http://pajamasmedia.com/2007/02/power_faith_and_fantasy_in_the.php

An Interview with Historian Michael Oren on the Tangled Web of US Involvement 
from the age of Jefferson to Today

by Michael J. Totten, Pajamas Media, 20 February 2007

 

 

"You cannot withdraw from Iraq and be confident that the enemy is not going to 
follow you. Because the enemy is going to follow you. America can't detach from 
the Middle East because the Middle East is not going to detach from America. 
And America's going to have to learn to fight this fight to win in a much more 
prudent and effective way. And there are ways America can fight it more 
effectively."

- Michael Oren

 

 

PORTLAND, OREGON - Renowned American-Israeli historian and best-selling author 
Michael Oren is touring the United States promoting his new book Power, Faith, 
and Fantasy, a sweeping history of America's involvement in the Middle East 
from 1776 to the present. It's the first and only book on the subject ever 
written, and it's current inching toward the top of the New York Times 
best-seller list for non- fiction.

 

I first met Michael Oren under Katyusha rocket fire when he worked as a 
Spokesman for the IDF Northern Command in Israel during last summer's war 
against Hezbollah, and I met him again when he came to my home town of 
Portland, Oregon, last week on his book tour.

 

 

MJT: So tell us, Michael, why does America's involvement in the Middle East 200 
years ago matter today? What does it have to do with September 11 and Iraq?

 

Oren: Well it matters, Michael, because many of the same issues that Americans 
are facing today in the Middle East were confronted by America's founding 
fathers - Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, George Washington. For example, they 
had to confront the issue of state-sponsored terrorism in the Middle East. They 
had to face a threat to the United States, and decide whether to generate 
military power and then project that power thousands of miles from the United 
States. They had to decide whether to involve the United States in an 
open-ended and rather expensive bloody war in the Middle East. This was, of 
course, the Barbary War, America's first overseas military engagement and 
America's longest overseas military engagement. It lasted from 1783 to 1815. 
During the course of this engagement, as my book shows, the United States was 
confronting a jihadist state-sponsored terrorist network that was taking 
Americans hostage in the Middle East. It's very similar to what is going on 
today.

 

 

MJT: They were more than hostages, they were slaves, weren't they?

 

Oren: They were slaves. But beyond the military component - the book is not a 
military history, it's also a diplomatic, cultural, artistic, and economic 
history - I wanted to show Americans today that our experience in the Middle 
East has very deep roots. Overall it's a story of magnificent things that 
America did for the Middle East. It wasn't always about confrontation, it was 
also about schools and hospitals and building for development and artistic 
inspiration and cooperation.

 

MJT: You write that the American government was paying these North African 
states, bribing them basically, to stop taking our ships and enslaving our 
civilians; paying at the rate 20 percent of the federal budget at one point?

 

Oren: The Adams Administration in 1790s was paying about 20 percent of its 
federal revenues in bribery to the Middle Eastern pirates. Thomas Jefferson was 
from the opposing school. He said that the more you paid off the pirates the 
more bribery they would demand. Jefferson said that any treaty signed with any 
individual pirate ruler - whether they be from Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, or 
Libya - that treaty would only be good as long as the ruler's life.

 

We can see how American leaders later on in American history didn't heed 
Jefferson's advice. Take Ronald Reagan in the 1980s. He sold Iran arms in an 
attempt to induce the Iranians to kidnap fewer Americans in Lebanon. He 
basically violated Thomas Jefferson's first rule in the Barbary Wars.

 

 

MJT: Do you think there's a similarity with the United States paying the 
Egyptian government 2 billion dollars a year? Some say this is a way of 
preserving Egypt's cold peace with Israel.

 

Oren: It's more to keep the Egyptian government, Hosni Mubarak, in power. 
There's a very large Muslim extremist Brotherhood in Egypt that is a contender 
for power. It hates the government, it hates America, it certainly hates 
Israel. They hope that by giving Egypt this money - and Egypt is a Third World 
country, this money is needed literally to buy bread - they can keep Mubarak in 
power. One of the benefits of keeping Mubarak in power is the maintenance of 
the Israeli-Egyptian peace treaty, but that's not the only benefit.

 

 

MJT: One thing that stood out for me, especially at the beginning of the book, 
is how much Arab North Africa is different now than it was. I don't think 
anybody can imagine Morocco or Tunisia enslaving civilians from the United 
States or from any other country.

 

Oren: They were part of what was then known to Americans, indeed to Westerners, 
as the Orient. It is not a geographical designation because much of the Orient, 
like Tunisia and Morocco, lies to the West of much of Western Europe. 
Westerners knew, though, that when they crossed the Mediterranean they were 
entering Islamic Civilization.

