*** chuckles @ “The key is to find what minimal structures would ensure a nonetheless democratic and regulated form of life that inspires peace, creativity and satisfying, shared work and responsibility as far as possible.” ***
;-) ;-) ;-) On Nov 1, 9:44 am, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > In my view, Chomsky doesn't do much other than point to a form of > anarchy. This is old hat, if welcome. The key is to find what > minimal structures would ensure a nonetheless democratic and regulated > form of life that inspires peace, creativity and satisfying, shared > work and responsibility as far as possible. The problem with most > discussion in here is that most don't recognise what follows or is > implied in their positions. The deeper problematic, of course, is > that there are 'rules of argument' and varying abilities in it (or > rather various forms of it). More understanding of this needs to be > established, yet how do we do that without some arbiter becoming the > problem - or even the new Fuhrer. Also concealed in much we do are > the rules of mannered society (Norbert Elias) and the gatekeepers of > public air time. Frankly, we can't even lay out the argument and > start looking for evidence, theoretical help and so on - here > personal deceptions about our beliefs and experience are severely > limiting. > It is easy enough to hide snide ad hominem behind assertions to argue > objectively - I've just seen our Home Secretary make an utter arse of > himself trying to say he sacked out drug's advisor over his behaviour > (at a time when all politicians are failing to address their own > thieving and lack of ability), when all the guy has done is be > truthful and reasonably scientific. I can only say we are very bad at > it in here (as most of my students remain, even after three years) - > but then we would be in such a short format. I'd like to see more > reasoned dialogue in here, but there are many other ways to take what > we do. In the end, I prefer the odd smile, jibe, swipe and laugh. We > miss something about being able to share in disagreement, perhaps > whilst thinking 'what the ****' even with the gun lobby - and what can > be done in wit and debunking the over-serious. > > On 1 Nov, 10:59, ornamentalmind <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > (continuation of discussion with gruff from topic: "Her", > > Objectification.) > > > refute > > > ▸ verb: prove to be false or incorrect > > ▸ verb: overthrow by argument, evidence, or proof > > > “…You have implied that I am a part of a problem rather than of a > > solution…” – gruff > > > Yes, I have and retain that view. So far I see no actual refutation of > > this view. > > > “…You have implied that I am a tea bagger…” – gruff > > > That was an extension to the previous comment, was hyperbolic > > association and an attempt at levity. This I had hoped to be clear > > with the use of the emoticon [ ;-) ] > > > “…You have implied that I support fascism, totalitarianism and other > > (similar) ideologies…” – gruff > > > If you read it that way, such an interpretation was not intended. My > > actual words were: “In the sense of the way Chomsky defines anarchy, I > > would say that I am proposing it as being a preferable stance than > > that of supporting and participating in fascism, totalitarianism and > > other ideologies.” I retain my stance. > > > My guess is that you do lean toward these and other ideologies more > > than you lean towards Chomsky’s notion of anarchy or perhaps even the > > principle of universality. I don’t know for sure about the latter. > > What you write about Noam seems to support (be evidence for) my guess. > > Of course, you admit to not knowing his view(s) of anarchy, so the > > discussion breaks down from that point on. To help us discuss this > > more extensively, I ask that you read this short decade old interview > > with Noam about anarchy. I resonate with most of the views expressed > > therein. Then perhaps you could with more information provide evidence > > against his view(s).http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/19961223.htm > > > “…You have implied that I do not wish to explore "the truth" which I > > take to mean your truth…” – gruff > > > Well, the ‘truth’ in context included the following: “…that they are > > quite different”. Here we were talking about the terms ‘right’ and > > ‘power’. The confusion might be caused by my not having gone into > > detail enough. I will do my best to remedy that a bit now. I meant to > > imply that a ‘right’ is something innate and a ‘power’ is something > > granted. I used the Declaration of Independence to support this view. > > Specifically, the following excerpt, often quoted, seldom studied: > > > “…We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created > > equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable > > rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of > > happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted > > among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the > > governed…” > > > Note how the terms are differentiated