> If you're taking votes ... OPTION 2 looks good Ditto.
# * Intact pen Only appears when the message is signed, either per # Preferences or per this message only (Options menu). # * Only show the broken pen when the user wants to send this message # signed but can't for some reason (is this a valid scenario?). # * Show No pen icon at all if signing is turned off (user not # interested, don't annoy them with it). # * The lock icon as closed when the message can be sent encrypted # and encryption is turned on. # * Open lock when message can't be sent encrypted and encryption # is turned on. # * No lock if encryption is not turned on. I like this. The only difference I'd suggest is that instead of no pen and/or no lock (to indicate the option is not selected), I'd put a greyed-out pen and/or lock. This seems to indicate "deselected" more strongly, and is more discoverable.
