*** sometimes I really miss Chaz, he was good - if often too ascerbic - at taking up stuff like this ***
Manfranco, you have invited comment from "learned religious people" on your thinking with regard to the book of Genesis. While I no longer describe myself as "religious", I did spend six years studying theology (in a Catholic context), so I suppose that does qualify me to be described as somewhat "learned." It seems to me that you have a major methodological problem. You put forward the thesis that the description of the historical course of events in the Book of Genesis is not always accurate. Good for you! This openness to the possiblility that not everything the Bible contains is literally true, however, presents you with a major problem; what criterea are you going to use to distinguish between what is historically reliable and what is not? One approach would be to look for other, independent sources describing the same events as those described in the bible, at best, sources which contain eyewitness reports. For the historical course of events following the "Flood" there are no such sources. What do exist are many different flood legends from the Fertile Crescent area (and further afield in the ancient world, including Greece, China and India) - e.g. the Babylonian Gilgamesh story or the reference in the Indian tradition to the Dravidan king, Manu, who, guided by Matsya, the avatar of Vishnu, survived a global flood. For peoples who had recently left the hunter-gatherer form of life and taken up a sedentary existence, based on cultivation and husbandry, any kind of flooding was a cataclysmic event, leading as it did to the destruction of crops and domestic animals with consequent high human mortality. That such events would become the subject of stories in all these different cultures, developing with the telling over the years to major myths and legends is completely understandable. The problems for us begin when we try to work back from such legends and myths to the particular historical kernels which gave rise to them. One thing is, however, clear - we cannot prima facie take any of the details in these mythological accounts as historically accurate. On this basis, all the stories in Genesis must be seen as completely mythological, since there are no accounts of the particular events described in any other (independent) sources. Indeed, I can historically expand this statement to cover the whole Pentateuch, including the Abraham, Jacob, Joseph and Moses cycles. (The Qur'an does contain traditions concerning Abraham [Ibrahim] and his first- born son, Ishmael [from whom Muhammed is descended], which may have an alternative tradition leading back to a common origin in stories told by various Semitic nomadic groups). The first biblical historical references with independent source confirmation refer to the "House of David" around the middle of the 9th. Century B.C.E. ( ביתדוד - the Tel Dan Stele, proclaiming the military prowess of a king of Damascus). Manfranco, your basic problem, however, remains. If major parts of the bible are not historically true, at the very least in all the details described, what criterea of truth do you apply to the bible? Or is it, as frequently seems to me, a smorgasbord, from which various Christian believers and groups pick and choose according to their subjective taste? This they are perfectly entitled to do, but they should not then complain if their arguments are rejected as irrational and frivolous by those who apply more stringent terms with regards to claims referrring to historical truth and accuracy. Francis On 3 Nov., 03:17, Manfraco Frank the Elder <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Pat and members of Minds Eye group! > Pat I agree with you that The Tower of Babel may very well represent > our own consciousness, which at times seems to be confused; so, the > writer of The Tower of Babel must have been aware of that, therefore, > he followed by saying that God confounded the languages, so that > people would not be able to group together and try to challenge Him. > But one has to keep in mind that religious books are written for the > sole purpose of making people believe what the writer himself believes > what else can a religious leader do? > Now if one reads religious books properly, soon or later one becomes > aware that in some cases they have not been written properly, because > sometimes they might not agree within themselves. > One of these faults may happen when they talk about the time that has > elapsed between events, of perhaps something else. I am talking about > this because I have noted it myself recently. This does not imply that > the religious book in question that one is reading is false, it only > means that the writer wasn’t aware when he wrote the book that those > dates or number of years mentioned in their writings would not had up > correctly. > Therefore some religious books are long overdue to be explained, why > they have been written the way that they have been written, and could > not be corrected in the past, but they can only be explained for > future readers. So I am going to try to do some explaining myself. > But since I am writing and most likely I will make some mistakes; if > ever my writings were to be published: Hereby I invite the future > learned religious people of the world to set things right. And above > all I invite them to criticise and straighten any of my mistakes, and > try to improve my own ideas wherever they need to be improved. > Just because some members of the group still seem to believe > completely what is written in the Bible, I would like to show them the > following, which has led me to believe that the writer of Genesis did > not have the knowledge of the time that actually had past between > these events. And it seems to me that, he is only writing the story as > it has been told from generation to generation; so, it follows that > the Bible needs to be read and compared with the events of those > times. For instance: > In The Patriarch, after the flood, the writer is writing a