From Meryl Nass: States, Hospitals Mandating H1N1 Vaccinations Just Don't Get It They will be on the hook for all liability for injured recipients
<http://anthraxvaccine.blogspot.com/>http://anthraxvaccine.blogspot.com/ A domino effect is cascading through the country, as officials rush to impose vaccination mandates on citizens (Massachusetts) and health care employees (New York), as well as mandates in many additional healthcare systems and hospitals. The tsunami mandating vaccinations is occurring in a vaccuum of information about the incidence and impact of the diseases citizens will be forcibly protected against, and the effectiveness and safety of mandated vaccines. Meantime, the institutions mandating the vaccinations appear clueless about the massive liability for vaccine injuries they are assuming as a result of these mandates. 1) Low disease incidence of seasonal influenza viruses Currently (this week) only 1% of circulating influenza viruses in the United States are of the "seasonal" type. Seasonal flu outbreaks usually start late in the season: November at the earliest. It takes 7-10 days to develop a strong immune response. Vaccine recipients who are elderly or have weak immune systems have a rapid fall in antibody levels, after they peak, over the following few months. It makes no sense to vaccinate these people early in the season, as they may lose vaccine protection before flu season is over. And since only 1% of currently circulating flu viruses will be covered by the seasonal vaccine, it hardly makes sense to use that vaccine at all, at this point in time. If such viruses increase in the population as time passes, vaccinations could be started at a more appropriate time for them. (Those with good memories may recall that seasonal vaccinations are normally offered in October and November.) 2) Uncertain swine flu vaccine effectiveness and adverse effects Swine flu vaccine generates antibody levels, but we still don't know how well it prevents disease. Nor do we know how safe it is, since pretty much all the experts agree that until millions receive a vaccine, it is impossible to accurately identify its adverse effects. Now, a story out of British Columbia's disease control center indicates that people who have received flu vaccine in a previous year may be more susceptible to developing swine flu (the disease). Odd as this sounds at first, it is a fact that that receiving certain animal vaccines increased susceptibility to the disease the vaccine was designed to prevent. Such vaccines were taken off the market. We need to wait to learn if this finding (higher risk of swine flu associated with prior vaccination) is borne out by other studies, but it does offer a reminder that vaccinations can have unanticipated effects that are a lot more serious than a sore arm. By the way, CSL's swine flu "vaccine triggered side-effects including headache, myalgia, fever and nausea in more than 60 per cent of trial participants." From Bloomberg: "This is the biggest mass vaccination we have done in world history and we are doing it on data so far which shows this virus is not a lot worse than seasonal influenza," said Peter Collignon, director of infectious diseases at the Australian National University's medical school. "There is a real worry that the fear makes us do things out of proportion to the risk." "If this was causing 1 or 2 percent mortality and spreading quickly, I would be the first person up there with my arm," Collignon said. As it is, "I will put my arm up next February or March when I have seen more data." Swine flu killed 170 people in Australia, and the epidemic peaked there in July: a far cry from predictions of many thousands of deaths. Now Australia plans to start swine flu vaccinations; but it is likely most of the population is already immune as a result of widespread exposure! (When Australians enrolled in swine flu vaccine trials, 30% of subjects were found to be immune already.) 3) Workplaces and states which mandate swine flu vaccinations don't have liability waivers But everyone else involved in the swine flu vaccination process does have a liability waiver: this includes manufacturers, distributors, medical professionals who administer the vaccine and government program planners who worked on the vaccination program. Read it in the Federal Register of June 25, 2009. It says that licensed individuals authorized to prescribe, administer and dispense the vaccine have liability waivers, but there are no other "qualified persons" (pursuant to section 319F-3[i][8][B]) who are given this immunity, (such as employers of these persons, or states). Unless there has been a new government declaration extending immunity to these entities since June 25, of which I am unaware, hospitals, other health care institutions and states appear to be inviting lawsuits as a result of employee mandates they are issuing. Since the newly created federal compensation program for swine flu injuries has both a low payment cap and prevents access to the U.S. legal system, the occurrence of employee mandates virtually guarantees that any vaccine injuries suffered by employees will result in lawsuits against employers, the only "deep pocket" left liable. It appears that some employers may have already dug themselves a hole by issuing blanket mandates, since some states guarantee vaccine exemptions on the basis of religious beliefs or union contracts. Meryl Meryl Nass, MD Mount Desert Island Hospital Bar Harbor, Maine 04609 W 207 288-5081 ext. 1220 C 207 522-5229 H 207 244-9165 pager 207 818-0708 <http://anthraxvaccine.blogspot.com>http://anthraxvaccine.blogspot.com --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to Mark Crispin Miller's "News From Underground" newsgroup. To unsubscribe, send a blank email to [email protected] OR go to http://groups.google.com/group/newsfromunderground and click on the "Unsubscribe or change membership" link in the yellow bar at the top of the page, then click the "Unsubscribe" button on the next page. For more News From Underground, visit http://markcrispinmiller.com -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
