Who decides your universal values? How? Room for Mercy or Grace? Who adjudicates?
Sent from my iPad > On Oct 13, 2014, at 2:49 PM, Stephen C. Rose <[email protected]> wrote: > > Good and evil are needlessly mystified. If you have a values based ethic, > which is the only ethic that makes sense and produces measurable results, > good and evil can be seen as a spectrum that is an index that moves from the > depth of evil which is willful injury and inflicting death to selfishness and > good which runs through mindfulness, tolerance, helpfulness all the way to > acting to create truth and beauty. This index is universal and applies in all > contexts. It is a dynamic spectrum. Good and evil are values that signify > modes of behavior that we enact all the time. Life is the sum of such > actions, achieving mega force when people act in concert through various > means. The demythologizing and acceptance of our responsibility to know what > is good and what not is the project of this century as folk from Nietzsche > to Nozick have suggested. > > @stephencrose > >> On Mon, Oct 13, 2014 at 3:57 PM, Helmut Raulien <[email protected]> wrote: >> Hi Edwina! >> I am completely with you, no objections. There is the reality of evil, and >> human societies do not have an innate knowledge base to distinguish between >> good and evil. But I think, humans have, because they are creatures of: >> "God", say religious people, "evolution" say agnostics. God is "logos", >> logic, and "evolution" is based on logic too. So I think, it does not matter >> whether one is religious or is trying to understand the world by logical >> analysis. It is a matter of temperament or which way one can grasp it >> better, by allegoric pictures or by abstraction. Angels or the power of >> compassion, the devil, or the evil logic of a vicious circle? I myself >> believe in God, but do not know, what "to believe" is. Because I think, that >> all you can believe in you as well can reach by thinking, reflection, the >> capacities God has given us. Now this is a circular argument, I admit. But I >> (sort of) believe, that we also have the capacity (God-given?) to uncover >> evil as false. I think, there is something wrong with evil. It is false. And >> with logic (logos, God) we are able to prove it like that. So: Evil is real, >> but not true. Its reality is only temporary, and lasts only until it is >> proven for wrong, falsified. This is what I believe in, not knowing, but >> only intuitively feeling, what "to believe" is. How to overcome evil? See, >> that it is real, but not true, and look for ways to prove it wrong, but it >> is homeostatic, self-affirming, self-keeping. It has the form of a circle, a >> vicious one. So, how to break a circle, that is not based on truth? I think, >> with truth. Truth is an universalist concept, such as the value of life. >> Pragmatism is the quest for truth, and triadically, I would say: >> cat.1, iconical: beautiful, ugly >> cat.2, indexical: technically good (making things work), technically bad >> (things do not work) >> cat.3, symbolical: moralically good: Providing reasons for beauty and good >> working, evil: Reasons for ugliness and failure. >> And I think, that as you have said, social systems are not wise. Their >> nature is nothing but to make them more powerful, as this is the nature of >> any system, left to its own. This is something one can learn from Luhmann. >> Sytems take advantage of anything they can, be it good or evil. They even >> pervert, mix the concepts, and create super-evil situations, like: seemingly >> beautiful (utopies, huri-heaven, "arian" lunacy, to whom ever this may be >> attractive), technically good, providing reasons for good working, but in >> the end, they are a reason for extreme ugliness and total failure. This is >> eg. the isis and the nazis. So, never trust a system I would say. That is >> why I think, systems theory is good: Know the enemy. For my taste, Mumford >> is a bit too fascinated by cities. Cities are a sort of systems. I am >> writing too much. >> Best! >> Helmut >> >> >> "Edwina Taborsky" <[email protected]> >> >> Helmut - I don't think the issue is simply over a commandment of 'Thou shalt >> not kill'; it's over several other issues. >> >> First, the reality of the human capacity for reason and thus, evaluation of >> 'what is good and what is bad'. Since human societies do not have an innate >> knowledge base but must develop it within that society, then, they must have >> an evaluative capacity. >> >> Second, is the reality of evil. It exists in humans; whether it exists in >> the non-human world is debatable but I, for one, can't see it. This requires >> evaluation on our part. >> >> Cultural relativism denies evaluation. So does pacificism. Both refuse to >> acknowledge the reality of evil. >> >> Third, is the fact that we are now, globally, by virtue of our electronic >> informational network and our networked global economy - a 'world society'. >> Therefore, what goes on in one area is known - and we cannot stand by and >> ignore the reality of evil. This is the technical articulation of Peirce's >> synechism; we are actually physically (Secondness) connected. >> >> Fourth- within this synechistic 