On 20/10/11 20:37, Rob Weir wrote:
On Thu, Oct 20, 2011 at 3:20 PM, Dennis E. Hamilton<[email protected]> wrote:
I believe the next-action on administration of the ooo-bz is ours. It looks
like there need to be some @apache.org administrators, and the hierarchy of
administration with respect to the various categories also needs to be dealt
with.
Could we just flatten the hierarchy and see what emerges? That would
certainly be easier than trying to map the complexity of the existing
approach. We'll likely converge on a near-optimal solution over time,
as people volunteer. It is one of those things where the downside
risk from error is so very small that it may not be worth a lot of
effort to design the perfect approach. It will evolve organically,
but probably faster if we start fresh.
From the list that Mark Thomas provided, I only see 2 apache.org e-mail
addresses that have administrative logins, Mark Thomas himself and Herbert
Dürr. The rest are openoffice.org addresses of people who may or may not be
here, may or may not be committers/PPMC members. They might not have even
restored access to their bugzilla account after the move, but I suspect they
are still getting automated traffic from ooo-bz!?.
My thought is that this is an appropriate migration case to handle with more
detail on OOOUSER.
I am raising this flag for discussion. I think a couple of admins should be
nominated and option 2 taken. The mapping could be explained on the wiki. Who
already knows enough ins-and-outs of Bugzilla administration to land running?
Whoot! At last - something I can add some value to!
I am an admin on Bugzilla at my day job. I'd be happy to help as and
where I can.
Dave.
- Dennis
I would also like to know as soon as possible where bugs about the ooo-bz
itself can be posted. There are also migration-completion actions to be worked
through (maybe on OOOUSER in concept with individual concrete actionables as
ooo-bz tasks?
-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Thomas [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Friday, October 14, 2011 15:32
To: OOo-dev Apache Incubator
Cc: Apache Infrastructure
Subject: Re: Bugzilla notifications not going to an ASF mailing list
On 14/10/2011 18:34, Dave Fisher wrote:
Hi Mark,
Thanks. I believe that the podling PPMC needs to make sure there are people who
are able to be sysadmins.
Agreed. A quick glance at the lists below suggests that quite a few
additional admins are required.
Option 1:
Identify a few folks to be in the admin group who can then add other
users to groups as required and provide the list of login_names to infra.
Option 2:
Same as 1 plus provide infra with a suitably formatted list (plain text)
of login_name to group name mappings that you want created in bulk as a
one-off
In both cases, the OOo project would manage users of the OOo Bz instance
moving forwards.
Please create an infrastructure Jira ticket when you are ready to take
this forward.
Is it possible for you to identify who currently has a sysadmin role in the
AOOo BZ. Send it to ooo-private if you prefer.
The current mapping of users to admin roles for active users (those that
have reset their password) is as follows:
+---------------------------+----------------------+
| login_name | name |
+---------------------------+----------------------+
| [email protected] | admin |
| [email protected] | admin |
| [email protected] | api-admin |
| [email protected] | bizdev-admin |
| [email protected] | certification-admin |
| [email protected] | cs-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | extensions-admin |
| [email protected] | framework-admin |
| [email protected] | graphics-admin |
| [email protected] | gsl-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | infrastructure-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | sc-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | udk-admin |
| [email protected] | ui-admin |
+---------------------------+----------------------+
The current mapping of all users to admin roles is:
+-----------------------------------+----------------------+
| login_name | name |