 

And that to them was Oriental. The distinction between North Africa and the 
Middle East didn't exist back then. It was all part of the Orient. The Arabs 
had a notion of a distinction between the western Islamic world and the eastern 
Arab world. But that distinction didn't exist in the Western world at all. It's 
a very contemporary designation.

 

 

MJT: When speaking of the Barbary War you used the word "jihad." I don't think 
you used that word in your book, though, did you?

 

Oren: No, I didn't really have to. There was the case in 1785 where Thomas 
Jefferson is sent to negotiate with the envoy of the Pasha of Tripoli. 
Jefferson says to him that America only wants peace with the Barbary states. 
And he says to Jefferson "No, we want war with you. We have a holy book called 
the Koran which says that we have to conquer and enslave all infidel states. 
And the United States is an infidel state. And moreover our holy book the Koran 
tells us that if we are killed in the course of carrying out this war that 
we'll go directly to Paradise." So I didn't think I even had to put the label 
jihadist on there. I figured that remarkable report of Jefferson's at the 
Continental Congress would suffice to alert contemporary readers what Jefferson 
was dealing with in the Middle East.

 

 

MJT: You wrote about how Americans 200 years ago were thinking of the United 
States as their own Zion and comparing themselves to the Israelites. This long 
predates the founding of the state of Israel. This idea is much older than 
[founder of the Zionist movement] Theodore Herzl.

 

Oren: Much older. This goes back to the time of the Puritans, to the 17th 
Century. The Puritans had appropriated the biblical narrative. They saw 
themselves as the new Israel. They had escaped bondage in England, in Egypt, 
you know? They crossed the Atlantic Ocean, which was their Sinai. They 
inherited a promised land, which was the New World. They gave one thousand 
biblical names to their cities and towns. They gave biblical names to their 
sons and daughters. They made Hebrew a required language at their universities. 
James Madison was a Hebrew major.

 

As a result Americans felt a particular kinship with the old Jews, as though 
they were sort of cousins. They felt a very strong attachment to the old 
promised land of Palestine. And they concluded that as good Christians and good 
Americans it was incumbent on them to help God fulfill his biblical promises to 
the Jews to rescue them from exile and to restore them to the promised land. 
This was the notion of Restorationism. It was very common in colonial America 
well into the 19th Century and even into the 20th Century. And it's the origin 
of today's Evangelical support for Israel.

 

 

MJT: Fascinating. I had no idea about any of this. Most Americans probably 
don't.

 

Oren: I had no idea about it before I wrote about it.

 

 

MJT: I can't help but think this is part of why Americans support Israel more 
than Europeans do. It's not just for political reasons. The two countries do 
have a lot in common. Native Europeans never went far from where they were from 
to found another state. A lot of Israelis were born in Israel, of course, but 
huge numbers weren't. Their experience is a bit like America's writ small.

 

Oren: Also that Israel is a democracy resonates very strongly among Americans. 
Americans take their democracy more seriously than most Europeans. But more to 
the point, America is also the most faithful country in the Western world. 
There's a strong sense of faith-based attachment to Israel. And not only among 
Evangelicals. The most recent poll by Gallup shows that 70 percent of Americans 
support Israel. Evangelicals in this country only make up about a fifth of the 
population. That means there's another 50 percent of the population that 
supports Israel for reasons other than Jesus' Second Coming.

 

 

MJT: In your book you show how the Middle East was connected to our Civil War 
in some ways at the time. Yet it seems there should be no connection at all. 
Tell us about that.

 

Oren: Oh, there are many connections. During the Civil War about 500 Egyptian 
soldiers served with the French Army invading Mexico. It was the only time 
Arabic- speaking Muslims have fought on North American soil. One of the people 
involved in Abraham Lincoln's assassination plot managed to escape to and was 
arrested in Egypt. There were Civil War officers - Union and Confederate 
officers - who went to Egypt right after the war to help modernize the Egyptian 
army. They ended up building a school system for Egypt, as well as exploring 
and mapping the Sudan.

 

The biggest impact of the Civil War was on the Middle East rather than the 
Middle East on the Civil War. The biggest impact was cotton. When the North 
blockaded Southern cotton the textile mills of Europe went dry. So they turned 
to the only other place in the world that had cotton of a similar quality and 
that was in Egypt. The price of Egyptian cotton went up about 800 times. Egypt 
made a lot of money. And with that money they built wonderful buildings and 
palaces, they built the opera house where Verdi used to perform, and they also 
built the Suez Canal which completely changed the face of the Middle East.

 

In 1869 the cotton market in the South came back and the Egyptian cotton market 
went bankrupt. Egypt went bankrupt and that led to the British occupation of 
Egypt that lasted for 70 years. There was actually a direct line between the 
Civil War and the Suez crisis of 1956 during which the Egyptians tried to 
nationalize the Suez Canal. Britain and France invaded. And so, really, the 
reverberations from the American Civil War in certain ways continue to course 
across the Middle East.