'complex networked society' - the global >> world - we cannot have extremes of lifestyle. This ONE global society, each >> part existing as it does within vastly different ecological realities - from >> desert, to rainforest, to deciduous forests, to savannahs and plains to >> mountains to ice..to... nevertheless cannot expect its population (which has >> increased exponentially in so many areas) to live within extremes - extreme >> poverty - as is found in the Middle East, Africa, Central America and >> elsewhere - to extreme wealth - as is found in these same countries as well! >> And - we can't have extremes of lifestyle where, in one domain, women are >> enslaved and forbidden to get an education while in another, they are free. >> And so on. >> >> The world is now too economically and informationally small to functionally >> handle such extreme variations. This economic and societal imbalance and its >> resultant economic and political vacuums is why we are seeing the various >> implosions around the world. [No, they aren't due to the big bad USA]. >> >> What we see with ISIS, one type of vacuum filling implosion, for example, is >> an extreme, violent utopianism, where IF ONLY they were in power, >> THEN...perfection? Can't work for reasons which I won't go into here. But to >> attain that power, requires massive brutality and killing. And massive >> repression, where a huge section of the population are reduced to slavery. >> >> Am I my brother's keeper? >> >> Edwina >> ----- Original Message ----- >> From: Helmut Raulien >> To: [email protected] >> Sent: Monday, October 13, 2014 1:22 PM >> Subject: Aw: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Re: PEIRCE-L] "More Pragmatism, Not Less" >> >> Hi! Eugene Halton was right with saying, that my post was amazingly >> thoughtless- or rather ignorant, because I havent known anything about >> Mumford but these quotes by Brooks. Now, when I see that what I have called >> "neglectiion of the value of life" in the context of his position against >> appeasement poilicy towards the nazis, I can understand it- but still I >> think, that saying "life is worthless" is an overreaction. There are dilemma >> situations, in which pacifism does not work, or even produces very bad >> results. But not being a pacifist anymore does not mean that you must throw >> the principles you have had when you were one over board: You still can say, >> that the value of life is the most important thing, and usually "thou shalt >> not kill". But in case of nazis or isis, it is better to kill them, because, >> if you dont, they kill far more people. So this is blending some utilitarism >> (highest advantage for the highest number of people) into the else no more >> working categorical imperative. But all this is still universalism based on >> the value of life. A psychologist I like very much, who has explored human >> morality in dilemma situations, is (was) Lawrence Kohlberg. >> Best, >> Helmut >> >> "Stephen C. Rose" <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> And of course the iconoclast, obedient to the First Commandment, will add >> "and none" while adhering to these sage rules.. >> >> @stephencrose >> >>> On Mon, Oct 13, 2014 at 11:26 AM, Edwina Taborsky <[email protected]> >>> wrote: >>> Thanks, Stephen. [ I had expected to be 'flung to the wolves' for my >>> views]. That quote on synechism, from Essential Peirce, vol 2, p 2 is >>> indeed relevant. As he continued, "All men who resemble you and are in >>> analogous circumstances are, in a measure, yourself, though not quite in >>> the same way in which your neighbors are you". >>> >>> That is, we are both necessarily individuals (Secondness) and also, members >>> of a vast collective (Thirdness). We have a duty to live within both modes. >>> Not just one mode of isolation of the individual self. Nor one mode of >>> denying that self and submerging it within the utopianism of 'communal >>> submission'. But both; it's not an easy task. >>> >>> Edwina >>> ----- Original Message ----- >>> From: Stephen C. Rose >>> To: Edwina Taborsky >>> Cc: Peirce List >>> Sent: Monday, October 13, 2014 11:06 AM >>> Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Re: PEIRCE-L] "More Pragmatism, Not Less" >>> >>> This is not a blog it's a list. You are not a lone voice. Peirce himself >>> said. “Nor must any synechist say, 'I am altogether myself, and not at all >>> you.' If you embrace synechism, you must abjure this metaphysics of >>> wickedness. In the first place, your neighbors are, in a measure, yourself, >>> and in far greater measure than, without deep studies in psychology, you >>> would believe. Really, the selfhood you like to attribute to yourself is, >>> for the most part, the vulgarist delusion of vanity.” >>> >>> @stephencrose >>> >>>> On Mon, Oct 13, 2014 at 10:43 AM, Edwina Taborsky <[email protected]> >>>> wrote: >>>> Well, I don't know if this blog is the place to debate the values of war >>>> versus no-war, and I know I'm almost a lone voice among a blog that seems >>>> heavily slanted towards 'the left' ideologies which to me, are always >>>> utopian rather than pragmatic, but I'm certainly not a pacifist. That's >>>> because I support the rule of law versus