Hi, It appears that the Intel's IMM Module is using FRU Device Id of 1 instead of 0, from the IPMI standard. It seems to be contradicting Section 30 (v.1.5) below:
".... FRU Device ID #00 at LUN 00b is predefined as being the FRU Device for the FRU that the management controller is located on...." On my older machine, "7.1 (Basbrd Mgmt Ctlr) mc present" has device id of 0. On my new machine, "7.1 (IMM Module FRU) fru present has device id of 1". I've added some FRU info to the above entities, and retrieve them on boot. On boot I relied on device id of 0 (relying on the basic ipmicmd -k). This means I can't retrieve my info on the newer machines. Here's the complete entities from both machines using ipmi_ui on smi 0. My older machines: 7.1 (Basbrd Mgmt Ctlr) mc present 32.1 (DIMM 1 SPD) fru present 32.2 (DIMM 2 SPD) fru present 32.3 (DIMM 3 SPD) fru present 32.4 (DIMM 4 SPD) fru present 29.1 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.2 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.3 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.4 (fan_cooling) unknown present 3.1 (processor) unknown present 3.2 (processor) unknown present 21.1 (power_management_board) unknown present 23.1 (system_chassis) unknown present My newer machine: 7.1 (IMM Module FRU) fru present 10.1 (Pwr Supply 1 FRU) fru present 10.2 (Pwr Supply 2 FRU) fru present 21.1 (Power Cage FRU) fru present 32.1 (DIMM 1A SPD) fru present 32.2 (DIMM 1B SPD) fru present 32.3 (DIMM 2A SPD) fru not present 32.4 (DIMM 2B SPD) fru not present 32.5 (DIMM 3A SPD) fru not present 32.6 (DIMM 3B SPD) fru not present 37.1 (group) unknown present 43.1 (processor/memory module) unknown present 43.2 (processor/memory module) unknown not present 32.7 (memory_device) unknown not present 32.8 (memory_device) unknown not present 23.1 (system_chassis) unknown present 34.1 (bios) unknown not present 38.1 (remote_mgmt_comm_device) unknown present 12.1 (front_panel_board) unknown present 29.1 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.2 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.3 (fan_cooling) unknown present 29.4 (fan_cooling) unknown present 7.2 (system_board) unknown not present 3.1 (processor) unknown present 3.2 (processor) unknown present 8.1 (memory_module) unknown not present 8.2 (memory_module) unknown present 8.3 (memory_module) unknown not present 8.4 (memory_module) unknown present 8.5 (memory_module) unknown not present 8.6 (memory_module) unknown present Thanks for any help that is offered. Michael ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys - and earn cash http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV _______________________________________________ Openipmi-developer mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openipmi-developer
