I will answer this mail. But refering to the condition of tagging source=ideib.cat, really, really, really it's not the case.
The permission they give me is _literally_: "You could use the IMATGES-AERIES service [N.T.: aerial imatges service] as a background for editing other layer. You only have to cite the source" That we have to "cite the source" I interpreted as put source=... put really, it suffices to mention "IDEIB" in the comment of the update data (comment tag I think), in "note" tag, in anything else. But mention the source. Xan. En/na Richard Weait ha escrit: > 2010/3/28 Xan <[email protected]>: > >> I just have to say that I did not "negotiate". I only make a question if >> I could use the WMS in openstreetmap. Only a question. >> >> Good if OSM Foundation negotiate directly with them and get some better >> conditions. >> > > Dear Xan, > > You presented the information as if the data was okay for inclusion in > OSM. Please update your wiki page to indicate that this is a > potential data source, but is not yet okay for inclusion in OSM. And > please pass that along to any other channels (talk-es and others) you > may have used. > > If they donate data under PDDL, or data is available as Public Domain, > that's generally okay from a license perspective. But that does not > address the quality or suitability of the data. Both of those must be > considered as well. > > Did you tell them that OSM would add source= for each object? Then > you negotiated. Do they think that you speak for all of OSM or the > OSM Foundation? Then you negotiated. ;-) > > I applaud your enthusiasm and the initiative in finding a potential > data source. But licenses are complicated and OSM aims to stay > unassailable in our respect for the data of others, as we expect > others to respect our data. > > Best regards, > Richard > > _______________________________________________ > newbies mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/newbies > _______________________________________________ newbies mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/newbies
