> 
> As I may have replied to that assertion earlier, I don't know that the ISO
> CRC implementation is broken so much as simply missing.  I believe that the
> 'dist10' distribution only implements CRC checking for layers I & II.  And
> yes, my CRC polynomial seems to work just fine, thanks (decodes streams
> encoded by commercial encoders, encodes streams decodable by commercial
> decoders), or I wouldn't have posted it...
> 
> Alex

It's true: dist10 will set the layer III CRC bit, but doesn't
bother to compute a valid checksum and just writes 0's into the
bitstream.

LAME has a correct CRC implementation (enabled with -p) 
since version 3.12  - it was added by Johannes Overmann.

Mark


--
MP3 ENCODER mailing list ( http://geek.rcc.se/mp3encoder/ )

Reply via email to