________________________________
White first. African second<http://www.citypress.co.za/Columnists/White-first-African-second-20110924> 9/25/2011 10:00:00 AM Open letter to AfriForum CEO Kallie Kriel If one will always have to feel white first, and African second, it would be better not to stay on in Africa. It would not be worth it for this. - Nadine Gordimer Dear Kallie, Like you, I am a white Afrikaner who lives in Africa. I was glad to read in last week's City Press that you identify yourself as "an African with a light complexion". I do too. I suspect, however, that we have vastly different interpretations of what it means to be an African Afrikaner in South Africa and on the position of Afrikaners in 2011. You see yourself firstly as part of a minority group whose constitutional and human rights are being disregarded by the ANC. The premise of AfriForum's campaigns is one of victimhood. You regard the Afrikaners as a group under threat, a people whose basic rights to expression, association and movement are constantly being undermined by the black majority. You want to struggle - in the courts, on the streets and in the legislature.This is a dangerous game, Kallie. You are not stupid, I know that. So why are you refusing to present to your supporters a fairer, more balanced picture of your people's position in South Africa today? Is something more sinister at play? Is scaring people a more profitable tactic for AfriForum? You know as well as I do that the Afrikaner's cultural, religious and linguistic identity is not under threat. When I visit the Potchefstroom or Oudtshoorn arts festivals, I don't see people who are suppressed. In fact, they look happier to me than they were in 1994. Have you heard of Afrikaner author Deon Meyer's phenomenal success? We write what we like, Kallie. You referred to the right-wing publication Die Afrikaner in your interview with us. Would an oppressive regime, hellbent on suppressing its minorities, allow such a publication to appear? I think not. You (and Judge Colin Lamont) use the very narrow definition of numeracy to define minorities. Yes, numberwise the Afrikaner is a minority group. But even the United Nations, whose Minorities Declaration of 1992 is repeated almost verbatim on AfriForum's website, recognises numbers can never be the only determining factor when defining minorities. The UN published a report titled "Minorities under international law" in which it specifically (and ironically) quoted the South African example: "In most instances, a minority group will be a numerical minority, but in others, a numerical majority may also find itself in a minority-like or non-dominant position, such as blacks under the apartheid regime in South Africa." Who knows why the ANC's legal team didn't make this point in the case you brought against them. I'm sure AfriForum would agree that poor black South Africans are in an even less dominant position than middle-class Afrikaners from Pretoria.Which brings me to crime. Why does AfriForum focus largely on crime against whites when you know black, poor people are by far the most vulnerable members of society when it comes to violent crime? I see your old foe, the Transvaal Agricultural Union, admitted last week that farm murders were down by almost 50% in the last financial year. I didn't see a press statement from them or AfriForum on this.Isn't there also a responsibility on a civil rights group to inform its members when things improve? Isn't there a risk we'll have more Johan Nels - the young killer from Swartruggens who believed blacks were actively targeting whites in some form of genocide, and murdered four black people out of blind rage - if organisations like yours don't inform and educate your supporters about what's really going on? Or is there some reason you don't? If they are a minority, then Afrikaners must be one of the most powerful, wealthy and diverse minorities on the planet. Remember apartheid? The system that benefited your and my forbears to such an extent that we are still better off today than our black peers? Have you had a look at the Sunday Times' most recent Rich List published two weeks ago? If you did, you would have seen that four Afrikaners - Christo Wiese (Shoprite), Laurie Dippenaar (FirstRand), Johann Rupert (Rembrandt) and GT Ferreira (RMB) - are included in the country's top 10 richest people.And did you see who the top two earners were for 2010? Shoprite CEO Whitey Basson (who earned R627 million) and BHP Billiton boss Marius Kloppers (R77 million) - two Afrikaners. Did you discuss this with the members of AfriForum? Surely it is not possible for people from a minority group who are suppressed to do business in their country of birth? And have you asked Wiese, Dippenaar, Rupert and Ferreira whether they regard themselves as minorities? Have they addressed AfriForum's membership on becoming a billionaire minority? It doesn't seem so when I look at your website. I only see campaigns against Julius Malema, taxi drivers and Judge Nkola Motata (to your credit, you did commission a legal opinion on the Protection of Information Bill). Did you see Stats SA's latest Quarterly Labour Force Survey for 2011? Did AfriForum tell its supporters that the year-on-year