On Wed, 2008-02-06 at 12:29 +0000, Robert O'Rourke wrote: > Martin McEvoy wrote: > > Hello Robert > > > > Hi Martin, nice meeting you the other day
Well met too its surprising the places that you meet people ;) > > > On Tue, 2008-02-05 at 18:39 +0000, Robert O'Rourke wrote: > > > >> For cover tracks you'd have something like: > >> > >> <span class="contributor vcard"> > >> <span class="role">Original Artist</span> - > >> <span class="fn org">Primal Scream</span> > >> </span> > >> > > > > Here is the best action I have seen using roles, It may be useful to the > > discussion. > > > > from http://microformats.org/wiki/hcard-examples-in-wild-reviewed > > > > > > http://www.iowamilitaryveteransband.com/members/ > > > > their roles are the instruments that they play > > > > Roles are *NOT* defined in hAudio as such other than.. > > > > "The role attribute SHOULD be used to specify the contributor's > > responsibility related to the audio recording if hCard is utilized" > > http://microformats.org/wiki/haudio#Contributor > > > > > > the context comes from hcard > > > > "Information regarding the role of the object" > > http://microformats.org/wiki/existing-classes > > > > the "object" in most cases the person. > > > > whats good is, its user defined, we may be able to give sensible hints > > to what you put in there but really it's up to the publisher the choice > > is yours eg: "groupie", or "stage hand" could be fun!. > > > > "original artist", "band", "group", "quartet" are valid roles I would > > say > > > > so are > > > > "vocalist", "bassist", "drummer", "producer", "artist" for individuals > > > > If we had a "hPunchup" microformat you could have a role of "looser" ;) > > > > Ha! and a vevent for every punch. Never thought of marking up a boxing > match until now! It could be reused in hArgument? ...chuckle.... > > > I AM worried that we should be using "title" instead of "role" in some > > cases... > > > > That depends if you look at a piece of music as having "jobs" associated > with it. Is a piece of music some work that people were employed to > create or only a creative endeavour?. In the case of manufactured "bands" I would say that all involved are employed and have Job Titles... as do professional musicians maybe. > It can be either, but as far as > hAudio is concerned I would say "role" is most appropriate. Thoughts? I agree Roles are more important than their job titles as the two may not be related or have any context in the making of a piece of audio. I think the problem with the above is quite often in audio roles and job titles are quite often the same.. Manu explained the differences quite nicley to me.. A role is "what you do", where a title is "what your official title is at the organization". Role is hardly ever used in hcard in the "real world",and as a result not much info, I think maybe more information about "role" can be added to the hAudio wiki, perhaps even some good recommendations? Thanks Martin McEvoy > > > Thanks > > > > Martin McEvoy > > > > > > Cheers, > Rob _______________________________________________ microformats-discuss mailing list [email protected] http://microformats.org/mailman/listinfo/microformats-discuss
