Gecks:
Gecks wrote: > > ok, i've done so :) http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/EngineerRelationshipType > > basically, it's analogous with ArrangerRelationshipType in that you > can specifiy an instrument (and additionally, vocal type) > > (whilst i was there, i amended the link phrases for both classes so > that they include instrument and vocals) > Great! This helps me understand. I still have some uncertainties. 1. There are three uses of the AR name "engineered": a. artist engineered {release} or {track} b. artist engineered {instrument} on {album} or {track} c. artist engineered {vocal type} on {album} or {track} Perhaps the AR names in b. and c. should be "engineered instrument" and "engineered vocal", consistent with http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/PerformerRelationshipType ? (Same applies to 3 instances of "recorded".) 2. Shouldn't that be "release" instead of "album"? 3. Under "Description", I think it would be helpful to add "engineered instrument" and "engineered vocal", explaining when to use them instead of generic "engineered". (Same applies to "recorded instrument" and "recorded vocal".) 4. Are the {instrument} and {vocal type} parameters identical to the corresponding parameters in http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/PerformerRelationshipType ? It seems more straightforward that they be identical. If so, I suggest that the explanation say that, and refer to InstrumentRelationshipAttribute and VocalRelationshipAttribute . Those attribute pages will also need revision so that they talk about engineers and not just performers using the attribute. 5. In the Relationship Attributes section, it doesn't say that the Instrument and Vocal Type attributes apply to specific ARs only. This proposal doesn't include "Audio Engineered Vocal", right? Then I think it would be clearer for the Instrument and Vocal Type attributes description to say the ARs to which the apply. My CAD 0.02 as a clueless newbie, (maybe this is turning into CAD 0.03) --Jim DeLaHunt, Vancouver, Canada -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/RFV%3A-Adding-%7Binstrument%7D-and-%7Bvocals%7D-to-%27Recorded-By%27-AR-tp14577614s2885p14607531.html Sent from the Musicbrainz - Style mailing list archive at Nabble.com. _______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list Musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
