I rather agree Gruff that we shouldn't feel constrained by the kind of association of the facts and argument with the abusers. I haven't come across any of the regulars I'd worry about any of our kids going off on an exchange visit with or whatever (other than perhaps worrying about our daughters' behaviour when younger!). It isn't the sex stuff that raises the moral harridan in me - it's the exploitation, damage and grim squalor of my actual experience. Our moral panics cause more problems because they are so badly informed. And, of course, much of the problem is within families and family networks. I was a cop when almost any woman crying rape was subject to quite disgusting treatment, and later saw first-hand how many squalid and institutional cases of abuse were ignored. Molly is right that there are vicious circles to be broken here, and that care is needed not to give kicks to abusers or excuse what they do. Emile Pankhurst was shocked to discover the mores of the English working class when she was a recorder of births and deaths, and although I'm an advocate of more sexual freedom and honesty, I'm still sickened by some of what goes on across our society, from boring pelvic thrusting in pop videos, teenage pregnancies, through false accusations to the continuing lack of sense in the guidance offered on the basis of moral prudery and on to the suspicion culture which still fails to suspect the right people. The grim spread of aids down 'lorry routes' is a case in point.
On 26 Oct, 04:51, gruff <[email protected]> wrote: > An excellent initial foray into the subject, Orn, and one I'd be > inclined to follow. It's certainly a shame that you had to couch it > with disclaimers and explanations to avoid charges and accusations > which might be brought by the moral harridans among us. Such > prejudicial and narrow-minded attitudes go far to squelch any > productive discussion of a topic that is so badly in need of openness > and exploration. > > On Oct 25, 5:05 pm, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Well, at the risk of being pilloried or worse, such fanatical torture > > being an integral part of the western traditions of jurisprudence and > > theology, I will confess to being naïve when it comes to the topic of > > what seems to be an agreed upon notion for many here – that of child > > abuse. At great risk of facing the barbs of the morality keepers, I > > will ask specifics in an attempt at understanding it. So far, ‘it’, to > > me, seems similar to the term ‘pornography’, both being something that > > often is not easily definable but which one ‘knows it when they see > > it.’ > > > What exactly is included and what is excluded? Is there agreement on > > what ‘it’ is? Here I will even forgo the letter of the law guessing > > there is no clear line found here, not only from one country to > > another but even within one country, one state, one community, one > > church etc. > > > Let’s start the analysis while I work at ducking the charges of > > ‘pornographer’ by the pious local theocracy and gendarmes. > > > How do we approach the following? (No need to avert your eyes, I’m > > starting out mildly…at least that is my intent, your mileage may > > vary.) > > > What age constitutes a ‘child’? > > > When defined, is it an absolute in the sense that one day before the > > birthday is a perversion and one day after is not? What about ON the > > birthday? Inquiring minds want to know. > > > What relationship(s) are used in defining the ‘abuser’? Parent? > > Sibling? Grandparent? Uncle/Aunt? In-law? Neighbor? Friend? Teacher? > > Admirer? Stranger? Clergy? Spiritual leader? Psychiatrist? Is this a > > constant from community to community? From ethnic group to ethnic > > group? From religion to religion? Is it applied to everyone equally? > > > What age must the ‘abuser’ be? Older than the ‘child’? Can they be > > younger? What if they are a few hours older and ‘it’ occurs on their > > birthday? > > > What actions constitute abuse in this context? > > > Hugging a child? > > Leering at a child? > > Kissing a child? > > Holding a child’s hand? > > Caressing a child’s cheek? > > Placing a hand on a child’s back? Head? Knee? Thigh? > > Sleeping with a child? > > > In what I’m sure will be a failed attempt at not being charged with > > projected titillation, I will not continue the above list for the > > obvious reasons. > > > This topic is associated with what, to me, is an unclear notion (child > > abuse) except perhaps in the most extreme cases. Example: In almost > > every instance of slavery and forced activity, I feel a confidence in > > applying the term. Of course, even here the notion of being ‘forced’ > > has extended and ever changing meanings. (Please note that I used the > > term ‘unclear’ meaning I see no agreement rather than an attempt at > > creating a black/white duality of good/bad, of extreme and not- > > extreme.) > > > To be clear here, I am quite serious with this line of inquiry. I deny > > using it to even suggest that it is something one should aspire to or > > even tacitly allow. Such accusations of being complicit and/or even an > > advocate are the stuff of historical inquisitions. Perhaps if one > > identifies with the associated pious clergy and/or lawgivers, this > > approach is acceptable. > > > Yes, while serious, I am at once being provocative in the sense of > > probing beliefs, incalcitrant and possibly cathected positions as well > > as looking for answers. I ask these questions of myself and am hard > > pressed to find cogent answers, even if/when couched in relativistic > > language. Note that I’m not using Reductio Ad Absurdum in most cases > > to help gain, at the very least, personal clarity. Further I do not > > expect immediate and simple answers to my questions. I merely wish to > > continue exploring the