Very well put Vam.  The term 'biology' is pretty badly understood
generally though.  I would say this is now the key and missed issue in
many debates.  Biology doesn't 'doom' us to behave in particular ways
- there is quite massive divergence in the human species despite out
genetic similarity.  However, even in the case of identical twins, one
of them tends to dominate in the wonb and be first born, usually with
a more outgoing temperament than the other that lasts through life.
We should not under-rate the biology through general ignorance and the
dangerous knowledge of knowing a little.  Bird flock-flight is more
complex than Orn supposes, though the notion of a revolution coming is
very welcome.  In computing there are defaults - one can choose to set
other basics.  I think there are problems with what humans default to
if aspects of the easy morality by which most live are crumbled away.
Biology gives us good clues to the good and bad.  We do not cut it
away (the biology), but can learn to cope and do things differently,
feel differently about what we do as we change.  It might be worth
remembering here that Reason has drives as strong as biology.
I am not pleased to be swamped by Slip's Kahunas Orn - though possibly
less 'annoyed' than he must be to lose them.  Good to hear you utter
bollox.  Chomsky can sound just like a 'downsizer' and is not much of
an organisation or anti-organisation theorist.  Steeplejacks here
began to specialise in wrecking chimenys (argh!), but all these brick
institutions have gone, so have the steeplejacks.  That many human
organisatons look just the same is a momument to lack of human
creativity and I hardly want to trust to a waking, once droned bunch
of creative anarchists arising from soma.
The questioning is fine, and thought experiments can be conducted on
where things can lead.  Some of the structrues involved are physical,
others clearly man-made in some other stuff and hopefully unmakeable.
It is the Phoenix one wants to rise from the ashes, not Judge Dread.
We don't want to let a Napoleon raise the puppies either.  Spray
gonads in my direction if you must (did Slip give his permission?),
but don't sacrifice the majority in another hopeless cause against the
trained mercenaries of the Establishment - they will just put you on
show in their zoo at feeding time.

Our institutions aren't working and probably never did, though we
oldies may look back because jobs and work we easy to get.  Only a
revolution will do, but there is no revolution in most 'revolution' -
a beggar on foot is lashed by an officer on horse and in the 180
degree turn the beggars merely change places.  Even after the victory
in the Peasants' Revolt, Wat Tyler trusted the King and got stabbed in
the back.  He was too caught in the old etiquette and politesse.  We
should already be on the streets as a populace, but biology again has
us incumbent (a bee term) for this is its default in humans.  There
is, in fact, nothing much to argue about here, but you find ways in
this commune of egoists!

Slip - can you grow any more gonads?  The Arabs pay a high price ...

On 3 Nov, 15:03, gruff <[email protected]> wrote:
> "... On Nov 3, 1:09 am, ornamentalmind <[email protected]>
> wrote: ..."
>
> > One last small reflection: Anarchy as I’ve been presenting it and as I
> > understand Noam to use the term is a process…an attitude that is a
> > constant skepticism of institutions…the process is a never ending
> > questioning of their existence. This seems all to possible for us.
>
> Now that's a process and attitude I can agree with and I'm sorry if it
> was presented earlier in our discussion/argument and I missed it.
> Perhaps it was too veiled to be discernible by my mind's eye.
>
> I have been a skeptic of institutions, behavior, intentions and
> everything else in the human basket of goodies for some time.
--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
""Minds Eye"" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/minds-eye?hl=en
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to