If I may ask for a clarification: when you say that we should speak only one 
language, are you saying that every American should at least be able to speak 
English (which I agree with), or that Americans should only know English?

In fact, the first foreign language I learned was not Somali, or French, or 
even my ancestors' native German--it was Latin. At age nine I began to read 
Edgar Allan Poe, who like any other educated American of his time knew Latin 
and sprinkled his work with it. Ask any nongovernment worker in the legal or 
medical profession if Latin is also not important for them to know. I cannot 
form a sentence in Latin, but I know those phrases from Poe.

The Founding Fathers, being classically-trained, educated landowners, knew 
several languages. Being multilingual is not a new idea. In fact, many 
conservatives I know have studied Hebrew, Greek, and/or Italian, in addition 
to Latin.

Incidentally, what is English? I had to read Boewulf and Chaucer in their 
original forms of "English"--which would be practically indecipherable to 
most readers today. And if one reads The Story of English (also a PBS 
documentary), which traces the development of the many forms of "English" 
spoken around the world today, the question as to what English is becomes 
even more relevant.

Be careful about exhorting people to speak only English. I love the English 
language and to me, "English" means standard English. Yesterday I heard an 
FBI agent say, "You can't hardly..." Well, under my rulership he couldn't get 
away with that! No "ain't got no's," no "you don't gottas," that I hear 
people say all the time, if I had a say in it. (I don't hear this type of 
English from Somalis.) So be careful that you don't get what you wish.
Kristine Harley
Sheridan
_______________________________________

Minneapolis Issues Forum - A City-focused Civic Discussion - Mn E-Democracy
Post messages to: mailto:mpls@;mnforum.org
Subscribe, Unsubscribe, Digest, and more: http://e-democracy.org/mpls

Reply via email to