unemployment rate of white people was the only population group to have decreased? Did you explain to them that 30% of adult blacks (four million people) are jobless, compared with 5% (105 000 people) of whites? If not, why not? I suppose you have to emphasise the "threats" to get your supporters to donate to your "Stop Malema" campaign. This is speculation, but I'm guessing that AfriForum has close to zero legitimacy today for black South Africans (and thousands of whites). I am not saying you shouldn't have taken the Dubula ibhunu case to court, but I'm questioning why you decided to pick that case and insisted on a judgment, even when Lamont was trying his best to push for a settlement. Even your own "Civil Rights Manifest" argues in favour of settlements.I am deeply concerned about the effect AfriForum's actions are having on our society and this is why I'm writing this letter to you. Your actions are having a polarising effect and you need to do serious introspection if you want to be respected as a civil rights group. Otherwise, you risk being a racist lobby group. Is there any reason AfriForum has no black employees (according to your website) and, I assume, no black members? Have you considered joining forces with other rights groups like Abahlali baseMjondolo, the South African shackdwellers' movement? Or even the Landless People's Movement? Or do you really only want to represent the rights of (a small group of) Afrikaners, even though your "Civil Rights Manifest" commits you to benefiting "all the citizens of South Africa"? Do you always have to feel white first, and African second? Best wishes, Adriaan Basson Click here to read the rest of the story... <http://www.citypress.co.za/Columnists/White-first-African-second-20110924> [cid:[email protected]] Click here<http://www.citypress.co.za/Newsletters/Signup> to find out about this and other City Press newsletter, or refer-a-friend<http://www.citypress.co.za/> CONFIDENTIALITY & DISCLAIMER NOTICE This message contains specific, confidential or proprietary information for exclusive use by the individual/entities to whom/which it has been addressed. If you or your company is not the intended recipient kindly notify the sender immediately. Any use or dissemination of the contents of this message is strictly prohibited. The content of this message does not constitute a commitment or an offer by Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality, except where expressly provided for in a written agreement. Any views and/or opinions expressed by the sender do not necessarily represent those of the Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality do not accept liability or legal responsibility for the contents of this message nor any errors in or omissions to the content of electronically generated communications, or any loss or damages howsoever caused, arising as a result of reliance on the contents or unauthorised use thereof. Should verification be required, kindly request the sender to do so. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality have taken steps to ensure that this message is free from computer viruses, but the responsibility of detection and prevention lies solely with the recipient. Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality does not warrant the integrity of the data transmitted, nor that it has not been corrupted nor previously intercepted and/or tampered with. ##################################################################################### This e-mail message has been scanned for Viruses and Content and cleared by MailMarshal ##################################################################################### ##################################################################################### IMPORTANT NOTICE: Warning: The information in or attached to this email message is confidential, on a “without prejudice” basis and may be subject to legal privilege and client confidentiality. If you are not the intended recipient of this email (or such person's authorised representative), then: (a) please notify the sender of this email immediately by return email, facsimile or telephone and delete this message from your system; and (b) you may not print, store, forward or copy this message or any part thereof or disclose or cause information in this message to be disclosed to any other person. In addition this message is subject to important restrictions, qualifications and disclaimers ("the disclaimer") that must be accessed and read by copying the following address into your Internet browser's address bar : http://www.unitrans.co.za/uscsDisclaimer.asp If you cannot access the disclaimer, please obtain a copy thereof from us by sending an email to : <<[email protected]>>. The disclaimer is deemed to form part of this message in terms of Section 11 of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act 25 of 2002 or alternatively is incorporated by way of reference. ##################################################################################### -- Sending your posting to [email protected] Unsubscribe by sending an email to [email protected] You can also visit http://groups.google.com/group/payco Visit our website at www.mayihlome.wordpress.com
<<inline: image005.jpg>>
