On Sat, 2014-02-08 at 12:07 +0000, Laszlo Papp wrote: > Why is it a nightmare? For instance, maintainers in other projects > leave a "Pushed, thanks" note. > > See how much discussion this generates already, instead of two words. > While you are at the change to merge it, you are already in place to > leave the comment. However, contributors need to go and find the > corresponding url, etc. Please note that contributors may want to know > whether their voluntary work got merged without even a checkout, for > instance double checking from mobile, etc. > > ... or is the real problem the lack of maintainer man power?
Its both a man power problem and the process isn't as simple as described. The changes get batched together into large units, those get tested on the autobuilder. If they work out ok, the changes go in, if they fail, we pull out patches until we get a successful batch, then merge. Upon failures, we do aim to mention those on list. Having to go back through emails to find the ones which merge and "ack" them is a pain though since we are "not already in place" as you put it. There are only two people in general who do this on OE-Core, myself and Saul. We do have a ton of other pressures on our time, we do the best we can. If someone wants to ack patches that merge I'm happy for them to do so, it would be just as much work for them as it would for me/Saul. I am aware there are patch management tools out there which can show status of patches. We've looked hard at them and in general they impose more overhead and process onto people who don't want it. Cheers, Richard _______________________________________________ Openembedded-core mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openembedded.org/mailman/listinfo/openembedded-core