mores and memes of the moment, of the psyche > > and associated belief structures and emotional reasoning. > > > To me, the devil is in the above listed details. > > > On Oct 25, 2:29 pm, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > We did briefly have some idiot in using some old hat stuff about > > > Simbian (maybe Sambian - I forget easily these days) young male > > > homosexual stuff as a paedo excuse Slip. A perhaps inapt metaphor was > > > that he got the bum's rush. I've seen no attempt to excuse the > > > sickos, certainly not from Gruff (or Molly for that matter). Both on > > > the basis of the recent above are right. > > > > I am just reading up on how victims get rather generally accused of > > > being responsible for their own plight and how we 'find the victim' in > > > the perpetrator and a range of ethnographic research (tales might be > > > better) of the gutter. There is much one would want not to know that > > > one needs to know. We've just seen a young man (witness) give away > > > his £10,000 reward to a rape victim and sometimes one is in need of > > > such lovely gestures. The madness soon spoils, and now a teacher of > > > 62 is fined £1500 for physically removing a 13 year old racist from > > > class with a grip on belt and hoodie (am I supposed to turn myself in > > > for past crimes?). I'm with Gruff on the need to get much more of > > > this out into the open, yet whatever I feel on this I'm glad porn and > > > the rest are sort of shut away because I just don't want the stuff. I > > > also believe there is much we do know about perverse perpetrators > > > already and that it is possible to have discussion on the basis that > > > they are problematic and perverse. The current vogue of serial killer > > > detection lauds the perversity in my view and most of the genre is > > > mere pathetic invention. 30 years ago and more, one could get a pie, > > > pint, chips and a strip show in Manchester for what would be £5 > > > today. Objectivation with chips! I do not want erotic dancing with > > > my beef stew and note I can't get a decent beef stew. > > > The social contract in which we give up on individual impulses for > > > social gain has long been held a negative one for the individual > > > (Freud). I have been suckered by 'clever' shits who have got me into > > > all kinds of conversation - one has to go native to some point - and > > > it's always difficult to know what is fact and fantasy. There are > > > rumours of a very seedy and illegal sex club in Bolton, and there is a > > > reality of abuse and rings of it. We have wasted millions on a high > > > level, high profile policing failure instead of getting into the > > > 'real' (likely squalid, local, family connected). Bureaucratic > > > loonies waste money on all kinds of panics that should be seen > > > through. The real debate probably has more to do with this form of > > > perversion and its base. > > > > On 25 Oct, 17:23, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > Thanks, Slip, I guess my response to gruff above will also respond to > > > > your points here. > > > > > On Oct 25, 1:16 pm, Slip Disc <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > Not wanting to get in the middle of any fray here but would like to > > > > > point out that I don't remember anyone in ME representing pedophilia > > > > > as an acceptable behavior, historically or contemporized. > > > > > The mere mention of a historical fact serves in the informative sense > > > > > and doesn't warrant labeling or personal adherence to any group or > > > > > organization, no more than a biblical reference to the rainbow being > > > > > an expressed affiliation with a gay coalition. There are people that > > > > > are 'unaware' of historical events and not just those based on > > > > > sexuality. > > > > > I don't see that discussing sexual issues, whether lawful or not, > > > > > constitutes a platform for the voice of a criminal element. We should > > > > > be able to put all aspects of the issue in perspective in order to see > > > > > them for what they are and enable constructive discussion. > > > > > > On Oct 25, 7:25 am, Molly Brogan <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > > > Gruff the last time we had this go around your proposal of an open > > > > > > discussion of the topic of sex resulted in your espousing your ideas > > > > > > on the natural and beautiful aspects (in your opinion) of adults > > > > > > having sex with children. Very clever of you to suggest that I am a > > > > > > prude because I do not want to be a part of a discussion that gives > > > > > > pedophiles a platform to voice their "rights" as they are clearly > > > > > > blind to the true destructive nature of their crimes. Your > > > > > > statement > > > > > > that "the reality is that every year the number of children > > > > > > subjected > > > > > > to > > > > > > > > pedophile pastimes climbs higher and higher and more children are > > > > > > > hurt > > > > > > > and many times scarred for life as a result" > > > > > > > is a real departure from your views of our last discussion, so I > > > > > > will > > > > > > ask you directly, do you think that adults should be allowed to have > > > > > > sex with children? Your ideas in the above posts are ideas that > > > > > > pedophile rights groups use, along with: pedophilia has always been > > > > > > in > > > > > > human history; is not criminal in many cultures; it is a natural > > > > > > expression of love between adults and children etc,. These were also > > > > > > your views in the last discussion, and the basis of our > > > > > > disagreement. > > > > > > My suggestion that we do not use this ME to rationalize this > > > > > > criminal > > > > > > behavior is what lead to the > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
