An excellent initial foray into the subject, Orn, and one I'd be inclined to follow. It's certainly a shame that you had to couch it with disclaimers and explanations to avoid charges and accusations which might be brought by the moral harridans among us. Such prejudicial and narrow-minded attitudes go far to squelch any productive discussion of a topic that is so badly in need of openness and exploration.
On Oct 25, 5:05 pm, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > Well, at the risk of being pilloried or worse, such fanatical torture > being an integral part of the western traditions of jurisprudence and > theology, I will confess to being naïve when it comes to the topic of > what seems to be an agreed upon notion for many here – that of child > abuse. At great risk of facing the barbs of the morality keepers, I > will ask specifics in an attempt at understanding it. So far, ‘it’, to > me, seems similar to the term ‘pornography’, both being something that > often is not easily definable but which one ‘knows it when they see > it.’ > > What exactly is included and what is excluded? Is there agreement on > what ‘it’ is? Here I will even forgo the letter of the law guessing > there is no clear line found here, not only from one country to > another but even within one country, one state, one community, one > church etc. > > Let’s start the analysis while I work at ducking the charges of > ‘pornographer’ by the pious local theocracy and gendarmes. > > How do we approach the following? (No need to avert your eyes, I’m > starting out mildly…at least that is my intent, your mileage may > vary.) > > What age constitutes a ‘child’? > > When defined, is it an absolute in the sense that one day before the > birthday is a perversion and one day after is not? What about ON the > birthday? Inquiring minds want to know. > > What relationship(s) are used in defining the ‘abuser’? Parent? > Sibling? Grandparent? Uncle/Aunt? In-law? Neighbor? Friend? Teacher? > Admirer? Stranger? Clergy? Spiritual leader? Psychiatrist? Is this a > constant from community to community? From ethnic group to ethnic > group? From religion to religion? Is it applied to everyone equally? > > What age must the ‘abuser’ be? Older than the ‘child’? Can they be > younger? What if they are a few hours older and ‘it’ occurs on their > birthday? > > What actions constitute abuse in this context? > > Hugging a child? > Leering at a child? > Kissing a child? > Holding a child’s hand? > Caressing a child’s cheek? > Placing a hand on a child’s back? Head? Knee? Thigh? > Sleeping with a child? > > In what I’m sure will be a failed attempt at not being charged with > projected titillation, I will not continue the above list for the > obvious reasons. > > This topic is associated with what, to me, is an unclear notion (child > abuse) except perhaps in the most extreme cases. Example: In almost > every instance of slavery and forced activity, I feel a confidence in > applying the term. Of course, even here the notion of being ‘forced’ > has extended and ever changing meanings. (Please note that I used the > term ‘unclear’ meaning I see no agreement rather than an attempt at > creating a black/white duality of good/bad, of extreme and not- > extreme.) > > To be clear here, I am quite serious with this line of inquiry. I deny > using it to even suggest that it is something one should aspire to or > even tacitly allow. Such accusations of being complicit and/or even an > advocate are the stuff of historical inquisitions. Perhaps if one > identifies with the associated pious clergy and/or lawgivers, this > approach is acceptable. > > Yes, while serious, I am at once being provocative in the sense of > probing beliefs, incalcitrant and possibly cathected positions as well > as looking for answers. I ask these questions of myself and am hard > pressed to find cogent answers, even if/when couched in relativistic > language. Note that I’m not using Reductio Ad Absurdum in most cases > to help gain, at the very least, personal clarity. Further I do not > expect immediate and simple answers to my questions. I merely wish to > continue exploring the mores and memes of the moment, of the psyche > and associated belief structures and emotional reasoning. > > To me, the devil is in the above listed details. > > On Oct 25, 2:29 pm, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > We did briefly have some idiot in using some old hat stuff about > > Simbian (maybe Sambian - I forget easily these days) young male > > homosexual stuff as a paedo excuse Slip. A perhaps inapt metaphor was > > that he got the bum's rush. I've seen no attempt to excuse the > > sickos, certainly not from Gruff (or Molly for that matter). Both on > > the basis of the recent above are right. > > > I am just reading up on how victims get rather generally accused of > > being responsible for their own plight and how we 'find the victim' in > > the perpetrator and a range of ethnographic research (tales might be > > better) of the gutter. There is much one would want not to know that > > one needs to know. We've just seen a young man (witness) give away > > his £10,000 reward to a rape victim and sometimes one is in need of > > such lovely gestures. The madness soon spoils, and now a teacher of > > 62 is fined £1500 for physically removing a 13 year old racist from > > class with a grip on belt and hoodie (am I supposed to turn myself in > > for past crimes?). I'm with Gruff on the need to get much more of > > this out into the open, yet whatever I feel on this I'm glad porn and > > the rest are sort of shut away because I just don't want the stuff. I > > also believe there is much we do know about perverse perpetrators > > already and that it is possible to have discussion on the basis that > > they are problematic and perverse. The current vogue of serial killer > > detection lauds the perversity in my view and most of the genre is > > mere pathetic invention. 