Michael,
On the Jarrell motherboard where the IMM resides, there is a default
mini-BMC and then the IMM plugin with IPMI 2.0 and the advanced
features. So, there are actually two BMCs, but only one is active at a
time. That is why the IMM has a FRU Device ID of 1, since the mini-BMC
occupied FRU ID 0.
This should not pose a problem, and attached is the output from
'fruconfig' (from ipmiutil) on a TIGI2U system with an IMM. You can see
from the attached immfru.txt that the SlaveAddress/ChannelNumber for the
IMM BMC is 20/00, while the SlaveAddress/FruDeviceID is 20/01.
The IPMI 1.5 text you reference is similar to text in section 37.7 about
the FRU Device ID, and is still true, since the mini-BMC on that
motherboard is FRU Device ID 0, but it is inactive.
Andy
-----Original Message-----
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
[mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, January 22, 2007 2:13 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: [Openipmi-developer] FRU dev id on IMM Module
Hi,
It appears that the Intel's IMM Module is using FRU Device Id of 1
instead of 0, from the IPMI standard. It seems to be contradicting
Section 30 (v.1.5) below:
".... FRU Device ID #00 at LUN 00b is predefined as being the FRU Device
for the FRU that the management controller is located on...."
On my older machine, "7.1 (Basbrd Mgmt Ctlr) mc present" has device id
of 0. On my new machine, "7.1 (IMM Module FRU) fru present has device
id of 1".
I've added some FRU info to the above entities, and retrieve them on
boot. On boot I relied on device id of 0 (relying on the basic ipmicmd
-k). This means I can't retrieve my info on the newer machines.
Here's the complete entities from both machines using ipmi_ui on smi 0.
My older machines:
7.1 (Basbrd Mgmt Ctlr) mc present
32.1 (DIMM 1 SPD) fru present
32.2 (DIMM 2 SPD) fru present
32.3 (DIMM 3 SPD) fru present
32.4 (DIMM 4 SPD) fru present
29.1 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.2 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.3 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.4 (fan_cooling) unknown present
3.1 (processor) unknown present
3.2 (processor) unknown present
21.1 (power_management_board) unknown present
23.1 (system_chassis) unknown present
My newer machine:
7.1 (IMM Module FRU) fru present
10.1 (Pwr Supply 1 FRU) fru present
10.2 (Pwr Supply 2 FRU) fru present
21.1 (Power Cage FRU) fru present
32.1 (DIMM 1A SPD) fru present
32.2 (DIMM 1B SPD) fru present
32.3 (DIMM 2A SPD) fru not present
32.4 (DIMM 2B SPD) fru not present
32.5 (DIMM 3A SPD) fru not present
32.6 (DIMM 3B SPD) fru not present
37.1 (group) unknown present
43.1 (processor/memory module) unknown present
43.2 (processor/memory module) unknown not present
32.7 (memory_device) unknown not present
32.8 (memory_device) unknown not present
23.1 (system_chassis) unknown present
34.1 (bios) unknown not present
38.1 (remote_mgmt_comm_device) unknown present
12.1 (front_panel_board) unknown present
29.1 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.2 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.3 (fan_cooling) unknown present
29.4 (fan_cooling) unknown present
7.2 (system_board) unknown not present
3.1 (processor) unknown present
3.2 (processor) unknown present
8.1 (memory_module) unknown not present
8.2 (memory_module) unknown present
8.3 (memory_module) unknown not present
8.4 (memory_module) unknown present
8.5 (memory_module) unknown not present
8.6 (memory_module) unknown present
Thanks for any help that is offered.
