Ben Bucksch wrote:

> Bob Lord wrote:
> 
>> In older versions of Communicator, there was a step in the 
>> certificate  enrollment process where the user was asked to name 
>> his/her newly issued  certificate.  Although this gave the user some 
>> flexibility, it mostly  casued problems.  Users would sometimes choose 
>> non-descriptive names  that would cause Help Desk problems down the road.
> 
> 
> Why not offer a good default?

It can still be trouble to give users control over things they don't 
understand, even with good defaults.  :-)


 
> Even if you don't want the nicknames: I read it that the nickname 
> facility exists. Why not leave the backend intact? If you change your 
> mind (or somebody else does), you can easily readd them.

The underlying infrastructure in NSS will still have nicknames.


> 
>> I'd like for the Issuer to be visible in the browser chrome during 
>> SSL  sessions.  In N6.0 it shows up as a tooltip if you're able to 
>> mouse-over  the little lock icon.
> 
> 
> That's just fine for me. I assume you want to extent that and have it 
> displayed directly in e.g. the status bar? Do we have enough place for 
> that, considering that the Taskbar might merge with the status bar in 
> the future?

I would assume that there's room, but I have not seen any mockups to 
know for sure.

In fact did have the CA in the chrome for a while, but a few people felt 
that it presented too much clutter.  I'd like to get more people's input.


> 
> I don't see that the issuer were very important for the user. Why would 
> Joe User want to trust a cert issued from VeriSign more than one issued 
> from TC Trustcenter or one from a (non-standard) CA that he explicitly 
> accepted? Or am I missing something?

The browser isn't making an assertion about a web site; the issuer is. 
We'd like to give that information to the user.  That will become more 
important as more CAs spring up.



> 
>> I use "Netscape" in these demos, but assume that's a variable.  When 
>> the  application is "Mozilla", the app displays that string.  Same for 
>> Beonex.
> 
> 
> Cool, thanks! :-)


-- 
Bob Lord
Director, Security Engineering
Netscape Communications Corp.
http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/
http://people.netscape.com/lord/open-reqs.html


Reply via email to