I mean -- to be clear -- this question should have a step-by-step analysis on a wiki page, to illustrate how R2L and PLN actually deal with it. The fact that we don't have such a page is a major issue.
--linas On Thu, Nov 10, 2016 at 7:39 PM, Linas Vepstas <[email protected]> wrote: > Its not a trivial question, I'm sorry no one answered your email earlier. > Nil works on this component, I am not sure how it works or how well it > works right now. > > --linas > > On Fri, Oct 21, 2016 at 2:11 AM, Tareq Alkhaldi <[email protected]> > wrote: > >> Hi everyone, >> >> So I've been trying to figure out the steps of inference the bc/fc will >> do in order to answer the following TruthQuery: >> >> (nlp-parse "Japan won the game.") >> >> (ReferenceLink >> (InterpretationNode "sentence@4603e95d-b5b8-4831-a >> 0ac-95f28feaa119_parse_0_interpretation_$X") >> (SetLink >> (InheritanceLink >> (ConceptNode "game@85e71213-577b-4aa2-8412-da49e62ba2f4") >> (ConceptNode "game" (stv 0.03125 0.0012484394)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "definite") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "game@85e71213-577b-4aa2-8412-da49e62ba2f4") >> ) >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@2d483477-9a2d-4049-968f-8f7120f43e51") >> (ConceptNode "Japan" (stv 0.03125 0.0012484394)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "definite") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@2d483477-9a2d-4049-968f-8f7120f43e51") >> ) >> ) >> (ImplicationLink >> (PredicateNode "won@349785b2-b0c2-4feb-bd51-29d7fffefc73") >> (PredicateNode "win" (stv 0.055555556 0.0012484394)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "won@349785b2-b0c2-4feb-bd51-29d7fffefc73") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@2d483477-9a2d-4049-968f-8f7120f43e51") >> (ConceptNode "game@85e71213-577b-4aa2-8412-da49e62ba2f4") >> ) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "won@349785b2-b0c2-4feb-bd51-29d7fffefc73") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@2d483477-9a2d-4049-968f-8f7120f43e51") >> ) >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (InterpretationNode "sentence@4603e95d-b5b8-4831-a >> 0ac-95f28feaa119_parse_0_interpretation_$X") >> (DefinedLinguisticConceptNode "DeclarativeSpeechAct") >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (PredicateNode "won@349785b2-b0c2-4feb-bd51-29d7fffefc73") >> (DefinedLinguisticConceptNode "past") >> ) >> ) >> ) >> >> and the question: >> >> (nlp-parse "Did Japan win the game?") >> >> (ReferenceLink >> (InterpretationNode "sentence@71d1be55-9c56-46d5-a >> 293-94c4d002feea_parse_0_interpretation_$X") >> (SetLink >> (InheritanceLink >> (ConceptNode "game@19f5a774-8b38-4d92-b6e5-f443e2115476") >> (ConceptNode "game" (stv 0.05882353 0.0024937657)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "definite") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "game@19f5a774-8b38-4d92-b6e5-f443e2115476") >> ) >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@6df1a66e-f269-460d-bd32-9f300dc4a607") >> (ConceptNode "Japan" (stv 0.05882353 0.0024937657)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "definite") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@6df1a66e-f269-460d-bd32-9f300dc4a607") >> ) >> ) >> (ImplicationLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> (PredicateNode "win" (stv 0.10526316 0.0024937657)) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "Truth Value") >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> ) >> (VariableNode "$O1UKaXxsl6dTKvIOxy67sJqT5cVPhF4uSq6o") >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@6df1a66e-f269-460d-bd32-9f300dc4a607") >> (ConceptNode "game@19f5a774-8b38-4d92-b6e5-f443e2115476") >> ) >> ) >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@6df1a66e-f269-460d-bd32-9f300dc4a607") >> ) >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (InterpretationNode "sentence@71d1be55-9c56-46d5-a >> 293-94c4d002feea_parse_0_interpretation_$X") >> (DefinedLinguisticConceptNode "TruthQuerySpeechAct") >> ) >> (InheritanceLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> (DefinedLinguisticConceptNode "past_infinitive") >> ) >> ) >> ) >> >> >> >> Soo, about this part: >> >> (EvaluationLink >> (DefinedLinguisticPredicateNode "Truth Value") >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "win@72e29756-e848-4eb8-8924-407072e74d5e") >> ) >> (VariableNode "$O1UKaXxsl6dTKvIOxy67sJqT5cVPhF4uSq6o") >> ) >> >> What do the nested EvaluationLink here mean? >> >> And what steps will the bc follow to ground the variable to this (if >> that's how it works): >> >> (EvaluationLink >> (PredicateNode "won@349785b2-b0c2-4feb-bd51-29d7fffefc73") >> (ListLink >> (ConceptNode "Japan@2d483477-9a2d-4049-968f-8f7120f43e51") >> (ConceptNode "game@85e71213-577b-4aa2-8412-da49e62ba2f4") >> ) >> ) >> >> >> I appreciate any help on this! (and sorry if these are trivial things) >> >> -- >> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups >> "opencog" group. >> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an >> email to [email protected]. >> To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. >> Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/opencog. >> To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/ms >> gid/opencog/a1e990db-df73-4372-8ef5-0931a0a8cb69%40googlegroups.com >> <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/opencog/a1e990db-df73-4372-8ef5-0931a0a8cb69%40googlegroups.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer> >> . >> For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout. >> > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "opencog" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/opencog. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/opencog/CAHrUA35K0Rrz%3DoCGgE8j%2BO3nRip3%2Bv2OWPretcEuXXkU7zEAwA%40mail.gmail.com. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
