Hi Rob,

On 03/02/10 11:53 -0700, Robert Thurlow wrote:
>  Jan Kryl wrote:
> > Hi,
> > please could you review the following fix for 6920999?
> > webrev:
> >   http://cr.opensolaris.org/~jkryl/nfs-utf8/
> 
>  Hi Jan,
> 
>  The changes look good to me except for something related
>  to the ASSERT change Tom mentioned.  I think ASSERTs and
>  a runtime check should be put in nfscmd_findmap(), which
>  is the highest point that is vulnerable to a stray NULL
>  pointer.
> 
I have removed asserts and added a NULL-test in
nfscmd_findmap() as you have suggested. I think that
the asserts aren't usefull anymore now when we test
NULL values for both debug and non-debug kernels.

>  Thanks for running with this, I had not appreciated there
>  was incomplete implementation on the server as well.  The
>  CR should be clear that this problem and this fix is about
>  the server side, not the client.
> 
I have added a clear statement to evaluation of CR to
clarify this.

Please see new revision of webrev:
  http://cr.opensolaris.org/~jkryl/nfs-utf8-3/
  
Thanks for your comments
-Jan

Reply via email to