+-----------------------------------+----------------------+
| [email protected] | aa-admin |
| [email protected] | aa-admin |
| [email protected] | aa-admin |
| [email protected] | about-admin |
| [email protected] | about-admin |
| [email protected] | admin |
| [email protected] | admin |
| [email protected] | af-admin |
| [email protected] | af-admin |
| [email protected] | af-admin |
| [email protected] | af-admin |
| [email protected] | am-admin |
| [email protected] | am-admin |
| [email protected] | am-admin |
| [email protected] | api-admin |
| [email protected] | api-admin |
| [email protected] | api-admin |
| [email protected] | ar-admin |
| [email protected] | ar-admin |
| [email protected] | ar-admin |
| [email protected] | ast-admin |
| [email protected] | ast-admin |
| [email protected] | ast-admin |
| [email protected] | az-admin |
| [email protected] | az-admin |
| [email protected] | az-admin |
| [email protected] | az-admin |
| [email protected] | bal-admin |
| [email protected] | bal-admin |
| [email protected] | bal-admin |
| [email protected] | bg-admin |
| [email protected] | bg-admin |
| [email protected] | bg-admin |
| [email protected] | bibliographic-admin |
| [email protected] | bibliographic-admin |
| [email protected] | bibliographic-admin |
| [email protected] | bibliographic-admin |
| [email protected] | bizdev-admin |
| [email protected] | bizdev-admin |
| [email protected] | bizdev-admin |
| [email protected] | bizdev-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bn-admin |
| [email protected] | bo-admin |
| [email protected] | bo-admin |
| [email protected] | bo-admin |
| [email protected] | br-pt-admin |
| [email protected] | br-pt-admin |
| [email protected] | bre-admin |
| [email protected] | bre-admin |
| [email protected] | bre-admin |
| [email protected] | bs-admin |
| [email protected] | bs-admin |
| [email protected] | bs-admin |
| [email protected] | bs-admin |
| [email protected] | ca-admin |
| [email protected] | ca-admin |
| [email protected] | ca-admin |
| [email protected] | certification-admin |
| [email protected] | certification-admin |
| [email protected] | certification-admin |
| [email protected] | contributing-admin |
| [email protected] | contributing-admin |
| [email protected] | council-admin |
| [email protected] | council-admin |
| [email protected] | council-admin |
| [email protected] | cs-admin |
| [email protected] | cs-admin |
| [email protected] | cs-admin |
| [email protected] | cs-admin |
| [email protected] | cy-admin |
| [email protected] | cy-admin |
| [email protected] | cy-admin |
| [email protected] | da-admin |
| [email protected] | da-admin |
| [email protected] | da-admin |
| [email protected] | da-admin |
| [email protected] | dba-admin |
| [email protected] | dba-admin |
| [email protected] | de-admin |
| [email protected] | de-admin |
| [email protected] | de-admin |
| [email protected] | de-admin |
| [email protected] | de-admin |
| [email protected] | development-admin |
| [email protected] | development-admin |
| [email protected] | distribution-admin |
| [email protected] | distribution-admin |
| [email protected] | distribution-admin |
| [email protected] | distribution-admin |
| [email protected] | dm-admin |
| [email protected] | dm-admin |
| [email protected] | dm-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | documentation-admin |
| [email protected] | download-admin |
| [email protected] | download-admin |
| [email protected] | dz-admin |
| [email protected] | dz-admin |
| [email protected] | dz-admin |
| [email protected] | dz-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | education-admin |
| [email protected] | el-admin |
| [email protected] | el-admin |
| [email protected] | el-admin |
| [email protected] | el-admin |
| [email protected] | el-admin |
| [email protected] | eo-admin |
| [email protected] | eo-admin |
| [email protected] | eo-admin |
| [email protected] | eo-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | es-admin |
| [email protected] | et-admin |
| [email protected] | et-admin |
