(continuation of discussion with gruff from topic: "Her", Objectification.)
refute ▸ verb: prove to be false or incorrect ▸ verb: overthrow by argument, evidence, or proof “…You have implied that I am a part of a problem rather than of a solution…” – gruff Yes, I have and retain that view. So far I see no actual refutation of this view. “…You have implied that I am a tea bagger…” – gruff That was an extension to the previous comment, was hyperbolic association and an attempt at levity. This I had hoped to be clear with the use of the emoticon [ ;-) ] “…You have implied that I support fascism, totalitarianism and other (similar) ideologies…” – gruff If you read it that way, such an interpretation was not intended. My actual words were: “In the sense of the way Chomsky defines anarchy, I would say that I am proposing it as being a preferable stance than that of supporting and participating in fascism, totalitarianism and other ideologies.” I retain my stance. My guess is that you do lean toward these and other ideologies more than you lean towards Chomsky’s notion of anarchy or perhaps even the principle of universality. I don’t know for sure about the latter. What you write about Noam seems to support (be evidence for) my guess. Of course, you admit to not knowing his view(s) of anarchy, so the discussion breaks down from that point on. To help us discuss this more extensively, I ask that you read this short decade old interview with Noam about anarchy. I resonate with most of the views expressed therein. Then perhaps you could with more information provide evidence against his view(s). http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/19961223.htm “…You have implied that I do not wish to explore "the truth" which I take to mean your truth…” – gruff Well, the ‘truth’ in context included the following: “…that they are quite different”. Here we were talking about the terms ‘right’ and ‘power’. The confusion might be caused by my not having gone into detail enough. I will do my best to remedy that a bit now. I meant to imply that a ‘right’ is something innate and a ‘power’ is something granted. I used the Declaration of Independence to support this view. Specifically, the following excerpt, often quoted, seldom studied: “…We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed…” Note how the terms are differentiated in this context. A ‘right’ is assumed to be innate. A ‘power’ is something consented to. This is and was the totality of my truth of differentiation of the two terms in our current context. If you still disagree, I will await your evidence. “…You have implied that my logic and reason are not only false but childish and irrational..” – gruff You will have to provide evidence about the ‘childish and irrational’ part. I used the term ‘logic’. Again, in the context and given my understanding of the terms used as evidenced by the document quoted above, until evidence is provided, I stand by my contention that the terms are different and any attempt to exchange them *in this precise context* would not have the same meaning as was your contention. “…You have implied that I am naïve…” – gruff You will have to show evidence of this gruff. The one time I used the term ‘naïve’ I was applying it to my own thinking, not yours. “…You have implied that I do not know the simple definition of words…” – gruff Again, you will have to provide evidence for this argument. I have suggested that in specific circumstances, as mentioned above, two words have a specific and unique meaning when used in the specific context we are discussing. There was no generalized suggestion that you do not know “the simple definition of words”. I did also suggest that you falsely argued that appeasement meant the same thing as not keeping a standing army. So far I see no evidence to change this view. “…You have implied that I have conducted a "takeover" of the original theme of this post…” – gruff The original theme of the topic (not post) was and remains *”Her” Objectification*. We have gone far afield from any discussion associated with Slip’s first post: “The newest mustering of contempt for flagrant expressions of male perceptions concerning females as sexual objects opens yet another door to deeper insights into this age old dilemma within a era of modernist interpretations….” – SD QED “… And you have implied that I am in favor of force over agreement…” – gruff I do not accept that characterization without evidence. “…I contend that you have no basis for these contentions and that perhaps you are merely being a contrarian or an instigator…” gruff See above. “…That said, I will attempt to rebut much of what you say or at the very least explain my reason and logic more clearly for your edification. First and foremost, I am very much in favor of peace on earth. Yet however much we pay lip service to that phrase, there is no evidence whatsoever in our entire past nor in our contemporary world that such a condition is currently possible and with that lack of evidence or even inclination on the part of the world, recommending that we disband our military and lay down our arms seems to me just plain foolishness….” – gruff Gruff, I am very glad to hear that you are in favor of peace on earth or at least give lip service to the phrase. Maybe we could start a new topic on it since this is the first time the phrase has been used in this topic by either of us? Are you recommending that we ‘disband our military and lay down our arms’? I know I have not done so. “…As an aside and regards your criticism of my argument through asking questions, was this not the highly regarded method used by Socrates?...” – gruff The fallacy of argumentation: http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#question nor the fallacy of the rhetorical question: http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#rhetorical_question have anything to do with representations of Socrates’ methodology except perhaps for the question mark. In the current context, I mean more precisely to point out that you are not doing either: 1) making a clear argument nor 2) asking a Socratic question. I contend that your answers are more along the line of rhetorical questioning as the