Michael
------------------------------------------------------------------------
-
Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT
Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share
your
opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys - and earn cash
http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDE
V
_______________________________________________
Openipmi-developer mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openipmi-developer
fruconfig: version 1.27
-- BMC version 0.53, IPMI version 2.0
SDR[004e] FRU 20 01 07 01 IMM Module FRU
Component FRU Size : 256
Board Mfg DateTime : Sun May 29 02:56:00 2005
Board Manufacturer : Intel
Board Product Name : Intel(R) Management Module - Advanced Edition
Board Serial Number : 523IMFA00296
Board Part Number : C44973-502
Board FRU File ID : FRU Ver 0.03
Board OEM Field :
Product Manufacturer:
Product Name :
Product Part Number :
Product Version :
Product Serial Num :
Product Asset Tag :
Product FRU File ID :
Product OEM Field :
SDR[004f] FRU 20 02 07 01 ADVC GCM NIC
Component FRU Size : 128
Board Mfg DateTime : Sun May 29 15:36:00 2005
Board Manufacturer : Intel
Board Product Name : GCM NIC Board
Board Serial Number : 0002B3F4104A235IMGC
Board Part Number : C44941-203
Board FRU File ID : FRU Ver 0.01
Board OEM Field :
Product Manufacturer:
Product Name :
Product Part Number :
Product Version :
Product Serial Num :
Product Asset Tag :
Product FRU File ID :
Product OEM Field :
SDR[0050] FRU 20 03 15 01 Power Cage FRU
Component FRU Size : 256
Product Manufacturer: DELTA
Product Name : AC-044 A
Product Part Number : C85874-003
Product Version : S2
Product Serial Num : DLC0514000181
Product Asset Tag :
Product FRU File ID :
SDR[0051] FRU 20 04 0a 01 Pwr Supply 1 FRU
Component FRU Size : 256
Product Manufacturer: DELTA
Product Name : DPS-600RB-1A
Product Part Number : C85873-005
Product Version : S4
Product Serial Num : DLD0537000114
Product Asset Tag :
Product FRU File ID :
SDR[0052] FRU 20 05 0a 02 Pwr Supply 2 FRU
Component FRU Size : 256
Product Manufacturer: DELTA
Product Name : DPS-600RB-1A
Product Part Number : C85873-005
Product Version : S4
Product Serial Num : DLD0537000106
Product Asset Tag :
Product FRU File ID :
SDR[0053] FRU 20 06 20 01 DIMM 1A SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51036cc7
SDR[0054] FRU 20 07 20 02 DIMM 1B SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51026ce6
SDR[0055] FRU 20 08 20 03 DIMM 2A SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51046cc8
SDR[0056] FRU 20 09 20 04 DIMM 2B SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51046ce0
SDR[0057] FRU 20 0a 20 05 DIMM 3A SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51016cd5
SDR[0058] FRU 20 0b 20 06 DIMM 3B SPD
Memory SPD Size : 128
Memory Type : SDRAM
Module Density : 256 MB per bank
Module Banks : 96 banks
Module Rows, Cols : 13 rows, 10 cols
DIMM Config Type : ECC
Manufacturer ID : Samsung (0xce)
Manufacturer Part# : M3 93T3253FG0-CCC
Manufacturer Rev : 30 46
Manufacturer Date : year=05 week=04
Assembly Serial Num : 51056cc9
SDR[0059] IPMB 20 00 07 01 Basbrd Mgmt Ctlr
SDR[005a] IPMB 28 00 07 01 Chs Bridge Ctlr
SDR[005b] IPMB c0 00 0f 01 Hot Swap Ctlr
Component FRU Size : 256
Board Mfg DateTime : Fri Apr 29 08:24:00 2005
Board Manufacturer : Intel
Board Product Name : TIGI2U FPIO HSC
Board Serial Number : AZLR51800047
Board Part Number : C87352-300
Board FRU File ID :
Mainboard FRU Size : 256
Chassis Type : Main Server Chassis
Chassis Part Number :
Chassis Serial Num :
Chassis OEM Field : TIGI2U
Board Mfg DateTime : Wed Jul 13 11:59:00 2005
Board Manufacturer : Intel
Board Product Name : SE7520JR23
Board Serial Number : BZJT52900200
Board Part Number : C94555-701
Board FRU File ID : FRU Ver 0.01
Board OEM Field :
Product Manufacturer: Intel
Product Name :
Product Part Number :
Product Version :
Product Serial Num :
Product Asset Tag : telco64
Product FRU File ID :
Product OEM Field :
System GUID : 3ca75685-08c5-11d7-c3a2-000423bcac12
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT
Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your
opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys - and earn cash
http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV
_______________________________________________
Openipmi-developer mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openipmi-developer