story the > way that it has been told from generation to generation. But here > somehow it becomes too obvious to an observant reader, that the > numbers of years mentioned don’t add up at all, because the number of > years and the generations that the writer mentions, are not enough to > achieve the regrowth of the population, and the events that happened > during that mentioned frame time. So if the reader takes tame to work > it out for himself, he would become aware that there must be quite a > few generations missed out, it also contradicts other length of time, > and here I would like to write everything down to show you what I > mean. > Just to make it a little bit easier to calculate, it would be helpful > to take, The Flood, as year zero, and then one could calculate the > years that have past since the flood according to the writer list of > The Patriarchs. So the following is how it could be worked out. > > Start counting from, The Flood, taken as year > zero. 0 > Shem descendants, only the first born would be written in here: > Shem, became the father of Arpachshad two years after the > flood; 2 > Arpachshad, became the father of Shelah, when he was 35 years > old; 35 > Shelah, became the father of Eber, when he was 30 years > old; 30 > Eber, became the father of Peleg, when he was 34 years > old; 34 > Peleg, became the father of Reu, when he was 30 years > old; 30 > Reu, became the father of Serug when he was 32 years > old; 32 > Serug, became the father of Nahor, when he was 30 years > old; 30 > Nahor, became the father of Terah, when he was 29 years > old; 29 > Terah, became the father of Abraham, when he was 70 years > old; 70 > So, if we calculate the number of years past according to this list, > from the > Flood to the birth of Abraham there are only 292 years accounted for. > Abraham lived for one hundred and seventy five years then he > died. 175 > Therefore, Abraham died 467 years after the flood according to this > list. > It is written in the Bible that Noah lived 350 years after the flood, > and Shem, the son of Noah lived 500 years after the birth of > Arpachshad, So that means that he lived 502 after the flood, then both > Noah and Arpachshad should have been still alive at the time of > Abraham if the list above were to be correct. In fact if everything in > the list was correct: Shem, the son of Noah would have been outliving > Abraham by 35 years, and that seems highly impossible. > Now we have also to take into account the growth of the population > that had tried to build the tower of Babel during that time, which is > after the flood and well before the birth of Abraham, therefore 292 > years as I have worked it from the list above, could not be enough > time for the population to grow that much and try to build the tower > ob Babel. There is also the fact that they could not even think of > building the tower of Babel so soon after the flood, while Noah and > Shem were still living, because they could see what the people were > doing and would certainly forbid them to do that, since they would > have known that it would anger Yahweh. Therefore they would certainly > forbid the building of the tower, and their offspring would listen to > them, since they knew that Noah and Shem had seen the power of God > during the flood. Therefore the building of the tower of Babel must > have happened at least a few generations after Noah and Shem died. > By taking in consideration what I have said above, I reckon that there > is at least one thousand years, and perhaps up to two thousand years > not accounted for, in the list of the Patriarchs as shown above. > Of course the writer of Genesis never intended that the list above be > understood as I do now, it may be that he wrote the story as it was > told by his ancestors, or perhaps he wrote a longer list of the > Patriarchs that got lost and nobody knows how to find it now. > Not withstanding what I have said above, we have to take in > consideration that when the book of Genesis was first written, the > writer had to overcome lots of limitations that were present at those > times. The very first limitation was that there were no other > religious books before this one; there wasn’t enough writing material > to write on; there were only a few people that were able to write. > Almost everything in those times was past through words of mouth from > generation to generation, therefore when happenings were too old or > too many to remember people just started to forget them; and I am sure > that there were even more limitations that I have been able to > mention, so many that one would never been able to think of the many > limitations of those times. > Therefore the writer of Genesis did a real great job, if one considers > all the possible limitations that were against him. And the book of > Genesis is as good as could have been written at that time, the value > of the book stands high because one has to read it as if it is correct > for religious purposes. > Now just a few words about the 666 seat for the antichrist, as I have > shown you that the Bible can be flawed it the story above, it can also > be flawed in Revelation, so we better don’t count on it. > I apologise for my post being too long, so I better stop now. > My regards to you all > Manfraco. > > On Oct 30, 11:57 pm, Pat <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > I just thought I'd pass this along as something to cogitate. > > > It came to me yesterday that there's an important lesson in that > > old story in Genesis about the Tower of Babel (the structure that > > tried to reach God). The structure that truly reaches God is not a 4- > > D space-time structure like said Tower, but the internal structures of > > feelings and knowledge (structures of consciousness!), which, to be > > understood by oneself, requires no language--just feelings and > > thoughts. Thus the confounding of language being the 'result' of the > > 'inevitably doomed to failure' attempt at building a physical tower > > that would reach God. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