link above addresses and that they are leading a person *who has not nor is apt to agreed with your contention* to your point of view. I will add that it is my opinion that when you asked: “Isn't that as much a form of status discrimination as any caste system? What if you wanted to live in east LA, or Oakland, or Chinatown? Wouldn't you feel set upon by foolish and irrational prejudices?” – gruff …these questions could be interpreted as being Socratic in nature. However, when you directly asked me: “Do you really think we'd still be here had we de-militarized at any time during the Cold War? Do you really think that we'd have gone unscathed had we de-militarized at any other time since?” – gruff …I found the questions to be disingenuous in the sense that they at once included your answer in them and little room for an opposing view and that they to me implied that I was suggesting the very things you were asking me to defend. In this case, one of the fallacies associated with methodology is the fallacy of changing the subject: http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#digression I find this tactic annoying at best. “…It also works very well in the practice of law…” – gruff Uhh, in the context of law, I’m not sure what you mean by ‘works very well’. In fact, IF you are contending that ‘it’, the use of questions, works well in our interaction too, I will say that they might. It would depend on many factors. One of which is what the goal is of the one posing the question. If it is to misdirect, yes, such use of questions can ‘work well’. IF it is to expand the understanding of those in discourse, as Socrates did, it can work well too. Again, this is the case only if the question is well intended, open ended to some extent and not meant as a means to unduly persuade or misdirect. Regardless, I prefer open and honest discussion to legalistic machinations. I also use questions to learn and seldom if ever to obfuscate or misdirect. “You confirm that “…Laws are the glue that holds society together and allow us to live with each other in reasonable certainty of making it to tomorrow…” is true, then ask what my point is and state that it has nothing to do with rights and freedoms. Let me point out that every law, every rule, every regulation is a limitation on individual and societal freedom and rights and without such limitations we would have chaotic anarchy.” – gruff Here I was echoing your use of the two terms ‘rights and freedoms’ which you attribute to Ben Franklin, a direct correlation I had not made. Perhaps you were not implying that I had. Regardless, in the current context, I was addressing the earlier point about motor cycle helmets. My intention was to point out that there was more freedom if there was NO law about using a helmet. One would have the freedom to either wear one or not wear one. Your response to this argument was a non sequitur. It also was the fallacy of generalization: http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#generalize …thus my albeit ironic question about what your point was. IF you wish to refute my specific argument about motorcycle helmet use, please do so. If not, OK. “… I have no idea how Chomsky defines anarchy but I do know he declares himself to be an adherent of libertarian socialism. Socialism requires extensive laws, rules and regulations. Where is the freedom and anarchy in that?...” gruff The short interview I presented above goes into both of these points. I do not wish to be an apologist for Noam thus let his words speak for him. I find that your misunderstanding of the use of the term ‘anarchy’ in this context has led to unwarranted assumptions and rhetorical questions. “…Human beings are excellent practitioners of the seven deadly sins and without laws, rules and regulations (i.e., anarchy) we'd be at each others throats with every weapon we could find at hand…” – gruff I have covered the term anarchy above. And, this is an assertion and not a refutation nor is there any evidence provided. “…Chomsky believes that science is a good way to understanding history and social affairs and goes on to say that science is a way of learning what argument means, what evidence means and what makes sense to postulate as well as what is going to be convincing. I've always been quite open to being convinced of something through argument and evidence but I've yet to see either one in the postings you've made, and I do believe I have a fairly firm grip on both argument and evidence since both were tools of my profession for many years…” - gruff I guess I missed reading about this aspect of Noam. Would you please provide a reference so I can learn more about it? Thanks. After I read it, I will be informed enough to know how to respond intelligently. I will say that when you say that you have seen neither argument nor evidence from me, I am perplexed. Please let me know if you are using Noam’s notions of the terms or not. If not, since you seem to be asking for both, I would like to be able to oblige with whatever your standards are. Normally, I prefer discussion and not argumentation as you may know. However, since argument and evidence is strongly suggested by this group’s set of standards, I do my best to oblige when requested. In this case, when we both appear to be discussing our opinions and seem to be talking past each other a lot, some clarity in how to proceed with you would be welcome indeed! I have no doubt that you have experience here yet question your intention(s) and goals in our discussion. IF you only wish to ‘win’ the ‘debate’, you may. IF you wish to influence, so far little has been the result. I wish to share my thinking, present things as I see them…see if we can find agreement somewhere…perhaps help to learn from each other etc. What do you expect? So far, since Chris likes using them, I’ve been peppering commentary with a few fallacies where I believe they apply. Perhaps this is not appropriate for the type of intercourse you are looking for? “…Orn, probably much to your displeasure, Chomsky does not present an end-all, be-all solution to the world's problems. He has been challenged quite successfully by many notable thinkers, among which are as Jean