SSD card = camera memory or maybe a USB stick

One thing I've heard about flash memory is that it is VERY slow compared to a hard drive.

That would make wonder if it's viable for any large amount of storage.

Sp


SD cards are generally in cameras, standing for Secure Digital, they use flash with a uC or specialized ASIC on the card to handle commands.

USB sticks are generally called USB sticks or flash sticks, not "SSD USB sticks." They also use a uC on the PCB to handle commands.

Although these are technically SSDs in the strictest sense of the meaning "Solid State Drive." When someone refers to SSDs, they tend to refer to drives that have an ATA/SAS/PCI-E interface and use SLC/MLC NAND Flash for storage, or in some cases RAM (enterprise solutions, and the rare consumer one like the Gigabyte drive using DDR from a few years ago).

For consumer MLC NAND based SSDs, Flash memory is very slow to erase compared to a hard drive, which can just copy over data. SSDs have to zero out a large block of Flash and read-modify-write. Write throughput depends on the configuration of the flash, and how good the SSD controller is. For example, my Intel X25Vs run 5 channels of flash, write at 40MB/s max throughput, and read at 190MB/s. The X25M runs 10 channels of flash, and writes twice as fast with roughly the same read speed. You can think of flash channels like RAID0, or ganged dual channel RAM.

Write speed doesn't matter much in this application.. although SandForce based SSDs read AND write at 285MB/s.. and most any drive has more sequential write throughput than the Intel drives. While MLC consumer drives are still "fairly," new, the flash in most of the drives is better than what you'd find in an SD card. They are rated at a UBE of 10^14, same as a SATA hard drive. SAS drives are 10^15 UBE.

SLC should last longer than MLC even with primarily reads.

-Frank
_______________________________________________
Mid-Hudson Valley Linux Users Group                  http://mhvlug.org
http://mhvlug.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/mhvlug

Upcoming Meetings (6pm - 8pm)                         MHVLS Auditorium
 Oct 6 - Creating Browser Extensions for Firefox and Chrome
 Nov 3 - Open Source Hardware: Bugs, Beagles and Beyond
 Dec 1 - IBM's Open Client Deployment

Reply via email to