| [email protected] | et-admin |
| [email protected] | et-admin |
| [email protected] | eu-admin |
| [email protected] | eu-admin |
| [email protected] | eu-admin |
| [email protected] | extensions-admin |
| [email protected] | extensions-admin |
| [email protected] | extensions-admin |
| [email protected] | external-admin |
| [email protected] | external-admin |
| [email protected] | external-admin |
| [email protected] | fa-admin |
| [email protected] | fa-admin |
| [email protected] | fa-admin |
| [email protected] | fa-admin |
| [email protected] | fi-admin |
| [email protected] | fi-admin |
| [email protected] | fi-admin |
| [email protected] | fi-admin |
| [email protected] | fi-admin |
| [email protected] | fr-admin |
| [email protected] | fr-admin |
| [email protected] | framework-admin |
| [email protected] | framework-admin |
| [email protected] | framework-admin |
| [email protected] | framework-admin |
| [email protected] | fur-admin |
| [email protected] | fur-admin |
| [email protected] | fur-admin |
| [email protected] | fur-admin |
| [email protected] | ga-admin |
| [email protected] | ga-admin |
| [email protected] | ga-admin |
| [email protected] | gd-admin |
| [email protected] | gd-admin |
| [email protected] | gd-admin |
| [email protected] | gd-admin |
| [email protected] | gd-admin |
| [email protected] | gl-admin |
| [email protected] | gl-admin |
| [email protected] | gl-admin |
| [email protected] | graphics-admin |
| [email protected] | graphics-admin |
| [email protected] | graphics-admin |
| [email protected] | groupware-admin |
| [email protected] | groupware-admin |
| [email protected] | groupware-admin |
| [email protected] | groupware-admin |
| [email protected] | groupware-admin |
| [email protected] | gsl-admin |
| [email protected] | gsl-admin |
| [email protected] | gsl-admin |
| [email protected] | gu-admin |
| [email protected] | gu-admin |
| [email protected] | gu-admin |
| [email protected] | gu-admin |
| [email protected] | he-admin |
| [email protected] | he-admin |
| [email protected] | he-admin |
| [email protected] | he-admin |
| [email protected] | hi-admin |
| [email protected] | hi-admin |
| [email protected] | hi-admin |
| [email protected] | hi-admin |
| [email protected] | hi-admin |
| [email protected] | hr-admin |
| [email protected] | hr-admin |
| [email protected] | hr-admin |
| [email protected] | hr-admin |
| [email protected] | ht-admin |
| [email protected] | ht-admin |
| [email protected] | ht-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | hu-admin |
| [email protected] | hy-admin |
| [email protected] | hy-admin |
| [email protected] | hy-admin |
| [email protected] | hy-admin |
| [email protected] | id-admin |
| [email protected] | id-admin |
| [email protected] | id-admin |
| [email protected] | infrastructure-admin |
| [email protected] | infrastructure-admin |
| [email protected] | infrastructure-admin |
| [email protected] | installation-admin |
| [email protected] | installation-admin |
| [email protected] | installation-admin |
| [email protected] | installation-admin |
| [email protected] | is-admin |
| [email protected] | is-admin |
| [email protected] | is-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | it-admin |
| [email protected] | ja-admin |
| [email protected] | ja-admin |
| [email protected] | ja-admin |
| [email protected] | ka-admin |
| [email protected] | ka-admin |
| [email protected] | ka-admin |
| [email protected] | ka-admin |
| [email protected] | kde-admin |
| [email protected] | kde-admin |
| [email protected] | kde-admin |
| [email protected] | km-admin |
| [email protected] | km-admin |
| [email protected] | km-admin |
| [email protected] | ko-admin |
| [email protected] | ko-admin |
| [email protected] | ko-admin |
| [email protected] | ku-admin |
| [email protected] | ku-admin |
| [email protected] | ku-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | l10n-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lingucomponent-admin |
| [email protected] | lo-admin |
| [email protected] | lo-admin |
| [email protected] | lo-admin |
