I will miss you in some huge way, Neil, and coincidentally, I too will be more off than on as I meet my year end deadlines and explore opportunities on both coasts. I have noticed other members have dropped off considerably and already miss their views. Somehow, the babel is louder without them.
On Nov 3, 9:32 pm, archytas <[email protected]> wrote: > Indeed Francis, I miss the lad too. In fact, it's time for me to give > the group a miss for the time being. Too busy really, or at least I > need to be! I shall have to miss Francis' priestly ways for a while. > I shared an office with a seminary survivor for ten years, a rather > brutish man if compared with Francis, until you were allowed > underneath. I think this kind of religious stuff does great harm and > makes many much more vulnerable then need be. I was taught at school > that Shakespeare was an accurate historian and a variety of piffle > such as Britain being invaded by Julius Caesar in 53BC. I could once > list all the Kings and Queens of England since Athlestan, but now only > remember who beat that worthless rubbish into me. Holy texts, > including much considered fit to teach in schools and universities on > non-religious subjects with their own 'holy texts', are equally > unreliable and often disgusting (Numbers 31 is squalid, but fairly > typical of non-Xtian religions too - 'holy' management texts often > proceed as though people don't matter). > We lack something religious in terms of fellowship, assurance of > mutual support and spiritual well-being based on a fair and supportive > environment. This lack is great enough for major exploitation. Where > religion was banned like alcohol in the Prohibition, it survived, > often as some relief from greater tyranny. I'm not sure how it works > now, or on what, though I often see it involved with yet another path > to Establishment war. Having once found myself in a shooting match > between denominations I am less tolerant than Francis of this dreck. > The Bible isn't accurate, certainly isn't novel and denies many the > opportunity to question properly and form critical judgement as it is > used by churches that know how false it is. There are some stories in > it worth telling, but too many of them are actually about who is the > smarter arse. > On floods, India and Bangladesh have them as a matter of routine. with > many dying and/or displaced as a matter of course. The floods bring > the fertile silt on which much agricultural production relies. The > Earth once had very little land mass, with temperatures at 16 degrees > centigrade at the poles. There is no eoscene script to tell of > this. 10,000 years ago the sahara was not dry and the world a very > different place. Science is establishing this. Religion in terms of > the Bible-bashers is nothing less than the denial of proper enquiry > and all over the world is being misused for purposes of control. I'd > contend we have even allowed higher education to slip into this mire > through the new religion of managerialism - something that does not > seem 'new' at all when one considers the use of religion in social > control. > We live amongst symbolism and aesthetic judgement. Science should > admit to this more openly, and one can study our organisations in this > way. We need messages of peace and what peace entails. Religions are > far too stuck in the lies of tradition and the interests of their own > elites. The message from science is far too bleak for most and we > should be doing much more to ensure decent living standards, regular > fellowship and considered democracy. I'd take the guess that we > provide this in the west until secondary education and after this fail > almost entirely. > > In Ireland, two sides (it's more complex) each based views in chronic > trash - the rabid Protestantism of this country beggars belief. The > matter is not settled, with the formerly marxist-leninist Provos now > considered a sell out by the enlarging Real and Continuity IRA. More > than 30 years were wasted and quite a few died and many lived under > terror and gangsters. What we need is religion that sorts out such > nonsense, not takes sides in it. One cannot tell whether Crusade pre- > dates Jihad - only that both are equally vapid and revered on > different sides. To give up on the truth of history seems to give up > on getting to the roots of problems and moving into a modern world > free of the easy lunacy of whipped-up hatred and 'foreign policy'. > I'm not sure one can be as tolerant as Francis here, though one wants > anyone to be free to think and have religious freedom - but what do we > do when those who deny evidence become zealots, think of themselves as > the holy elite and start to bomb even their own, treat all others as > unworthy? The answers are not in scripture and fundamentalist > attitudes to text and they can't lie in a science that communicates > only to around 1% of those lucky enough to get an education. Yet the > danger of using simple stories is clear - people can pick the wrong > ones. What I find sad is that many are trained to know a least some > of the truth and don't pass this on at all, but rather hide it. The > Roman Catholic Church even gave us a false history of the great Roman > Empire - in fact the