion gallons of ethanol were used last year, replacing 170 
million barrels of oil. Under a federal mandate, ethanol consumption could 
almost double by 2012.

"It is the only option we have today in terms of a liquid fuel alternative 
to gasoline that can be used in the existing distribution system," said 
Neil Koehler, who has spent half of his 48 years pushing ethanol as a way 
to loosen crude oil's hold on cars.

Fresno-based Pacific Ethanol Inc., where Koehler is chief executive, 
recently won an $84-million pledge from Microsoft chief Bill Gates' 
investment firm. The company plans to open the first of five ethanol plants 
this year in Madera County.

Still, ethanol is no silver bullet.

Growing corn consumes oil products — fertilizers and tractor diesel — and 
processing equipment runs on natural gas or coal. Ethanol contains less 
energy than gasoline, so vehicles won't go as far on a gallon of fuel. And 
ethanol comes with its own air pollution headache — although much smaller 
than gasoline's — because ethanol makes gasoline evaporate more easily, 
releasing volatile organic compounds, a component of smog.

Today, fuel ethanol is made mostly from corn and other grains in the United 
States and from sugar in Brazil. But because farm land is limited and those 
source crops are arguably more valuable as food, experts say the long-term 
value of ethanol is that it can also be made from plant fibers of all kinds.

Researchers are experimenting with making ethanol from agricultural waste, 
wood chips and common prairie grasses using enzymes and bacteria. They also 
are probing termite innards to tap the insect's ability to digest wood. 
Experts say producing ethanol through those means would use less energy 
than current methods. But perfecting the process and making it affordable 
could take as long as six years.

Biodiesel is another alternative fuel gaining momentum.

It is most commonly produced from animal fats or natural oils such as those 
found in corn and soybeans. Some biodiesel is made from used vegetable oil 
tossed out by restaurants, giving a vehicle's exhaust the faint smell of 
fried food.

Production of biodiesel requires simple chemical reactions, which can be 
carried out in a good-sized refinery or a backyard contraption. The 
finished product can be sold as is to motorists, but it's more commonly 
blended into regular petroleum-based diesel in concentrations of 2% to 20% 
biodiesel. A company backed by country singer Willie Nelson has drawn 
attention to the fuel by selling BioWillie, a 20% biodiesel blend.

Stephen Flynn is among the converts. More than a year ago, the Valencia 
resident dumped his gasoline car for a 1996 Chevy Suburban diesel he found 
on EBay, and he's been filling up with 99% biodiesel ever since. Flynn, a 
prop master for television commercials, says he goes as much as 500 miles 
before refueling.

Any diesel engine can operate normally on a low concentration of biodiesel; 
a high concentration can require minor modifications.

"It runs great and clean," Flynn said. "I don't see any cons."

Biodiesel not only reduces consumption of petroleum-based diesel, thereby 
cutting harmful vehicle emissions, but also boosts the diesel equivalent of 
octane and improves lubrication in the engine.

The principal drawback is its expense compared with that of traditional 
diesel, though the gap has closed substantially with government incentives, 
tax breaks and the recent rise in diesel prices. In addition, biodiesel can 
be difficult to find because it is sold at only about 600 filling stations 
nationwide.

Flynn solved the problem by joining a co-op in West Los Angeles, where 
members fill up with 99% biodiesel from a self-serve dispensing trailer set 
up in a leased section of a parking lot. The group's 40 members pay an 
average of $3.40 a gallon for the fuel, a slightly inflated price to help 
offset overhead costs, according to co-op founder Colette Brooks.

"I'm not going back, even if I have to make it myself," Flynn said of 
biodiesel.

The most tantalizing alternative fuel of all is hydrogen. It's abundant, 
packed with energy, doesn't pollute and can be burned by itself or used to 
power battery-like devices known as fuel cells.

Hydrogen "has the potential of completely eliminating oil use and 
drastically reducing greenhouse gases," said Sperling of UC Davis. "It's 
also the most complex in terms of needing to transform both the energy 
industry and the automotive industry."

Thanks to a proliferation of experimental programs, there are more than 100 
vehicles on U.S. roads powered by hydrogen fuel cells or liquid hydrogen, 
according to the National Hydrogen Assn.

The Spallinos got one of them because they owned a natural-gas-fueled 
Honda, demonstrating to the car company that the family's members were 
adventurous and environmentally conscious. When a Honda representative 
called to offer them the chance to become "the world's first fuel cell 
family," Spallino said, they promptly signed up.

"I was interested because it's an alternative to oil … but also because the 
environmental benefits of a car that emits just a few drops of water were 
intriguing to me," Spallino said. Hydrogen gas, stored aboard the car in 
tanks, flows to a stack of fuel cells that create electricity to drive the 
engine. Unused water drips from the exhaust.

The family leases the car for $500 a month and must supply critiques of its 
performance. Spallino uses the FCX to commute to his job as chief financial 
officer of Southland Industries, an Irvine engineering and construction 
company.

The roadblocks to the hoped-for hydrogen heyday are considerable. Producers 
must find cheap and environmentally benign ways to extract hydrogen, and a 
whole new fleet of cars and fueling stations must be built.

Nearly all of the hydrogen in use today is separated from natural gas using 
steam and a catalyst. It's the cheapest method but emits some carbon 
dioxide, a greenhouse gas believed to cause global warming. In addition, 
using natural gas as a hydrogen source doesn't cut the nation's ties to 
finite fossil fuels.

Once the hydrogen's captured, there's the challenge of transporting and 
storing it. And people need places to fill up.

Honda handles refueling for the Spallinos with two hydrogen-making test 
units in Torrance. One strips hydrogen from water, using electricity 
collected through solar panels. The other collects hydrogen from natural 
gas. The Spallinos' car goes about 190 miles before it needs a hydrogen 
refill. Honda estimates that the price of each fill-up could range from 
less than 10 cents to 39 cents a mile depending on the process used.

"We should place some bets on hydrogen," said Peter Smith, chairman of the 
National Assn. of State Energy Officials. But, he added, not at the expense 
of funding near-term solutions.

"Right now we have the best opportunity we've had in a while," Smith said. 
"Energy is on the news every day."

*

(INFOBOX BELOW)

Fueling transport

Cars, trucks, planes and trains consume most of the nation's oil. Sales of 
alternative vehicles are projected to remain relatively small.

U.S. use of petroleum products by sector

Transportation – 70%

Industrial – 24%

Residential – 4 %

Commercial – 2%


================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
antunes at uh dot edu



Reply with a "Thank you" if you liked this post.
_____________________________

MEDIANEWS mailing list
[email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to