This is a discussion that belongs on par@perl.org rather than a bug,
isn't it?

Dorian Taylor via RT wrote:
>>> I propose that PAR::Packer be given a switch to strip out 
>>> architecture-dependent (i.e. XS) modules from the dependency
>>> inclusion list when packing a PAR. If I missed a method of doing
>>> this, then please direct me to it.

It seems to me that what you're looking for is a switch guaranteed to
produce broken distributions. If you want to produce a pure-perl distro
that will work on Windows, then start from a pure-perl installation, not
one that uses XS-based modules.

> I'm not trying to make work for anybody here; I'm content to write
> the code myself. I find it puzzling that the desire to only pack
> pure-perl module dependencies into a PAR has never come up before.

So I'd suggest you code it up and show everybody. That may resolve
people's doubts about the worthiness of the idea.

There've been a couple of useful suggestions about possible implementations.

Cheers, Dave

Reply via email to