" ...  none of it changes the basis of anarchy and its difference from
a representative democracy."


Gruff, words take on meanings with their usage. The opposite of
anarchy is not just " rule by state or rule of law." The opposite
includes all the private fiefs, corruption, white mafias, injustice,
inequities, incompetence, inefficiency, opaqueness, perversely
reversed master - slave equations, etc. ... that rule by state or rule
of law allows.

That 's both hard and real enough for us to see all about us, living
under the rule of state or rule by law.


Anarchy, as Chomsky seems to be suggesting ... a process of awakening
in opposition, is what I would imagine the Fourth Estate was supposed
to perform. Today, some do somewhat, but not ( and never ) enough ;
most do not. The NGOs ... very few do, almost all do not. The
political opposition ... they are all the same as the ones ruling.

So, who performs the function of such opposition, on the ground,
against real individuals and groups, entrenched and esconced in the
status quo ?


Anarchy would be our call to rise in opposition, not lulled into rest
by the sweet feeling that we've come far and will go far. It's a
demand and an insistence that we do better now, in everything we are
doing, effectively and efficiently.

The opposite of anarchy, from the above sense and context, is status
quo. I suppose too that anarchists would also follow a rule :  make
the institutions work better, not break or take over.

Just a constant message :  We know what we need and expect from you.
Keep it Simple. Inform us of the facts. Come into the light !


We can't live with the institutions we now have. We can't live without
them either, not now and not in the future.


On Nov 4, 5:05 am, gruff <[email protected]> wrote:
> "... On Nov 3, 12:44 pm, frantheman <[email protected]>
> wrote: ..."
>
> > “…Anarchism, in my view, is an expression of the idea that the burden
> > of proof is always on those who argue that authority and domination
> > are necessary." - Chomsky
>
> > I think this statement is the core of what Chomsky is talking about.
> > The irony is that this principle is also the constitutional core of
> > the classical constitutional representative democracies in which most
> > of us live - it is basically just a different expression of the
> > principle that power and authority is given by the "people" and
> > exercised in their name, on their behalf, with their approval.
>
> This appears utterly confusing.  It appears from the above statements
> that a representative democracy and anarchy are one and the same yet
> every accepted definition of anarchy (except of course by Chomsky)
> relates to, in one way or the other, of the absence of a state.  Even
> the word derives from the Greek ἀναρχία or anarchía, meaning without
> rule.
>
> It is quite a leap from without rule to a representative democracy
> (except of course for Chomsky).
>
> > The reality is, of course, that those with power and authority in
> > practice regard, use and defend it as if it were their entitlement and
> > right and have erected structures, both covert and overt, to assure
> > that this remains the case. (And that many of these structures are
> > dedicated to lulling the "people" into a sense of passive acquiescence
> > and disempowerment - bread [occasionally] and circuses [continually].
> > Along with the fact that taking responsibility for the power [ab]used
> > in our name is strenuous and time-consuming and, concomitantly, that
> > we are lazy enough to let the status quo continue.)
>
> I don't deny or even excuse any of the above but none of it changes
> the basis of anarchy and its difference from a representative
> democracy
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to