Since this has emerged into the daylight, I feel entitled to comment and I am appalled.
I have no idea what assertions have already been made in this hitherto private correspondance. However, I'd suggest that their objectivity be scrutinised very carefully. Francis Wood On 23 May 2009, at 12:30, Bill Telfer wrote: Just to make sure, again,-yes, count me in on this resolution Bill From: Anthony Robb [[1]mailto:anth...@robbpipes.com] Sent: 23 May 2009 10:29 To: Chris Almond; Colin and; Neil Baker; NIGEL BARLOW; Nigel Barlow; Bill Bohill; Daphne Briggs; Steve Campbell; Helen Capes; Pauline Cato; Margaret Cato; colin; Dave Cook; Rick Damon; Dave McQuade; Richard&Anita Evans; Reg Flower; John Gibbons; John Gibbons; Gordon Greenley; Philip Gruar; Marianne Hall; Honor Hill; David Hillery; Nick Hopkinson; Simon James; Ian Lawther; Simon Leveaux; Alan McKenzie; Dave McQuade; Margaret Moyes; Adrian Scofield; Matt Seattle; Mike Sharp; Bill Telfer Subject: Latest Just to let everyone know what's happening. The submission for Julia will go off as soon as I'm confident that the people whose names appear are happy. Some have expressed opinions so clearly and I don't expect to hear further from them. If you are having doubts either way about the presence of your signature please get in touch no later than Tuesday 26th May. May I add that I am doing this with Colin's approval although he certainly did not instigate it. In my view the Society needs the involvement of the grandees such as Colin. To have him put out to pasture at this stage would be, I think, unwise and unjust. Here is what I hope to send to Julia next week: Julia Say Hon. Secretary Northumbrian Pipers' Society Dear Julia We the undersigned request that an Extraordinary general meeting of Society members be convened in order to consider the following motion: "Following strong dissatisfaction expressed by many members, this meeting proposes that the committee's choice of president be reconsidered, and mandates the committee to re-start the selection process, with nominations and voting facilities to be extended to the entire membership." Yours sincerely, Helen Capes Richard Evans Gordon Greenley Philip Gruar Paul Gretton Marianne Hall Simon James Ian Lawther Anthony Robb Adrian Schofield Matt Seattle Neil Tavernor -- To get on or off this list see list information at [2]http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html -- References 1. mailto:anth...@robbpipes.com 2. http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html