 

 

MJT: Americans have been trying to modernize and liberalize the Middle East for 
two centuries. George W. Bush isn't the first person to think of this idea and 
do something about it. The religious missionaries have been at it for a long 
time, and not just to convert people to Christianity. They built schools and 
promoted liberal secular American values.

 

 

MJT: Are we naïve? Arrogant? Should we give this up or do we have the right 
idea here?

 

Oren: We have the right idea, but we have to realize there is a limit to how 
much our ideas are appropriate to or can be adapted by the peoples of the 
Middle East.

 

I'll give you an example. We think of democracy as putting a ballot in the box 
every four years. People in the Middle East look at democracy and they see a 
package. Yes, it's putting a ballot in a box. But it's also giving rights to 
women, rights for children to marry whom they want when they want. The right to 
be secular. The right to have free speech. None of these ideas are going to 
take root in the Middle East very fast. Believe me. They look at democracy and 
they see a civilization that has lost many of its family values, given to drugs 
and alcohol, is full of sexual promiscuity. They don't want that.

 

 

MJT: You're saying that when we say "democracy" they hear liberalism.

 

Oren: When we say "democracy" they see Western modernity. And they don't want 
it.

 

 

MJT: Some of them do, butŠ

 

Oren: They don't want to pay the price for it. And the price is that their kids 
are going to marry whomever they want, their kids are going to marry people of 
different religions, of different colors, their wives are going to drive cars 
and go to work and maybe their wives will go out with other men before they get 
married. They don't want that.

 

 

MJT: It's interesting how they associate all these things that they view as 
decadent with democracy. They do go hand in hand, but that isn't necessarily 
required.

 

Oren: Democracy means freedom, and freedom is a package. You can't pick and 
shop. You can't say we want free speech but we don't want freedom for women. 
You can't say we want balloting but we don't want freedom of assembly.

 

 

MJT: You wrote about the Reagan Administration's incoherent foreign policy, how 
they traded anti-tank missiles for hostages in Iran - they bribed the Iranians, 
basically, like the U.S. did with the Barbary Pirates. The Reagan 
Administration flip- flopped on the PLO, bumbled into and out of Lebanon. You 
used the word "bewilderment" in your description of Reagan and his staff.

 

Lebanese-American professor Fouad Ajami used the same word in his recent book 
The Foreigner's Gift, which is about the Americans in Iraq. He wrote a whole 
chapter called "The Liberator's Bewilderment." This is something we keep 
running into. Is this our fault? Or is the Middle East just inherently 
incomprehensible to Americans because of the cultural gap?

 

Oren: I tend to think of Americans in the Middle East the way Mark Twain 
thought of them, more or less as Innocents Abroad. We stumble into the Middle 
East with the best of intentions and we manage to find ourselves in all sorts 
of predicaments. Reagan was engaged in combat operations against the Syrians 
and the Libyans at various times, and then against the Iranians. Nobody 
remembers that American played a pivotal role in securing the independence of 
Libya, Syria, and Iran. America came to these countries in the post-war world 
with, really, the best of intentions.

 

America didn't want to pick a fight with the Libyans. America didn't want to 
pick a fight with the Syrians. But America ends up fighting the Syrians in 1982 
and 1983 because the Syrians wanted to overthrow the democratically elected 
government in Lebanon.

 

 

MJT: In our 200 plus years of involvement what do you think are our greatest 
successes and our greatest failures in the Middle East?

 

Oren: Our greatest successes have been building the modern school systems in 
the Middle East, introducing the idea of secular nationalism. The United States 
built the infrastructure of Arab oil. That the producers of Arab oil chose to 
squander the greatest resource in human history and not devote it to 
development and science is not the fault of the United States. We certainly 
created the wherewithal for them to make the choice. And America has liberated 
a great many people in the Middle East from Ottoman oppression and European 
occupation.

 

 

MJT: What about the biggest failures?

 

Oren: The Mossadeq overthrow in 1953 [in Iran] was completely unnecessary and 
gratuitous. Saving [Egyptian dictator Gamal Abdel] Nasser in 1956 was probably 
the single worst mistake made by any American administration.

 

If Eisenhower hadn't saved Nasser there would have been no Six Day War, no 1973 
war, no occupation [of the West Bank and Gaza], no intifadas, no settlements.

 

 

MJT: The CIA helped put Nasser in power, too.

 

Oren: They did. And if Woodrow Wilson had declared war against the Ottoman 
Empire during World War I the Middle East today would look much different. That 
also was a big mistake.

 

 

MJT: What surprised you most when researching your book?

 

Oren: The faith component. I knew it was there, but I didn't know how big it 
really was. I actually had to tone it down in the book. Otherwise it could have 
been called American Faith in the Middle East. I wanted to get Power and 
Fantasy in their somewhere.