the rule of thugs. >>>> >>>> Phyllis, I don't think that your dandelion analogy can really be compared >>>> with fascist and fundamentalist ideologies. You seem to be saying that >>>> rather than confronting them and denying their legitimacy, one should >>>> 'just leave them alone'. The problem is, that this moves to the Rule of >>>> Thugs. Dandelions can be far more powerful and invasive than grass. Now, >>>> does grass have any 'rights to life'? Or is it just 'whichever is more >>>> powerful'? >>>> >>>> The interesting thing is that nature doesn't function by 'whichever is >>>> more powerful. Naturally, those dandelions would be eaten by browsing >>>> herbivores, supplying a certain amount of protein and other minerals. >>>> >>>> I feel that fundamentalist ideologies - if they keep their ideologies and >>>> actions confined to themselves - well, I'd agree with 'who cares'. But >>>> when their ideology includes as a basic axiom, the actual necessity to >>>> kill others, to enforce their beliefs and way of life on others - well, I >>>> think that the State and humanity - have the duty, moral as well as legal, >>>> to step in and stop them. Otherwise - it's 'rule by thugs'. >>>> >>>> The Taliban and their fundamentalist ideology were far greater in power >>>> than the people of Afghanistan. Should such a regime - with its stoning of >>>> women, its refusal to allow education, be allowed to do this? >>>> >>>> Should ISIS - with its crucifixions, beheadings, stonings, mass slaughter, >>>> openly stated agenda of taking over villages and towns and forcing people >>>> into fundamentalism - should it be allowed to continue to do this to >>>> people who simply don't have the strength to defend themselves? >>>> >>>> I'm sure you've heard of the term of 'Just War' . There's a nice book by >>>> Jean Bethke Elshtain (who also wrote a superb book on 'Sovereignty: God, >>>> State and Self). The book is 'Just War Against Terror: The burden of >>>> American power in a violent world'. >>>> >>>> She refers to Camus' The Plague, where people refuse to see evil; they >>>> have simply banished the word 'evil ' from their vocabularies. (Heh, >>>> rather similar to renaming terrorism to 'man-caused disasters'; or >>>> 'work-place violence' or calling ISIS 'just JV players'). But evil exists >>>> and we can't hide from it. >>>> >>>> Taking over a population by ruthless force, dictated by an ideology of >>>> biological or religious or ideological racism, i.e., exclusionary - and >>>> repressing by force, expelling, murdering anyone who does not submit to >>>> this ideology...I don't think that pacifism is the moral response to such >>>> thuggish behaviour. >>>> >>>> Edwina >>>> ----- Original Message ----- >>>> From: Phyllis Chiasson >>>> To: Gary Richmond ; Eugene Halton >>>> Cc: Peirce List >>>> Sent: Monday, October 13, 2014 2:19 AM >>>> Subject: [PEIRCE-L] Re: PEIRCE-L] "More Pragmatism, Not Less" >>>> >>>> >>>> Main >>>> >>>> Benign neglect was a policy proposed in 1969 by Daniel Patrick Moynihan, >>>> who was at the time on Nixon's White House Staff as an urban affairs >>>> adviser. >>>> >>>> I see the problem of wars in the way I see the problem of dandelions. I >>>> admit that I feel a sort of visceral hatred of dandelions. I want them >>>> gone from my life. Several years ago I began a campaign to extract them >>>> from the yard. I was not allowed to use chemicals, as neither my husband >>>> nor i support the use of chemical pesticides or herbicides. >>>> >>>> So, I bought a nifty little dandelion extractor and began pulling them out >>>> by the roots. For a short time (very short considering all my efforts) I >>>> had a dandelion free yard. Then POW! A plethora of dandelions. I tried a >>>> new approach, a weed burner, guaranteed to work. And it did work, but not >>>> as I wanted; weed burning resulted in even more dandelions than before. I >>>> tried an all organic herbicide, but without any luck at all. We vetoed >>>> salt, as that would kill the grass too. >>>> >>>> It was around that time of the salt discussion that Hal pointed out to me >>>> that the empty lot next door to us was practically dandelion free. Someone >>>> comes around every year with a big mower to keep the grass down and that >>>> is the sum total of gardening work on that lot. >>>> >>>> Of course, it did not require a degree in horticulture for me to >>>> understand what i had been doing by means of my exertions. I had been >>>> preparing the soil for to receive and sprout ever more of the very things >>>> that i didn't want. (Yes, i know dandelions have herbal and medicinal >>>> uses; I have even read Ray Bradbury's book, Dandelion Wine, several times.) >>>> >>>> However, I still think there is a big connection between my attempts to >>>> eradicate dandelions and our country's attempt to eradicate radical Muslim >>>> organizations. We are just preparing the ground for more dandelions, only >>>> in this case, dandelions with bombs and rocket launchers. So, to me, the >>>> most problematic effect of our military/industrial/congressional complex >>>> is that they just keep tilling the soil to encourage more and more >>>> dandelions to take root. >>>> >>>> Based on intentions measured against