| [email protected] | look-admin |
| [email protected] | look-admin |
| [email protected] | look-admin |
| [email protected] | lt-admin |
| [email protected] | lt-admin |
| [email protected] | lt-admin |
| [email protected] | lt-admin |
| [email protected] | lv-admin |
| [email protected] | lv-admin |
| [email protected] | lv-admin |
| [email protected] | lv-admin |
| [email protected] | marketing-admin |
| [email protected] | marketing-admin |
| [email protected] | marketing-admin |
| [email protected] | marketing-admin |
| [email protected] | marketing-admin |
| [email protected] | mg-admin |
| [email protected] | mg-admin |
| [email protected] | mg-admin |
| [email protected] | mg-admin |
| [email protected] | miq-admin |
| [email protected] | miq-admin |
| [email protected] | miq-admin |
| [email protected] | miq-admin |
| [email protected] | mk-admin |
| [email protected] | mk-admin |
| [email protected] | mk-admin |
| [email protected] | mk-admin |
| [email protected] | mk-admin |
| [email protected] | ml-admin |
| [email protected] | ml-admin |
| [email protected] | ml-admin |
| [email protected] | mn-admin |
| [email protected] | mn-admin |
| [email protected] | mn-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | modularization-admin |
| [email protected] | mr-admin |
| [email protected] | mr-admin |
| [email protected] | mr-admin |
| [email protected] | mr-admin |
| [email protected] | mr-admin |
| [email protected] | ms-admin |
| [email protected] | ms-admin |
| [email protected] | ms-admin |
| [email protected] | ms-admin |
| [email protected] | my-admin |
| [email protected] | my-admin |
| [email protected] | my-admin |
| [email protected] | ne-admin |
| [email protected] | ne-admin |
| [email protected] | ne-admin |
| [email protected] | ne-admin |
| [email protected] | nl-admin |
| [email protected] | nl-admin |
| [email protected] | nl-admin |
| [email protected] | nl-admin |
| [email protected] | no-admin |
| [email protected] | no-admin |
| [email protected] | no-admin |
| [email protected] | no-admin |
| [email protected] | ny-admin |
| [email protected] | ny-admin |
| [email protected] | ny-admin |
| [email protected] | odf-at-www-admin |
| [email protected] | odf-at-www-admin |
| [email protected] | odf-at-www-admin |
| [email protected] | odf-at-www-admin |
| [email protected] | odf-at-www-admin |
| [email protected] | om-admin |
| [email protected] | om-admin |
| [email protected] | om-admin |
| [email protected] | oopm-admin |
| [email protected] | oopm-admin |
| [email protected] | oopm-admin |
| [email protected] | oopm-admin |
| [email protected] | pa-admin |
| [email protected] | pa-admin |
| [email protected] | pa-admin |
| [email protected] | pap-admin |
| [email protected] | pap-admin |
| [email protected] | pap-admin |
| [email protected] | performance-admin |
| [email protected] | performance-admin |
| [email protected] | performance-admin |
| [email protected] | performance-admin |
| [email protected] | pl-admin |
| [email protected] | pl-admin |
| [email protected] | pl-admin |
| [email protected] | porting-admin |
| [email protected] | porting-admin |
| [email protected] | porting-admin |
| [email protected] | porting-admin |
| [email protected] | porting-admin |
| [email protected] | ps-admin |
| [email protected] | ps-admin |
| [email protected] | ps-admin |
| [email protected] | pt-admin |
| [email protected] | pt-admin |
| [email protected] | pt-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | qa-admin |
| [email protected] | ro-admin |
| [email protected] | ro-admin |
| [email protected] | ro-admin |
| [email protected] | ro-admin |
| [email protected] | ro-admin |
| [email protected] | ru-admin |
| [email protected] | ru-admin |
| [email protected] | ru-admin |
| [email protected] | sc-admin |
| [email protected] | sc-admin |
| [email protected] | sc-admin |
| [email protected] | security-admin |
| [email protected] | security-admin |
| [email protected] | security-admin |
| [email protected] | sg-admin |
| [email protected] | sg-admin |
| [email protected] | sg-admin |
| [email protected] | shs-admin |
