John Plocher wrote:
> Darren Kenny wrote:
>> In this case, using the mv command, ... it cannot reconcile 
> 
> This seems to be a serious flaw that needs to get fixed.  No, I don't
> know how best to fix it, but I believe there are mechanisms in place
> to watch for filesystem changes and react....

Not sure how file event monitoring would deal with:

1.  a "mv" command by root while the user is not logged in

2.  a case where the user's home directory is on a remote NFS server, so 
that the "mv" command is not run on the system running the Gnome 
software.  Think of a NetApp box, for example...

Having said that:

> John Fischer wrote:
>> This filename is in a <dot> directory that is owned by the
>> user.  How is this any different from messing up ones
>> bookmarks?

On the one hand the directories subject to moving are at the top level, 
e.g. $HOME/Music.  Not dotfiles.

But on the other hand, I'm fairly sure that it I type "mv Music 
Music.old" on MacOS, the desktop does not track this and instead creates 
a new Music directory next time I fire up iTunes.  In fact, if using "mv 
Music Music.backup", I've relied on this in the past.  Sometimes the 
user may want the system to start with a new directory...

Hugh.

Reply via email to