Sylwester Pietrzyk wrote:
>
> Well, I would say, that 200mm lens on APS-sized DSLR will
have the same DOF
> as the same piece of glass on 35mm camera. One condition -
the same camera
> to subject distance. At equal magnification, DSLR will
have greater DOF -
> just because you have to stand at longer distance than you
would with 35mm
> camera to obtain the same magnification level.


Hi Sylwek,

The above is true only if you assume the same diameter of
the "Circle of Confusion" for 35mm film and the APS- size
CCD.  That is a pretty gross assumption, and not one I would
support ...

>From long experience of 35mm versus medium format
comparisons I think we should take the very greatest care
when relating different DOFs for different formats.  When
comparing digital to film we should be even more careful
about drawing what appear to be finely-balanced conclusions
made on the basis of gross assumptions.

John



Reply via email to