| [email protected] | shs-admin |
| [email protected] | shs-admin |
| [email protected] | si-admin |
| [email protected] | si-admin |
| [email protected] | si-admin |
| [email protected] | sk-admin |
| [email protected] | sk-admin |
| [email protected] | sk-admin |
| [email protected] | sk-admin |
| [email protected] | sl-admin |
| [email protected] | sl-admin |
| [email protected] | sl-admin |
| [email protected] | sl-admin |
| [email protected] | sl-admin |
| [email protected] | so-admin |
| [email protected] | so-admin |
| [email protected] | so-admin |
| [email protected] | specs-admin |
| [email protected] | specs-admin |
| [email protected] | specs-admin |
| [email protected] | sq-admin |
| [email protected] | sq-admin |
| [email protected] | sq-admin |
| [email protected] | sq-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | sr-admin |
| [email protected] | stats-admin |
| [email protected] | stats-admin |
| [email protected] | stats-admin |
| [email protected] | support-admin |
| [email protected] | support-admin |
| [email protected] | support-admin |
| [email protected] | sv-admin |
| [email protected] | sv-admin |
| [email protected] | sv-admin |
| [email protected] | sv-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | sw-admin |
| [email protected] | ta-admin |
| [email protected] | ta-admin |
| [email protected] | ta-admin |
| [email protected] | ta-admin |
| [email protected] | te-admin |
| [email protected] | te-admin |
| [email protected] | te-admin |
| [email protected] | te-admin |
| [email protected] | te-admin |
| [email protected] | test-admin |
| [email protected] | test-admin |
| [email protected] | test-admin |
| [email protected] | test-admin |
| [email protected] | tg-admin |
| [email protected] | tg-admin |
| [email protected] | tg-admin |
| [email protected] | th-admin |
| [email protected] | th-admin |
| [email protected] | th-admin |
| [email protected] | th-admin |
| [email protected] | ti-admin |
| [email protected] | ti-admin |
| [email protected] | ti-admin |
| [email protected] | ti-admin |
| [email protected] | tools-admin |
| [email protected] | tools-admin |
| [email protected] | tools-admin |
| [email protected] | tr-admin |
| [email protected] | tr-admin |
| [email protected] | tr-admin |
| [email protected] | tr-admin |
| [email protected] | tr-admin |
| [email protected] | tt-crh-admin |
| [email protected] | tt-crh-admin |
| [email protected] | tt-crh-admin |
| [email protected] | tt-crh-admin |
| [email protected] | ua-admin |
| [email protected] | ua-admin |
| [email protected] | ua-admin |
| [email protected] | ucb-admin |
| [email protected] | ucb-admin |
| [email protected] | ucb-admin |
| [email protected] | udk-admin |
| [email protected] | udk-admin |
| [email protected] | udk-admin |
| [email protected] | udk-admin |
| [email protected] | ui-admin |
| [email protected] | ui-admin |
| [email protected] | ui-admin |
| [email protected] | urd-admin |
| [email protected] | urd-admin |
| [email protected] | urd-admin |
| [email protected] | urd-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | ux-admin |
| [email protected] | uz-admin |
| [email protected] | uz-admin |
| [email protected] | uz-admin |
| [email protected] | uz-admin |
| [email protected] | vba-admin |
| [email protected] | vba-admin |
| [email protected] | vba-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | vi-admin |
| [email protected] | why-admin |
| [email protected] | why-admin |
| [email protected] | why-admin |
| [email protected] | why-admin |
| [email protected] | why-admin |
| [email protected] | wp-admin |
| [email protected] | wp-admin |
| [email protected] | wp-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | www-admin |
| [email protected] | xml-admin |
| [email protected] | xml-admin |
| [email protected] | xml-admin |
| [email protected] | xml-admin |
| [email protected] | zh-admin |
| [email protected] | zh-admin |
| [email protected] | zh-admin |
| [email protected] | zh-admin |
| [email protected] | zh-admin |
+-----------------------------------+----------------------+
