Hi Bernard, I agree. I checked in the newly built opkg meta rpms for ganglia with the same version number of ganglia at r6810. http://svn.oscar.openclustergroup.org/trac/oscar/browser/branches/branch-5-1/packages/ganglia/distro/fc8-i386
Anyway, when I was testing, I rebuilt the ganglia meta rpm without modifying its changelog entry(more specifically, I did not upgrade the version in the changelog entry). That's why my previous email shows the old version(3.0.5) of opkg-ganglia. Regards, - DongInn Bernard Li wrote: > Hi DongInn: > > Thanks for the fix. However, I think that each opkg release should be > tied to a specific version of the underlying package. i.e. this > release of ganglia opkg should only work with 3.0.6, which is the > tested version and the version that is checked into our repository. > > My $0.02. > > Cheers, > > Bernard > > On 1/1/08, DongInn Kim <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> OK, it was worth to try it. >> >> -------------------------------------- >> >> Dependencies Resolved >> 1199219982.55 >> >> ============================================================================= >> Package Arch Version Repository Size >> ============================================================================= >> Installing: >> opkg-disable-services-server noarch 1.1.0-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >> 1.7 k >> opkg-ganglia-server noarch 3.0.5-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 3.2 k >> opkg-lam-server noarch 7.1.4-7 oscar_fc-8-i386 3.7 k >> opkg-maui-server noarch 3.2.6p19-8 oscar_fc-8-i386 2.2 k >> opkg-mtaconfig-server noarch 1.1.0-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 4.7 k >> opkg-netbootmgr-server noarch 1.7-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 3.0 k >> opkg-ntpconfig-server noarch 2.0.1-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 3.9 k >> opkg-openmpi-server noarch 1.2.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 2.1 k >> opkg-opium-server noarch 1.6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 2.1 k >> opkg-pvm-server noarch 3.4.5+6-3 oscar_fc-8-i386 2.2 k >> opkg-torque-server noarch 2.1.8-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 4.2 k >> Installing for dependencies: >> ganglia-gmetad i686 3.0.6-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 84 k >> ganglia-gmond i686 3.0.6-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 214 k >> ganglia-web noarch 3.0.6-1 oscar_common-rpms 118 k >> lam-oscar i686 7.1.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 3.6 M >> lam-oscar-modulefile noarch 7.1.4-1 oscar_common-rpms 8.7 k >> lam-switcher-modulefile noarch 7.1.4-2.oscar oscar_common-rpms 7.6 >> k >> libaio i386 0.3.106-3.2 i386_os 19 k >> libaio-devel i386 0.3.106-3.2 i386_os 11 k >> maui-oscar i686 3.2.6p19-8 oscar_fc-8-i386 1.7 M >> netbootmgr noarch 1.7-1 oscar_common-rpms 60 k >> openmpi i686 1.2.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 5.2 M >> openmpi-switcher-modulefile noarch 1.2.4-1 oscar_common-rpms >> 7.0 k >> opkg-ganglia noarch 3.0.5-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 12 k >> php-gd i386 5.2.4-3 distro_fedora-8-i386 >> 111 k >> pvm i686 3.4.5+6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 2.6 M >> pvm-modules-oscar i686 3.4.5+6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 6.8 k >> rrdtool i386 1.3-0.1.beta1.fc8 i386_os 390 >> k >> ssh-oscar noarch 1.1-6 oscar_common-rpms 3.6 k >> tcsh i386 6.15-1.fc8 i386_os 468 k >> tk i386 1:8.4.15-5.fc8 distro_fedora-8-i386 >> 1.2 M >> torque i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 21 k >> torque-client i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 174 k >> torque-gui i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 240 k >> torque-modulefile noarch 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_common-rpms 2.5 k >> torque-mom i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 105 k >> torque-server i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 106 k >> >> Transaction Summary >> ============================================================================= >> Install 37 Package(s) >> Update 0 Package(s) >> Remove 0 Package(s) >> >> Total download size: 16 M >> Downloading Packages: >> using local copy of libaio - 0.3.106-3.2.i386 >> using local copy of rrdtool - 1.3-0.1.beta1.fc8.i386 >> using local copy of libaio-devel - 0.3.106-3.2.i386 >> using local copy of tcsh - 6.15-1.fc8.i386 >> Running rpm_check_debug >> Running Transaction Test >> Finished Transaction Test >> Transaction Test Succeeded >> Running Transaction >> Installing: torque ####################### [ 1/37] >> Installing: torque-modulefile ####################### [ 2/37] >> Installing: netbootmgr ####################### [ 3/37] >> Installing: opkg-ganglia ####################### [ 4/37] >> Installing: openmpi-switcher-modulefile ####################### [ 5/37] >> Installing: opkg-netbootmgr-server ####################### [ 6/37] >> Installing: opkg-ntpconfig-server ####################### [ 7/37] >> Installing: opkg-mtaconfig-server ####################### [ 8/37] >> Installing: opkg-disable-services-server ####################### [ 9/37] >> Installing: tcsh ####################### [10/37] >> Installing: pvm ####################### [11/37] >> Installing: tk ####################### [12/37] >> Installing: torque-client ####################### [13/37] >> Installing: lam-oscar ####################### [14/37] >> Installing: torque-server ####################### [15/37] >> Installing: php-gd ####################### [16/37] >> Installing: rrdtool ####################### [17/37] >> Installing: libaio ####################### [18/37] >> Installing: ganglia-gmetad ####################### [19/37] >> Installing: torque-mom ####################### [20/37] >> Installing: openmpi ####################### [21/37] >> Installing: torque-gui ####################### [22/37] >> Installing: ganglia-gmond ####################### [23/37] >> Installing: libaio-devel ####################### [24/37] >> Installing: ganglia-web ####################### [25/37] >> Installing: maui-oscar ####################### [26/37] >> Installing: lam-switcher-modulefile ####################### [27/37] >> Installing: lam-oscar-modulefile ####################### [28/37] >> Installing: pvm-modules-oscar ####################### [29/37] >> Installing: ssh-oscar ####################### [30/37] >> Installing: opkg-torque-server ####################### [31/37] >> Installing: opkg-maui-server ####################### [32/37] >> Installing: opkg-opium-server ####################### [33/37] >> Installing: opkg-openmpi-server ####################### [34/37] >> Installing: opkg-ganglia-server ####################### [35/37] >> Installing: opkg-pvm-server ####################### [36/37] >> Installing: opkg-lam-server ####################### [37/37] >> >> Installed: opkg-disable-services-server.noarch 0:1.1.0-1 >> opkg-ganglia-server.noarch 0:3.0.5-2 opkg-lam-server.noarch 0:7.1.4-7 >> opkg-maui-server.noarch 0:3.2.6p19-8 opkg-mtaconfig-server.noarch 0:1.1.0-1 >> opkg-netbootmgr-server.noarch 0:1.7-1 opkg-ntpconfig-server.noarch 0:2.0.1-1 >> opkg-openmpi-server.noarch 0:1.2.4-1 opkg-opium-server.noarch 0:1.6-2 >> opkg-pvm-server.noarch 0:3.4.5+6-3 opkg-torque-server.noarch 0:2.1.8-2 >> Dependency Installed: ganglia-gmetad.i686 0:3.0.6-1 ganglia-gmond.i686 >> 0:3.0.6-1 ganglia-web.noarch 0:3.0.6-1 lam-oscar.i686 0:7.1.4-1 >> lam-oscar-modulefile.noarch 0:7.1.4-1 lam-switcher-modulefile.noarch >> 0:7.1.4-2.oscar libaio.i386 0:0.3.106-3.2 libaio-devel.i386 0:0.3.106-3.2 >> maui-oscar.i686 0:3.2.6p19-8 netbootmgr.noarch 0:1.7-1 openmpi.i686 >> 0:1.2.4-1 openmpi-switcher-modulefile.noarch 0:1.2.4-1 opkg-ganglia.noarch >> 0:3.0.5-2 php-gd.i386 0:5.2.4-3 pvm.i686 0:3.4.5+6-2 pvm-modules-oscar.i686 >> 0:3.4.5+6-2 rrdtool.i386 0:1.3-0.1.beta1.fc8 ssh-oscar.noarch 0:1.1-6 >> tcsh.i386 0:6.15-1.fc8 tk.i386 1:8.4.15-5.fc8 torque.i686 0:2.1.8-3oscar >> torque-client.i686 0:2.1.8-3oscar torque-gui.i686 0:2.1.8-3oscar >> torque-modulefile.noarch 0:2.1.8-3oscar torque-mom.i686 0:2.1.8-3oscar >> torque-server.i686 0:2.1.8-3oscar >> Complete! >> >> -------------------------------------- >> >> Once the ganglia dependency issues are resolved, everything else seemed to >> work just fine. >> The fix was checked in on r6810. >> http://svn.oscar.openclustergroup.org/trac/oscar/changeset/6810 >> >> I will post further how the installation of branch-5-1 goes on Fedora 8 X86. >> >> Regards, >> >> - DongInn >> >> >> DongInn Kim wrote: >>> Hi Bernard, >>> >>> I like the idea yum can handle this kind of issues when the version of >>> oscar packages is newer than the distro one (e.g., ganglia from Fedora 8). >>> Sure, we can do a workaround as you mentioned. I think it is a worthwhile >>> attempt. >>> I will try and let you know what happens. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> - DongInn >>> >>> >>> Bernard Li wrote: >>>> Shouldn't the Ganglia opkg package require specific version of Ganglia >>>> (i.e. 3.0.6) -- in this case the Ganglia version which came from the >>>> distribution (3.0.5) will not be selected. >>>> >>>> Cheers, >>>> >>>> Bernard >>>> >>>> On 1/1/08, DongInn Kim <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >>>>> Hi, >>>>> >>>>> I found that setting up oscar on Fedora 8 is not as easy as on all the >>>>> other linux distros that we support. >>>>> (test r6708 on Fedora 8-X86) >>>>> >>>>> Most importantly, yum can not really handle the dependency of some >>>>> packages on Fedora 8. Especially there is a Fedora 8 ganglia (3.0.5) >>>>> competing with ganglia-3.0.6 ported on branch-5-1. There are some >>>>> problems on resolving the dependencies on two different versions of >>>>> ganglia. Because of that, oscar could not finish the installation of >>>>> ganglia. >>>>> >>>>> I think there are more but the obvious conflicts are from the ganglia one >>>>> now. >>>>> Here is what I found on oscarinstall.log. >>>>> >>>>> ------------------------------------------------ >>>>> >>>>> Dependencies Resolved >>>>> 1199162148.52 >>>>> >>>>> ============================================================================= >>>>> Package Arch Version Repository >>>>> Size >>>>> ============================================================================= >>>>> Installing: >>>>> opkg-disable-services-server noarch 1.1.0-1 >>>>> oscar_fc-8-i386 1.7 k >>>>> opkg-ganglia-server noarch 3.0.5-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 3.2 k >>>>> opkg-lam-server noarch 7.1.4-7 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 3.7 k >>>>> opkg-maui-server noarch 3.2.6p19-8 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 2.2 k >>>>> opkg-mtaconfig-server noarch 1.1.0-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 4.7 k >>>>> opkg-netbootmgr-server noarch 1.7-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 3.0 k >>>>> opkg-ntpconfig-server noarch 2.0.1-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 3.9 k >>>>> opkg-openmpi-server noarch 1.2.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 2.1 k >>>>> opkg-opium-server noarch 1.6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 2.1 k >>>>> opkg-pvm-server noarch 3.4.5+6-3 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 2.2 k >>>>> opkg-torque-server noarch 2.1.8-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 4.2 k >>>>> Installing for dependencies: >>>>> ganglia-gmetad i686 3.0.6-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 84 k >>>>> ganglia-gmetad i386 3.0.5-1.fc8 i386_os >>>>> 85 k >>>>> ganglia-gmond i686 3.0.6-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 214 k >>>>> ganglia-web i386 3.0.5-1.fc8 i386_os >>>>> 118 k >>>>> lam-oscar i686 7.1.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 3.6 M >>>>> lam-oscar-modulefile noarch 7.1.4-1 oscar_common-rpms >>>>> 8.7 k >>>>> lam-switcher-modulefile noarch 7.1.4-2.oscar oscar_common-rpms >>>>> 7.6 k >>>>> libaio i386 0.3.106-3.2 i386_os >>>>> 19 k >>>>> libaio-devel i386 0.3.106-3.2 i386_os >>>>> 11 k >>>>> maui-oscar i686 3.2.6p19-8 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 1.7 M >>>>> netbootmgr noarch 1.7-1 oscar_common-rpms >>>>> 60 k >>>>> openmpi i686 1.2.4-1 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 5.2 M >>>>> openmpi-switcher-modulefile noarch 1.2.4-1 >>>>> oscar_common-rpms 7.0 k >>>>> php-gd i386 5.2.4-3 distro_fedora-8-i386 >>>>> 111 k >>>>> pvm i686 3.4.5+6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 2.6 M >>>>> pvm-modules-oscar i686 3.4.5+6-2 oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 6.8 k >>>>> rrdtool i386 1.3-0.1.beta1.fc8 i386_os >>>>> 390 k >>>>> ssh-oscar noarch 1.1-6 oscar_common-rpms >>>>> 3.6 k >>>>> tcsh i386 6.15-1.fc8 i386_os >>>>> 468 k >>>>> tk i386 1:8.4.15-5.fc8 distro_fedora-8-i386 >>>>> 1.2 M >>>>> torque