in this context. A ‘right’ is > > assumed to be innate. A ‘power’ is something consented to. This is and > > was the totality of my truth of differentiation of the two terms in > > our current context. If you still disagree, I will await your > > evidence. > > > “…You have implied that my logic and reason are not only false but > > childish and irrational..” – gruff > > > You will have to provide evidence about the ‘childish and irrational’ > > part. I used the term ‘logic’. Again, in the context and given my > > understanding of the terms used as evidenced by the document quoted > > above, until evidence is provided, I stand by my contention that the > > terms are different and any attempt to exchange them *in this precise > > context* would not have the same meaning as was your contention. > > > “…You have implied that I am naïve…” – gruff > > > You will have to show evidence of this gruff. The one time I used the > > term ‘naïve’ I was applying it to my own thinking, not yours. > > > “…You have implied that I do not know the simple definition of words…” > > – gruff > > > Again, you will have to provide evidence for this argument. I have > > suggested that in specific circumstances, as mentioned above, two > > words have a specific and unique meaning when used in the specific > > context we are discussing. There was no generalized suggestion that > > you do not know “the simple definition of words”. I did also suggest > > that you falsely argued that appeasement meant the same thing as not > > keeping a standing army. So far I see no evidence to change this view. > > > “…You have implied that I have conducted a "takeover" of the original > > theme of this post…” – gruff > > > The original theme of the topic (not post) was and remains *”Her” > > Objectification*. We have gone far afield from any discussion > > associated with Slip’s first post: > > “The newest mustering of contempt for flagrant expressions of male > > perceptions concerning females as sexual objects opens yet another > > door to deeper insights into this age old dilemma within a era of > > modernist interpretations….” – SD > > > QED > > > “… And you have implied that I am in favor of force over agreement…” – > > gruff > > > I do not accept that characterization without evidence. > > > “…I contend that you have no basis for these contentions and that > > perhaps you are merely being a contrarian or an instigator…” gruff > > > See above. > > > “…That said, I will attempt to rebut much of what you say or at the > > very least explain my reason and logic more clearly for your > > edification. First and foremost, I am very much in favor of peace on > > earth. Yet > > however much we pay lip service to that phrase, there is no evidence > > whatsoever in our entire past nor in our contemporary world that such > > a condition is currently possible and with that lack of evidence or > > even inclination on the part of the world, recommending that we > > disband our military and lay down our arms seems to me just plain > > foolishness….” – gruff > > > Gruff, I am very glad to hear that you are in favor of peace on earth > > or at least give lip service to the phrase. Maybe we could start a new > > topic on it since this is the first time the phrase has been used in > > this topic by either of us? > > > Are you recommending that we ‘disband our military and lay down our > > arms’? I know I have not done so. > > > “…As an aside and regards your criticism of my argument through asking > > questions, was this not the highly regarded method used by > > Socrates?...” – gruff > > > The fallacy of argumentation: > > >http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#question > > > nor the fallacy of the rhetorical > > question:http://www.don-lindsay-archive.org/skeptic/arguments.html#rhetorical_... > > > have anything to do with representations of Socrates’ methodology > > except perhaps for the question mark. > > > In the current context, I mean more precisely to point out that you > > are not doing either: 1) making a clear argument nor 2) asking a > > Socratic question. I contend that your answers are more along the line > > of rhetorical questioning as the link above addresses and that they > > are leading a person *who has not nor is apt to agreed with your > > contention* to your point of view. > > > I will add that it is my opinion that when you asked: > > > “Isn't that as much a form of status discrimination as any caste > > system? What if you wanted to live in east LA, or Oakland, or > > Chinatown? Wouldn't you feel set upon by foolish and irrational > > prejudices?” – gruff > > > …these questions could be interpreted as being Socratic in nature. > > > However, when you directly asked me: > > > “Do you really think we'd still be here had we de-militarized at any > > time during the Cold War? Do you really think that we'd have gone > > unscathed had we de-militarized at any other time since?” – gruff > > > …I found the questions to be disingenuous in the sense that they at > > ... > > read more »- Hide quoted text - > > - Show quoted text - --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
