Prakash, Some responses inline.
Thanks, Bryan Sullivan | AT&T From: Prakash Ramchandran [mailto:prakash.ramchand...@huawei.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 06, 2016 6:53 PM To: opnfv-tech-discuss@lists.opnfv.org Cc: Margaret Chiosi <margaretchiosi.o...@gmail.com>; SULLIVAN, BRYAN L <bs3...@att.com>; denglin...@chinamobile.com; giuseppe.care...@fokus.fraunhofer.de; Ulas Kozat <ulas.ko...@huawei.com>; Yingjun Li <yingjun...@huawei.com>; artur.tyl...@canonical.com; dne...@redhat.com; sric...@gmail.com; bob.monk...@arm.com; christopher.pr...@ericsson.com; raghavendrachari.kams...@hpe.com; ljlam...@live.com Subject: [opnfv-tech-discuss][opnfv-mano-wg] Need Subscription list plus discussions for Sept 14 VNF onbaoarding & Mapping TOSCA service to NFV{VNFD+NSD} Hi all, There was a request from Margret that she cannot get this as without joining opnfv-tech-list and that she and many in Polestar/S&P would prefer that we have a separate opnnfv-mano-wg subscription. My understanding is that this will be addressed by LF helpdesk. Until then I am copying the listed participants of MANO WG on wiki page and this is for September 14th meeting. We still have a week's time to get things moving. If so can I request LF helpdesk to enable the opnfv-mano-wg subscription list. We do have #opnfv-mano channel that we use besides the scheduled As part of MANO WG tasks would like to initiate debate on following items: Like to verify with Models & Domino/parser if they would create a opnfv-mano-wg tags and create a Jira tickets for the same? [bryan] Not sure what you mean by tags or why we need to create Jira tickets. I recommend to avoid getting too deep into Jira for project management at the level that these groups work (analysis, experimentation, specification). My experience is that except for code dev/bug tracking, Jira brings a lot of overhead that I don't think we need. Outlining the work of the group at a high-level is fine with Jira, but let's watch out for the overhead. 1. VNF On boarding as listed by Polestar / S&P team by Bryan [bryan] I will add some of the aspects of this to the wiki, as I described on the call, including a high-level outline of a conceptual process for onboarding, highlighting aspects that I think are potentially in scope for OPNFV projects (including those underway, today). This is work that is in the scope of the MANO WG, since it helps draw a thread through many of the systems and processes that make up a MANO stack, and above (e.g. business processes that are outside OPNFV/OpenSource scope). ? VNF Packaging - Compare and contrast in how JuJu and Tacker use OpenStack Glance or SDN-C (ODL/ONOS/OC} {how do they align with IFA011?} [bryan] This analysis is underway (or at least in scope) in the Models project, as a test/documentation exercise. The current state of that project is setting up the test environment (Cloudify, Tacker, JuJu, OpenBaton, etc) to assess how MANO-stack projects require/support various VNF Package elements, starting with TOSCA-based blueprints for reference VNFs (which will become part of the OPNFV CI/CD inventory along with vIMS). I welcome the support of anyone that wants to focus on the specific question Prakash mentioned. 2. Mapping between TOSCA and NFV for using VNFD from oasis for VNFM to use (http://docs.oasis-open.org/tosca/tosca-nfv/v1.0/csd03/tosca-nfv-v1.0-csd03.pdf ) ? Review how Service Descriptors from TOSCA match with NFV and if mapped correctly can Template Distribution and Parsing manage this to deliver to orchestrators like Heat or any controller that can support Pub/Sub via OPNFV project like Domino/Parser? [bryan] VNF Package cataloging/distribution is one of the key aspects of an onboarding process. As mentioned AFAIK only the Domino project has been considering so far some of the technical approaches to blueprint/template distribution (along with other VNF assets). The mapping of elements (e.g. Service Descriptors) is part of the information model - data model analysis that needs to be done; work that so far is still in the SDO realm AFAICT. 3. Would like to see OPEN-O(Opera) / OpenBaton (Orchestra) to add any Jira tickets that will help them on IFA007, use case or API aspects that would like to bring to opnfv-mano-wg Once we know JIRA tickets are established will let Bryan lead us on 1 and will try bring some proposal for 2 working with Domino/Parser projects and PTLS of Opera and Orchestra as what they will need guidance from MANO WG to support them. Thanks Prakash Prakash Ramchandran [logo_huawei] R&D USA FutureWei Technologies, Inc Email: prakash.ramchand...@huawei.com<mailto:s.c...@huawei.com> Work: +1 (408) 330-5489 Mobile: +1 (408) 406-5810 2330 Central Expy, Santa Clara, CA 95050, USA
_______________________________________________ opnfv-tech-discuss mailing list opnfv-tech-discuss@lists.opnfv.org https://lists.opnfv.org/mailman/listinfo/opnfv-tech-discuss