Piaget, Michel Foucault, William F. Buckley, Jr., Christopher Hitchens, Richard Perle, Hilary Putnam, and Alan Dershowitz. Chomsky believes in justified power yet feels that any wage earner is a mere slave and that workers should own and control their own workplace, which does nothing to reduce his contention that earning a wage is slavery whether the slave owns the business or not…” – gruff Uhhh, IF you are suggesting that I hold anything like a belief that Noam “presents an end-all, be-all solution to the world’s problems’, nothing is further from the case. IF you read the one link I posted here about his views on anarchy, you will see his own words of what he believes he can provide. I saw nothing of this type of claim at all. In fact, I saw him be more humble and incapable in such an endeavor than either you or I appear to be! While I have read a couple of the challenges you mention, I wasn’t impressed so far. If by appealing to authority you believe you can influence, it doesn’t work for me in this case…especially without specifics. The people you mention are bright. Their arguments are complex. That is about it. Your reasoning about wages and slavery would need to include references for me to know how to respond to no evidence. Even so, on the face of it, I just don’t get your claim. Sorry, I really do wish and hope we can at least communicate clearly here. “…Chomsky has made some partially valid criticisms of society including his indictment that the mass media is largely propaganda but fails to mention anything about an educated populace being able to sift through that propaganda to discern truth, and that there are also some media which work very hard to present a balanced and honest portrait of various aspects of the world. I offer The Christian Science Monitor as but one example. Another favorite of mine is The Financial Times…” gruff We do agree with his criticisms about the media being largely propaganda. I have found that his observations about things like 9/11 and the Middle East to be quite cogent too. I guess you have ceased your refutation here unless by suggesting that Chomsky should focus on an ‘educated populace’ and should mention a few media you appreciate you believe that you have made some point about him. First, I have not read his 100+ books so do not know the veracity of what you suggest he has omitted being the case. I wonder if you have. So, without direct evidence here, I will just wait for more information. “…Chomsky has claimed that the United States remains the greatest country in the world then turns around and contradicts himself by saying that such evaluations are senseless…” – gruff Where are you getting this stuff? “…He is an avowed anti-war activist but then claims that WWII was justified…” – gruff First, I don’t remember reading the latter although it may be the case. I just don’t know. Perhaps you can provide quotations? However, in either case, I see no contradiction where you seem to see one. Perhaps this is just a good example of an ambiguous assertion? “…He is anti- capitalism and and avowed unionist, the latter part of which has been the cause of many of this nations jobs moving to other countries. Unions have raised the cost of labor so high that it is impossible for heavily unionized companies from making a profit….” – gruff Is there a point here about Chomsky? Is this an attempt at a refutation? Perhaps it is just a claim you are making. We have gone around and around in the past about such things with little success at either agreement or in my view even understanding. Perhaps this is a failure to state? I do know that the subject is much more complex than that which you present. Is this a purposeful debate tactic of yours? To me there are too many fallacies to even take what may be just your opinion seriously. I do agree that unions have worked historically to attempt at helping to assure a living wage for their members among other things. I do know that prior to unions in the US, working conditions sucked big time here. I do know that today there are precious few unions left. I do know that unions did not ask for multinationals to give jobs to those in other countries. Personally, I find a few issues here of interest including: the discussion and work on environmental issues in most other countries are all but non- existent. As a result, the costs here to help keep the planet inhabitable are higher than where there are few or even no such provisions. I will assume that you are not suggesting that ‘we’ (USA) dismantle environmental protections. I do know that most other countries in the above context allow child labor and in general treat the workers as slaves. If you are suggesting that this is either acceptable or even worse, is preferable, we do disagree. If anything, unions should be a global thing and should return to prominence and power here in the USA. And, we both know what good ‘shoulds’ do! Hehe Oh, as an aside, the choices are not as simple as unionization/ profitable. There is no evidence of this and some for the opposite. And, my personal view is that corporations in general are anathema to humanity. You didn’t mention corporations, so I won’t assume you meant that stock holders should have preference over those who actually do the production. “…Years ago I began advising investors I knew to avoid putting their money into companies that were so unionized because they would eventually go bankrupt…” – gruff OK. Out of date, but OK. “…Chomsky is a radical socialist claiming libertarian principles which do not comport with much of what he says…” – gruff I will await the quotations. The link I provided above, using mostly his words clarifies and refutes your claim. “…He claims status in the left wing of U.S. politics yet many of his critics are liberal and progressive and he gives solid foundation to all conservative critics….” – gruff Again, I will await the evidence of his claims. What I have read of Chomsky goes much deeper when it comes to right/left, the meanings of which are not single issue nor engraved in stone. In fact, they have interchanged somewhat over the years and more than once. We are both old enough to know this. I don’t understand if/what your assertion