On Tue, 10 May 2022 20:03:08 GMT, Marius Hanl <mh...@openjdk.org> wrote:
> A common reason for using the `TextFormatter` is the need for a `filter`.
> Therefore, the following constructor is typically used:
> `public TextFormatter(@NamedArg("filter") UnaryOperator<Change> filter) { ...
> }`
>
> With that, no `valueConverter` is set in the `TextFormatter`.
>
> When a `TextField` will commit his value, `TextFormatter.updateValue(...)` is
> called.
> Since `valueConverter` is null, an NPE is thrown and catched inside it and
> `TextFormatter.updateText()` is called (which will call
> `TextInputControl.updateText(...)`), which won't do anything either since
> `valueConverter` is still not set (=null).
>
> A minor improvement here is to just skip `TextFormatter.updateValue(...)` and
> therefore `TextFormatter.updateText()` (->
> `TextInputControl.updateText(...)`), since this methods won't do anything
> without a `valueConverter`.
> With that change, no exception (NPE) is thrown and catched, and therefore
> also exception breakpoints are not called (can be annoying ;)).
> This will also slightly increase the performance, as throwing exceptions is a
> (minor) bottleneck.
>
> Added tests for all `TextFormatter` functionalities, which pass before and
> after.
The fix and tests look good, with a couple requested changes.
modules/javafx.controls/src/main/java/javafx/scene/control/TextFormatter.java
line 40:
> 38: * <ul>
> 39: * <li>A filter ({@link #getFilter()}) that can intercept and modify
> user input. This helps to keep the text
> 40: * in the desired format. A default text supplier can be used to
> provide the initial text.</li>
I know this is a simple typo, but it is unrelated to your bug fix, and is in
public API docs, so I'd like to see it go in separately under a "Fix mistakes
in docs" bug. I filed
[JDK-8286678](https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8286678) to track this
and any other such issues that arise (as we've done for most recent releases).
modules/javafx.controls/src/main/java/javafx/scene/control/TextFormatter.java
line 202:
> 200:
> 201: void updateValue(String text) {
> 202: if (valueConverter != null &&!value.isBound()) {
Minor: please add a space between the `&&` and `!` operators.
-------------
PR: https://git.openjdk.java.net/jfx/pull/794