Barbarians were often much finer people than the > Romans. > The lack of a real religion based on true history and prepared to > explain its symbolism and rituals, active in our communities across > the world is sad even to an atheist like me. Not quite Chaz, but > here's to his memory. I'm off where I can do some good for a while. > > On 3 Nov, 09:21, frantheman <[email protected]> wrote: > > > *** sometimes I really miss Chaz, he was good - if often too ascerbic > > - at taking up stuff like this *** > > > Manfranco, you have invited comment from "learned religious people" on > > your thinking with regard to the book of Genesis. While I no longer > > describe myself as "religious", I did spend six years studying > > theology (in a Catholic context), so I suppose that does qualify me to > > be described as somewhat "learned." > > > It seems to me that you have a major methodological problem. You put > > forward the thesis that the description of the historical course of > > events in the Book of Genesis is not always accurate. Good for you! > > This openness to the possiblility that not everything the Bible > > contains is literally true, however, presents you with a major > > problem; what criterea are you going to use to distinguish between > > what is historically reliable and what is not? One approach would be > > to look for other, independent sources describing the same events as > > those described in the bible, at best, sources which contain > > eyewitness reports. For the historical course of events following the > > "Flood" there are no such sources. What do exist are many different > > flood legends from the Fertile Crescent area (and further afield in > > the ancient world, including Greece, China and India) - e.g. the > > Babylonian Gilgamesh story or the reference in the Indian tradition to > > the Dravidan king, Manu, who, guided by Matsya, the avatar of Vishnu, > > survived a global flood. > > > For peoples who had recently left the hunter-gatherer form of life and > > taken up a sedentary existence, based on cultivation and husbandry, > > any kind of flooding was a cataclysmic event, leading as it did to the > > destruction of crops and domestic animals with consequent high human > > mortality. That such events would become the subject of stories in all > > these different cultures, developing with the telling over the years > > to major myths and legends is completely understandable. The problems > > for us begin when we try to work back from such legends and myths to > > the particular historical kernels which gave rise to them. One thing > > is, however, clear - we cannot prima facie take any of the details in > > these mythological accounts as historically accurate. > > > On this basis, all the stories in Genesis must be seen as completely > > mythological, since there are no accounts of the particular events > > described in any other (independent) sources. Indeed, I can > > historically expand this statement to cover the whole Pentateuch, > > including the Abraham, Jacob, Joseph and Moses cycles. (The Qur'an > > does contain traditions concerning Abraham [Ibrahim] and his first- > > born son, Ishmael [from whom Muhammed is descended], which may have an > > alternative tradition leading back to a common origin in stories told > > by various Semitic nomadic groups). The first biblical historical > > references with independent source confirmation refer to the "House of > > David" around the middle of the 9th. Century B.C.E. ( ביתדוד - the Tel > > Dan Stele, proclaiming the military prowess of a king of Damascus). > > > Manfranco, your basic problem, however, remains. If major parts of the > > bible are not historically true, at the very least in all the details > > described, what criterea of truth do you apply to the bible? Or is it, > > as frequently seems to me, a smorgasbord, from which various Christian > > believers and groups pick and choose according to their subjective > > taste? This they are perfectly entitled to do, but they should not > > then complain if their arguments are rejected as irrational and > > frivolous by those who apply more stringent terms with regards to > > claims referrring to historical truth and accuracy. > > > Francis > > > On 3 Nov., 03:17, Manfraco Frank the Elder <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > Hi Pat and members of Minds Eye group! > > > Pat I agree with you that The Tower of Babel may very well represent > > > our own consciousness, which at times seems to be confused; so, the > > > writer of The Tower of Babel must have been aware of that, therefore, > > > he followed by saying that God confounded the languages, so that > > > people would not be able to group together and try to challenge Him. > > > But one has to keep in mind that religious books are written for the > > > sole purpose of making people believe what the writer himself believes > > > what else can a religious leader do? > > > Now if one reads religious books properly, soon or later one becomes > > > aware that in some cases they have not been written properly, because > > > sometimes they might not agree within > > ... > > read more » --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups ""Minds Eye"" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