is about his critics. IF you are saying that people of different political views have disagreements with Noam, I wouldn’t expect otherwise. If you are claiming more, you need to do so. “…My personal opinion is that he should stay in his initially chosen field of linguistics in which he has received the majority of his accolades and stay out of politics….” – gruff Noted. I disagree and would guess, based on his popularity when it comes to speaking in public about all types of things there are many others who disagree too. His topics are not limited to politics although he is much appreciated there because of his vast recall and in my view ability to have a bigger picture of situations than almost anyone I know of in this context. Also, he speaks truths and about facts that are not found in most venues. Personally, I haven’t had the inclination to read even the one book he recommended to me about linguistics yet…maybe before I die, maybe not. “… I think you make a huge and incorrect leap of logic when you say that by my interchanging the words power and rights "(you) could interchange any words at all and it would have the same meaning." That statement makes no sense on its face within the meaning of the Constitution….” – gruff I recognize your claim gruff. While it was a bit of the hyperbole, I did so intentionally to make my point. Apparently I failed in your case. “… I never said that Chamberlain was evil….” – gruff Nor did I gruff. “… All I said was that his plan of appeasement was ill thought and clearly didn't work…” – gruff Perhaps we agree here about it not ‘working’ in the obvious sense. “…Nor does appeasement equate with not keeping a standing army….” – gruff Good, I’m glad you agree with this criticism I voiced about your earlier post. “…In the case of Chamberlain it meant giving Poland as a gift to Hitler with the hope that he wouldn't go any further. Of course I wasn't there but in hindsight it seems pure lunacy….” – gruff Well, again your opinion is noted. I’m not that well versed in this historical act, but it seems that the act of appeasement ("the policy of settling international quarrels by admitting and satisfying grievances through rational negotiation and compromise, thereby avoiding the resort to an armed conflict which would be expensive, bloody, and possibly dangerous.") has its merits. And, it seems that the debate about whether he even had a choice or not continues. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeasement “…Nor am I forgiving the ills and abuses of the military industrial complex but that does not mean I am in favor of eliminating them either…” – gruff Ambiguous assertion. Sorry. “…I do agree with you that if there were NO militaries in existence there would likely be no wars…” – gruff Cool! “…But the fact is that virtually every nation on earth has a standing military as do many corporations (i.e., security and mercenary forces) and until such time as they all disbanded none should disband…” – gruff Interesting position. I am reminded of a bit of humor in the Readers Digest from at least 40 years ago that is an analogy. I now forget the name of the section, sorry. However, it related one of those still on the book absurd laws that someone recently dug up. In this case, it was about a State law from the 1800s that said that when two trains come to a crossing (like an X), both trains must wait until the other goes by!!! Mexican standoff doesn’t even hold a candle to this view. “…It also seems ill-informed to say that if we are not under direct attack that we are at peace…” – gruff In the context of having a standing army, the topic and point being discussed, it was germane and in my view, not at all as you claim. “…I have noted several examples of this in previous posts and will not burden you with a repetition of them…” – gruff Ambiguous assertion… “…Nor do I find much value or substance in your contention that peace reigns when one "side" has been disarmed. All that means is that they are under the power and control of the side that has not disarmed…” – gruff Uhhh, in the context of the peace vs war dichotomy we were discussing, there was no other option given. If you wish to now insert some, by all means do. Otherwise, I stand by my assertion. “…Of course agreement is preferable to force, but until such time as we have such agreement, a standing, trained and armed military is the preferable stance… It certainly isn't laying down our arms and armies unilaterally and without achieving agreement.” – gruff I am very glad that we have another point of agreement…that about agreement being preferable to force. And, having said this, your addition of what appears to be a false choice (if no agreement, the only options are laying down arms and having a standing military) is unpersuasive. There are many other options. I will assume that you can think of a few by yourself. Also, there are countless little agreements that occur all of the time. Somehow these need to be factored in. I’m not sure I know how, but I think they should be at least looked at. A philosophical observation here is that there are constant cycles of agreement and using force. This reality, along with any arguments to the future being fallacious, shed yet another light on the subject. Rather than continuing to talk past each other, shall we take smaller bites, a little breath and discuss things point by point? Say, do you agree that the fact that we had a standing army on 9/11 did not prevent it from happening? Did you read either of my posts about the Declaration of Independence? If so, do you see how the terms ‘rights’ and ‘power’ are differentiated? Overall, I know this was a long post and a mixed bag. I also believe that most ‘arguments’ here on Mind’s Eye include fallacies, mine included. So, for me, just using any such ‘rules’ of debate are not very interesting. Although, I must admit to some enjoyment in providing Chris with a little entertainment! :- ) My historical experience with such back and forth with you gruff is that it can all too easily lead to misunderstanding and even worse. So, again, I would appreciate knowing how or even IF you wish to proceed. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
