*From: *Paolo Aglialoro <[email protected]> *To: *[email protected] *Date: *Nov 11, 2026 17:20:54
> On Tue, Nov 10, 2026 at 11:11 PM Brian Brombacher <[email protected]> > wrote: >> I’m curious how many of you have actually experienced a disk failure due to >> not having enough spare blocks for SSDs manufactured after 2020. I write a >> LOT of data to SSDs and I have yet to experience this issue and I take no >> precautions such as saving space at the end of the disk with an unused >> partition. Now that I just said that, I’ll have 10 disks fail tonight, >> karma… > > actually in datacenter we got different outcomes, but MOSTLY with different > producers. > Must be said that on production servers the write rates for some customers > might be quite high on a daily basis; 95%+ of the underlay storage is ZFS > based, hence demand on disks reliability is high. Please consider this data > kinda "subjective" as we're not keeping detailes statistics, especially of > the lifetime of the substituted drives. > > -old models SSDs (intel, sandisk,etc): all retired but kept in drawer; intels > have shown robust, but sample is to small > -tried some "solid" and they reavealed to be anything but solid... this > choice didn't last a month > -also crucial MX series die like flies (we don't buy them anymore after 4-5 > years "el cheapo" experience) > -samsung evo have a relatively low failure rate 2-4 disks per month over > about 20 racks > -samsung pro are die hard, changing a pro is an event that might take place > once or twice a year > -samsung PCIe HHHL PM1735 or PM1725 cards (unfortunately not produced > anymore, blame on samsung!) never seen one die!!! :O > -samsung PM983, PM9A3, etc. oh, they die too, but somewhat in between evo and > pro > -samsung NVMe evo/pro: die mostly only when used for long periods for zfs > caching, could be maybe the same for AI caching > -samsung NVMe server grade: not yet dead, but we got very few and are not > being used for caching > -high end kioxia: we got some at work, never seen one die but sample is also > too small > -in general we tend too avoid too "consumerish" brands, they're a cost not a > save > > I hope this answer meets your curiosity! Enough, thx a lot. Luckly there are still lots of sd disks out there waiting me in the 2hand market.