30 years ago and more, one could get a pie, > > pint, chips and a strip show in Manchester for what would be £5 > > today. Objectivation with chips! I do not want erotic dancing with > > my beef stew and note I can't get a decent beef stew. > > The social contract in which we give up on individual impulses for > > social gain has long been held a negative one for the individual > > (Freud). I have been suckered by 'clever' shits who have got me into > > all kinds of conversation - one has to go native to some point - and > > it's always difficult to know what is fact and fantasy. There are > > rumours of a very seedy and illegal sex club in Bolton, and there is a > > reality of abuse and rings of it. We have wasted millions on a high > > level, high profile policing failure instead of getting into the > > 'real' (likely squalid, local, family connected). Bureaucratic > > loonies waste money on all kinds of panics that should be seen > > through. The real debate probably has more to do with this form of > > perversion and its base. > > > On 25 Oct, 17:23, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > Thanks, Slip, I guess my response to gruff above will also respond to > > > your points here. > > > > On Oct 25, 1:16 pm, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Not wanting to get in the middle of any fray here but would like to > > > > point out that I don't remember anyone in ME representing pedophilia > > > > as an acceptable behavior, historically or contemporized. > > > > The mere mention of a historical fact serves in the informative sense > > > > and doesn't warrant labeling or personal adherence to any group or > > > > organization, no more than a biblical reference to the rainbow being > > > > an expressed affiliation with a gay coalition. There are people that > > > > are 'unaware' of historical events and not just those based on > > > > sexuality. > > > > I don't see that discussing sexual issues, whether lawful or not, > > > > constitutes a platform for the voice of a criminal element. We should > > > > be able to put all aspects of the issue in perspective in order to see > > > > them for what they are and enable constructive discussion. > > > > > On Oct 25, 7:25 am, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > Gruff the last time we had this go around your proposal of an open > > > > > discussion of the topic of sex resulted in your espousing your ideas > > > > > on the natural and beautiful aspects (in your opinion) of adults > > > > > having sex with children. Very clever of you to suggest that I am a > > > > > prude because I do not want to be a part of a discussion that gives > > > > > pedophiles a platform to voice their "rights" as they are clearly > > > > > blind to the true destructive nature of their crimes. Your statement > > > > > that "the reality is that every year the number of children subjected > > > > > to > > > > > > > pedophile pastimes climbs higher and higher and more children are > > > > > > hurt > > > > > > and many times scarred for life as a result" > > > > > > is a real departure from your views of our last discussion, so I will > > > > > ask you directly, do you think that adults should be allowed to have > > > > > sex with children? Your ideas in the above posts are ideas that > > > > > pedophile rights groups use, along with: pedophilia has always been in > > > > > human history; is not criminal in many cultures; it is a natural > > > > > expression of love between adults and children etc,. These were also > > > > > your views in the last discussion, and the basis of our disagreement. > > > > > My suggestion that we do not use this ME to rationalize this criminal > > > > > behavior is what lead to the very angry feelings between us that are > > > > > now coming to the surface again. > > > > > > An open and honest discussion about sex is very different than > > > > > defending the rights of sexual criminals in a discussion. So, my > > > > > suggestion is, drop the attacks, and let us know exactly where you are > > > > > headed with this. You may notice that not once in this post, did I > > > > > attack you as a person, and I suggest that if you can, stop attacking > > > > > me, as this behavior the last time we discussed this brought you > > > > > repeated suggestions to read the guidelines of group conduct. > > > > > > On Oct 24, 6:27 pm, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > > On Oct 23, 3:53 am (see post supra) Molly wrote "An examination of > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