i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 21 k >>>>> torque-client i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 174 k >>>>> torque-gui i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 240 k >>>>> torque-modulefile noarch 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_common-rpms >>>>> 2.5 k >>>>> torque-mom i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 105 k >>>>> torque-server i686 2.1.8-3oscar oscar_fc-8-i386 >>>>> 106 k >>>>> >>>>> Transaction Summary >>>>> ============================================================================= >>>>> Install 37 Package(s) >>>>> Update 0 Package(s) >>>>> Remove 0 Package(s) >>>>> >>>>> Total download size: 17 M >>>>> Downloading Packages: >>>>> (2/37): tcsh-6.15-1.fc8.i 100% |=========================| 468 kB 00:00 >>>>> (4/37): libaio-devel-0.3. 100% |=========================| 11 kB 00:00 >>>>> (10/37): ganglia-gmetad-3 100% |=========================| 85 kB 00:00 >>>>> (19/37): rrdtool-1.3-0.1. 100% |=========================| 390 kB 00:00 >>>>> (23/37): ganglia-web-3.0. 100% |=========================| 118 kB 00:00 >>>>> (28/37): libaio-0.3.106-3 100% |=========================| 19 kB 00:00 >>>>> Running rpm_check_debug >>>>> ERROR with rpm_check_debug vs depsolve: >>>>> Package ganglia-web needs ganglia-gmetad = 3.0.5-1.fc8, this is not >>>>> available. >>>>> Complete! >>>>> >>>>> ------------------------------------------------ >>>>> >>>>> As you can see, even though some packages (or most packages) could not be >>>>> installed because of the dependencies, the process of the Step 3 >>>>> "Install OSCAR Server" passed. >>>>> That made me believe that all the OSCAR server packages are fully >>>>> installed/configured. But apparently not. >>>>> >>>>> FYI, I used the following .url file. >>>>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] ~]# cat /tftpboot/distro/fedora-8-i386.url >>>>> file:/tftpboot/distro/fedora-8-i386 >>>>> http://ftp.ussg.iu.edu/linux/fedora/linux/releases/8/Everything/i386/os >>>>> >>>>> Regards, >>>>> >>>>> -- >>>>> - DongInn >>>>> >>>>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>>> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft >>>>> Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. >>>>> http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ >>>>> _______________________________________________ >>>>> Oscar-devel mailing list >>>>> [email protected] >>>>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel >>>>> >>>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------- >>>> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft >>>> Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. >>>> http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ >>>> _______________________________________________ >>>> Oscar-devel mailing list >>>> [email protected] >>>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel >>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------- >>> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft >>> Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. >>> http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Oscar-devel mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel >> ------------------------------------------------------------------------- >> This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft >> Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. >> http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ >> _______________________________________________ >> Oscar-devel mailing list >> [email protected] >> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel >> > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft > Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. > http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ > _______________________________________________ > Oscar-devel mailing list > [email protected] > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel ------------------------------------------------------------------------- This SF.net email is sponsored by: Microsoft Defy all challenges. Microsoft(R) Visual Studio 2005. http://clk.atdmt.com/MRT/go/vse0120000070mrt/direct/01/ _______________________________________________ Oscar-devel mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/oscar-devel
