Hi Robert, My first impression was also to set this on the PrimitiveSet...
But I use it since a year now, and I find it's easier to define it as a SateAttribute. The idea of this new OpenGL feature is : - set RestartIndex = "n" - draw elements strip -> when the index is "n", the strip is "stopped" and restarted It's very usefull for drawing tiles with a single strip and a "restart" at the end of each row. The idea a an OSG StateAttribute is : Usually we use to build geometry from code, because software modelers rarely support it (and 3d file formats doesn't support it) : -RootNode <= "PrimitiveRestartIndex=0" // So now, we know that our restart index is 0 for all drawables under this node | - Drawable 1 : triangles => as usual | - Drawable 2 : triangles strip => as usual | - Drawable 3 : triangles strip + "GL_PRIMITIVE_RESTART" mode = ON => use the restart index | - Drawable 4 : triangles strip + "GL_PRIMITIVE_RESTART" mode = ON => use the restart index | - Drawable 5 : triangles strip => as usual With a StateAttribute, it's easy for the developper to say "0 will be my restart index for all this object" and then activate the mode only on some nodes. The main problem is if you set and restart index value which is not included in the vertex array (for exemple set restart index = 100 but you have only 50 vertex). There is no problem with OpenGL, but some OSG algorithms will try to access the vertex[100] and will segfault. To solve this, I think there is two ways : 1/ add restart index in osg::PrimitiveSet and use this value in all algorithms. It's a lot of work, maybe dangerous, and it concern only a few situations : developpers who use this extension should be aware of advanced OpenGL (and OSG) data management 2/ use a StateAttribute, and choose a "correct" restart index. In my applications, I always use "0" as a restart index and duplicate the first vertex (vertex[0] = vertex[1]). So there is no difference for OpenGL and all OSG algorithms works properly. Cheers, Aurelien ------------------ Read this topic online here: http://forum.openscenegraph.org/viewtopic.php?p=52789#52789 _______________________________________________ osg-submissions mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openscenegraph.org/listinfo.cgi/osg-submissions-openscenegraph.org
