Lasse wrote:
> Me:
> Of what relevance to the list and it's members is it that you find it boring to
>repeat information on the FA* 28-70/2.8 Pentax lens? If you don't feel like
>responding, just don't.
> (The implication of your answer is that you think the poster should have refrained
>for asking his question just because you would be bored by responding to it.)
> You are being rudely unfriendly to include such an uncalled for comment to another
>list member's perfectly legitimate and on topic question.
I pointed to the archieve and said why I did so. The fact is that numerous members of
this forum don't like dead honest opinions on lenses if they are not positive. I've
been flamed for posting lens opinions even if the flamer have never used the lens in
question. I've been flamed for repeatedly posting the same opinion again because
people ask. As recent as a couple of weeks ago someone was very unhappy because I
called the A 35/2.8 mediocre although it is my honest opinion. True, I usually do not
care at all that some people react negatively. However, since the FA* 28-70/2.8 have
so many problems in my experience I takes a hell of a lot of time to write it down. By
refering to the recent archieve was a way to try to make everybody happy. Whats more,
I'm not sure if I like the idea of having opinions permanently on a web page.
Anyway, since people seem to want it and it suddenly occured to me that I could search
my own out box to find it here it is (BTW it was posted a month ago under the heading:
"Thoughts on the FA* 28-70mm Zoom"):
REPLY:
In my opinion (I know many would disagree and have had no problems) this is the one
Pentax lens that should never have been made. Its very delicate lens and quality of
construction is compromised. This is for two reasons: 1) Power zoom and 2) auto focus.
Normally, these feature shouldn't be disastrous in themselves but some smart bean
counter at Pentax figured out that they wouldn't cost inner focusing on this lens. As
a result, focusing is done by moving the whole front tube of the lens. Because theres
so much to move, the front lens tube is made of plastic to save weight. This means
also plastic filter thread. It also means a rotating front element and filter thread
something thats a pain in the ass when using Cokin filter system and polarizers. It
also means that the power zoom has to move all elements and lens tubes something in
most cases don't manage if not the lens is pointed downwards and thereby get help from
gravity. Many samples (most?) are unable to power zoom past!
the 35mm setting.
My lens in particular had constant recurring problems; 1) the zoom scale window was
loose (of course). 2) The button for powerzoom got stucked in the "in" position. This
needed to be repared (several times - I believe three or four - actually the lens
needs to be sent to Belgium because most Pentax centers can't repair it, or more
correctly; can't open it. Its too complicated). 3) The lens refused to stop down
atomatically during exposure. 4) Power zoom may stop completely after using it a few
times. Then it worked again after the lens "rested" for about one hour (actually this
freak sympthom was disbelieved by the repairman. After he managed to induce the same
behaviour after testing it, he was completely astonished - solution to this mystery
below). These problems were never fixed. That is, they were fixed but keept on comping
back.
Alexander:
Or the ultimate satisfaction question: If someone stole the lens would
you purchase another one?
REPLY:
Are you Joking. After two years I throw mine litterally in the garbage.
[Before throwing it away I dissasembled it. I finally found out why they (Belgium)
never where able to fix it. It was designed in a way that auto stopdown and power zoom
couldn't work simultaneously. You have to choose one or the other. I found out that
the power zoom contacts touched the aperture mechanism so that it prevented the lens
to stop down by the spring action. If you bent the power zoom contacts away from the
aperture mechanism then they wouldn't couple to the power zoom contacts on the lens
mount then giving no electricity to the lens for power zoom.]
I'm sure some people are happy with it. However, you wanted real field experience;
here is mine. Oh..its great optically...
-
This message is from the Pentax-Discuss Mail List. To unsubscribe,
go to http://www.pdml.net and follow the directions. Don't forget to
visit the Pentax Users' Gallery at http://pug.komkon.org .