 

The fact is America has acted on one hand as a Christian country and on the 
other hand as a democratic country. In both cases it has this irrepressible 
urge to export its religion and its civic faith to the Middle East. And we find 
that these are the major leitmotifs in America's engagement in the course of 
over 200 years. It's amazing.

 

 

MJT: We've talked about the Power and Faith components here. Tell us something 
about Fantasy.

 

Oren: The fantasy has very deep roots. It goes back to the 18th Century, back 
to the second most popular book on the American colonial book shelf which was 
One Thousand and One Arabian Nights. It was the second most popular book after 
the Bible. Everyone in America at the time read it. Everyone believed it. 
Everyone believed all these fantastic tales about the Middle East, that that's 
what the Middle East really looked like.

 

Starting in the 19th Century Americans started flocking there in great numbers. 
Thousands of them were going. Great American writers like Herman Melville, Mark 
Twain, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Frederick Douglas came to the Middle East. Also 
statesman. Ulysses S. Grant, General Sherman, George McClellan, they were all 
lured by this fantasy.

 

By the 20th Century these fantasies were being appropriated by Hollywood. Some 
of Hollywood's earliest blockbusters were Middle Eastern romances. And they're 
still making Middle Eastern fantasy movies. They don't go away. It's amazing.

 

 

MJT: What's the most recent one?

 

Oren: I guess Babel in a certain way. I haven't seen it, though, so I want to 
withhold judgment.

 

 

MJT: I saw it, it's not bad. And it's reasonably realistic.

 

 

Oren: I'll have to see it. There was a movie a couple of years ago called 
Hidalgo about a horse race across Arabia. Total Middle East fantasy.

 

MJT: You have taken the long view of American involvement in the Middle East 
perhaps more than anyone else in the world. Having done that, are you more 
optimistic or pessimistic about the future?

 

Oren: As a historian I'm optimistic. Listen, I view the war in Iraq not as a 
war, but as a battle in a much more protracted war. Iraq is America's Bull Run 
in the war in the Middle East. It's our first losing battle.

 

It is not Vietnam. You cannot withdraw from Iraq and be confident that the 
enemy is not going to follow you. Because the enemy is going to follow you. 
America can't detach from the Middle East because the Middle East is not going 
to detach from America. And America's going to have to learn to fight this 
fight to win in a much more prudent and effective way. And there are ways 
America can fight it more effectively.

 

 

MJT: What do you suggest?

 

Oren: I suggest America invest very heavily in intelligence and training an 
entire generation of service women and men to speak the languages, be 
conversant in the languages and the cultures of the Middle East. America has to 
invest much more heavily in intelligence gathering. America has to invest much 
more heavily in rapid response forces in the Middle East and retain them there.

 

America has to get involved in theology. We've been fighting a theology with an 
ideology. It doesn't work. We have to get in the business of promoting a 
reformist Islam. It's important. It's controversial, but important.

 

 

MJT: How do we do that? Do you mean by promoting the moderates who already 
exist?

 

Oren: Well there are some moderates who exist. They don't have any places where 
they can go out and speak and speak free of harm. We can help disseminate their 
ideas. Right now the extreme Wahhabi interpretation of Islam predominates in 
schools across Europe. The West has basically given up the field to these 
people.

 

 

Michael Oren is the of the best-selling books Six Days of War and Power, Faith, 
and Fantasy. He is a graduate of Princeton and Yale Universities and works as a 
Senior Fellow at the Shalem Center in Jerusalem.

 

Michael J. Totten's work has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, Time, 
Newsweek, Reason, LA Weekly, TCS Daily, and Beirut's Daily Star. Visit his blog 
at http://michaeltotten.com.

 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> 
Something is new at Yahoo! Groups.  Check out the enhanced email design.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/kOt0.A/gOaOAA/yQLSAA/TySplB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~-> 

--------------------------
Want to discuss this topic?  Head on over to our discussion list, [EMAIL 
PROTECTED]
--------------------------
Brooks Isoldi, editor
[EMAIL PROTECTED]

http://www.intellnet.org

  Post message: [email protected]
  Subscribe:    [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  Unsubscribe:  [EMAIL PROTECTED]


*** FAIR USE NOTICE. This message contains copyrighted material whose use has 
not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. OSINT, as a part of 
The Intelligence Network, is making it available without profit to OSINT 
YahooGroups members who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the 
included information in their efforts to advance the understanding of 
intelligence and law enforcement organizations, their activities, methods, 
techniques, human rights, civil liberties, social justice and other 
intelligence related issues, for non-profit research and educational purposes 
only. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of the copyrighted material 
as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use 
this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' 
you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/osint/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 

Reply via email to