Hi Vlada,

V pá, 18. 07. 2008 v 18:03, Vladimir Kotal píše:
> Doug Leavitt wrote:
> > Vladimir,
> 
> Hi Doug,
> 
> It's cool to see someone finally chimed in :)
> 
> > A couple of things:
> > 
> > 1) libresolv is a library tracked from the ISC bind9 distribution.
> >   So removing strsep from it is not something we do because we
> >   keep the code bases in sync, AFAIK.  Think of it as SFW software
> >   before there really was a SFW gate.  Ditto for sendmail.
> 
> libresolv2 changes removed.
> 
> I think you're only mentioning sendmail as an example of 3rd party 
> software living in ONNV and this comment has nothing to do with changes 
> done to usr/src/cmd/sendmail/db/config.h, correct ?
> 

I don't see reason why config.h should be changed. strsep() is available
now, so your config.h is correct.

> > 2) Secondly changing nss_ldap requires a significant amount of
> > testing [usually 2 experienced engineers 2 full days] on in about
> > 16 different combination runs:
> >     sparc/x86 x 32/64 x zones/no zones x normal/per-user
> > [this requires setting us a DS 6.x directory server for both SSL and 
> > Kerberos].
> 
> 2 full days for experienced engineers means at least 1 full week for me. 
> This is stuff I do in my spare time and spreading full week over 
> evenings and nights is 1 month of my time.
> 
> nss changes removed.
> 
> I can file a low priority CR against the duplicities removal in each 
> particular libary after the changes are in if anyone cares. The goal of 
> this integration is to provide strsep() in libc. Think of the removal of 
> duplicities as extra bonus.
> 

I know LDAP part of code, so, please, log P3 CR (code duplicity), I will
fix it, including testing.

> What about libsmb changes ? What about the rest of the changes ?
> 

No idea, you should go to people from CIFS server team.

[...]

> webrev refreshed:
>    http://cr.opensolaris.org/~vkotal/strsep_libc-webrev/
> 

My knowledge of adding new functions to libc is limited, but I think the
webrev is OK. Please, ask CIFS server people for their oppinion or log
the second CR for CIFS server.

Best regards,

Milan

_______________________________________________
opensolaris-code mailing list
opensolaris-code@opensolaris.org
http://mail.opensolaris.org/mailman/listinfo/opensolaris-code

Reply via email to