Unless they decide to *physically* cut the internet into two (or more) disconnected networks, or create laws forcing ISPs to block unofficial variations, it cannot succeed. Users will simply decide to use their own "unauthorised" DNS systems. Keep in mind that the internet is something achieved by consensus. There is no law which says we must use SMTP, or POP3, or HTTP, or for that matter ICANN's root DNS servers.
Theoretically, we could decide between us to use our own server as the root DNS server and work off that one. You could probably set things up in half an hour using Bind. So what do you imagine would happen if the US government decided to "go it alone"? Do you really think that all US online businesses would accept to lose their overseas sales overnight? Sit by the sidelines and watch the rest of the world engage in cross-boundary sales while they are restricted to domestic sales only? I very much doubt it. If the US decided to draw up an iron curtain it would find that much of its own businesses choose the other side of the fence, or set up a presence on both sides - in which case you'd end up with "Internet A" which consists of the entire world including all US sites of any value, and "Internet B" which consists of only US sites. When nobody chooses "Internet B" it would die a natural death. ________________________________ Ramon Casha Megabyte Ltd (www.megabyte.net) F4, The Technopark, Mosta MST02 Malta tel: (+356) 2142 1600 fax: (+356) 2142 1590 -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Keith Vasallo Sent: Il-Gimgha, 14 ta' Ottubru 2005 09:48 To: Malta Linux User Group - general list Subject: Re: [LINUX.ORG.MT] Internet falling apart... They're kidding, right? -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 lol... This was quoted on Slashdot (which has quite a lot of excrement too). It is plausabile though, isn't it? I mean, if in the meeting every country in the world says the DNS servers should be under UN control, logic says the US will say "OK". But, the US has been known to defy logic several times, so it might just say "screw you guys, I'm going home". In which case the rest of the world will be very annoyed and might just start their own DNS... Let's just hope it doesn't happen. Keith Ramon Casha wrote: > I think that was in the daily telegraph. It's a truckload of bovine > excrement. > > ------------------------- Ramon Casha Megabyte Ltd (www.megabyte.net > <http://www.megabyte.net/>) F4, The Technopark, Mosta MST02 Malta tel: > (+356) 2142 1600 fax: (+356) 2142 1590 Megabyte Ltd > > > > ------------------------- *From:* [EMAIL PROTECTED] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] *On Behalf Of *James Attard > *Sent:* Il-?img?a, 14 ta' Ottubru 2005 07:56 *To:* Malta Linux User > Group - general list *Subject:* Re: [LINUX.ORG.MT] Internet falling > apart... They're kidding, right? > > where did you read that? > > On 10/13/05, *Keith Vasallo* <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>> wrote: > > So far I've been following the story of the control of the Internet as > just another "America wants control of this and that..." story. > But now I read this: > > "The battle for the control of the internet could hit a climax next > month, with the EU saying that it could 'fall apart.' From the > article: 'The European commission is warning that if a deal cannot be > reached at a meeting in Tunisia next month the internet will split > apart. At issue is the role of the US government in overseeing the > internet's address structure, called the domain name system (DNS), > which enables communication between the world's computers. It is > managed by the California-based, not-for-profit Internet Corporation > for Assigned Names and Numbers (Icann) under contract to the US > department of commerce.'" > > This is exaggerated, right? I hope it is, it looks very ugly. > They're not actully going to do this.. are they? > _______________________________________________ MLUG-list mailing list [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> http://mailserv.megabyte.net/mailman/listinfo/mlug-list > -- j@ > *DISCLAIMER** */The information contained in this electronic mail may > be confidential or legally privileged. It is for the intended > recipient(s) only. Should you receive this message in error, please > notify the sender by replying to this mail. Unauthorised use of the > contents is strictly prohibited. Whilst all care has been taken, the > Megabyte Group is not responsible for the integrity of the contents of > this electronic mail and any attachments included within. / > ------------------------- > _______________________________________________ MLUG-list mailing list > [email protected] > http://mailserv.megabyte.net/mailman/listinfo/mlug-list - -- Keith Vassallo Registered GNU/Linux User #290991 http://www.keithvassallo.net -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://enigmail.mozdev.org iD8DBQFDT2KSym3HAdrlsyERAio2AJ9+XFJhPAbiPWTAkNXzEGguc/epbgCfQO7Y MSfgGJ6kt6IzR1AO0Al69ss= =KlRY -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ MLUG-list mailing list [email protected] http://mailserv.megabyte.net/mailman/listinfo/mlug-list DISCLAIMER The information contained in this electronic mail may be confidential or legally privileged. It is for the intended recipient(s) only. Should you receive this message in error, please notify the sender by replying to this mail. Unauthorised use of the contents is strictly prohibited. Whilst all care has been taken, the Megabyte Group is not responsible for the integrity of the contents of this electronic mail and any attachments included within.
