Headache time ... I think we'll just put the 18mm on the digi and the 28mm on the filmi, place the cameras on the same spot, and take a picture, and then look at the results.
================================ On Jul 13, 2005, at 8:50 PM, Tom Reese wrote: I suspect that the perspective would be different too. I think a cropped 18mm image will still show the exaggerated perspective of that lens. The background will appear to be much further behind the subject than it will in the image taken with the 28mm lens. That's my theory anyway. Then Gofrey said: Citing "Basic Photography" published by Focal Press, ca. 1968-73 Edition: "Perspective is a function of distance, not focal length. ... Focal length along with format dimensions determines field of view." I think you are confusing perspective with "wide angle distortion", which is the effect in a rectilinear corrected lens of causing circles to become ovoid when off the lens axis as you increase field of view. An 18mm lens on a 16x24 format will present the same field of view as a 28mm lens will on 35mm format, and wide angle distortion will be constrained to be the same due to the fact that the field of view is identical (presuming equal rectilinear correction, of course).