results, which I see as the essence >>>> of pragmatism, we are not really eradicating ISIS; we are recruiting for >>>> them. We have prepared the soil by previous wars and skirmishes and every >>>> time a drone hit produces collateral damage we are blowing fluffy >>>> dandelion seeds to take root all over the world. >>>> >>>> I don't have THE solution; but I do think it resides in Retroduction, not >>>> just in pragmatism. >>>> >>>> >>>> Gary Richmond <[email protected]> wrote: >>>> Gene Halton wrote: >>>> >>>> I find the both the letter to the New York Times from Joseph Esposito and >>>> Gary R’s claim that Brooks misused Mumford uninformed and misguided and >>>> yet you continue, Gene, that "Mumford’s allowance of the emotions was >>>> closer to Peirce's outlook, and in that sense Brooks’s understanding of >>>> “pragmatism,” whatever he meant by using the term, was shallow." So which >>>> is it Gene? Did Joseph and I perhaps get a sense of Brooks' shallowness as >>>> you termed it? Our "take" was certainly more about Brooks than Mumford. >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> I thought I made it quite clear that I have been "generally" quite >>>> sympathetic to Mumford's arguments (one of the reasons why I posted the >>>> group of quotations of his which I did), but, again, I found, as did you, >>>> "Brooks's understanding of 'pragmatism' . . . .shallow." So Joseph and I >>>> agree with you at least in that. >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> It is possible that when I read your book Bereft of Reason a few years ago >>>> I may have concentrated too heavily on such lines as the one you just >>>> quoted regarding the USA's involved in the WW2 that "Perhaps American >>>> involvement did lead to the military-industrial-academic complex and >>>> McCarthyism after the war. . ." >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Now, am I so "uniformed and misguided" if indeed our involvement in WW2 >>>> perhaps led, as you wrote, "to the military-industrial-academic complex" >>>> (Truman was strongly advised to leave out the third term of that >>>> diabolical triad, btw, which was NOT "academic" but "Congressional")? And >>>> what have we now in American and, indeed, global 'culture' but precisely >>>> the military-industrial-congressional complex writ large: the >>>> military-global corporate--governments-corrupted-by-power-and-money >>>> complex? And the women and children still suffer, as Camus wrote. Thanks >>>> for all those "good wars," those "wars to end all wars," etc., etc., etc., >>>> etc. >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Your modifying the last passage from your book which I quoted above with >>>> "perhaps" suggests to me that even you too may have some reservations >>>> about how throwing millions of American military lives into the WW2 fodder >>>> (and the Korean War fodder, and the Vietnam War fodder, and the Iraq wars >>>> fodder, and the Afghanistan fodder, and, and, and--who knows what the >>>> future may bring in the way of human fodder offered to the war machine?), >>>> that these wars may have proved historically, at least, problematic, >>>> especially given the fact that those resolved nothing, and that we have >>>> been and are still slaughtering children and young men and women and old >>>> men and women in battle, soldiers and civilians send to there deaths for. >>>> . .. what values?--to what end? (certainly in this sense at least, I >>>> completely agree with Dewey and Tori Alexander, most recently, that there >>>> is a case to be made for pacifism). >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> So to my way of thinking--after all the Brooks' nonsense is cleared >>>> away--it's not just a black and white issue that Mumford was completely >>>> correct and Dewey completely wrong, say. And, btw, I consider myself >>>> considerably less "uniformed and misguided" than you present me, and >>>> Joseph Esposito, whom I greatly respect, as being. I doubt that you or >>>> anyone has all the answers to the question of war and peace. >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Best, >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Gary >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> Gary Richmond >>>> Philosophy and Critical Thinking >>>> Communication Studies >>>> LaGuardia College of the City University of New York >>>> C 745 >>>> 718 482-5690 >>>> >>>>> On Sun, Oct 12, 2014 at 7:03 PM, Eugene Halton <[email protected]> >>>>> wrote: >>>>> I read David Brooks’ piece in the New York Times, and have had a long >>>>> term interest in pragmatism and in the work of Lewis Mumford. I actually >>>>> discuss Mumford’s essay described by Brooks in my book, Bereft of Reason, >>>>> on page 147 forward. >>>>> >>>>> I find the both the letter to the New York Times from Joseph Esposito and >>>>> Gary R’s claim that Brooks misused Mumford uninformed and misguided, and >>>>> Helmut’s claim that Mumford’s position is close to ISIS to be amazingly >>>>> thoughtless, 180 degrees from the truth, missing Mumford’s point in this >>>>> context being described that living for immediate pleasure gratification >>>>> regardless of purpose is wrong. In my opinion Mumford’s position >>>>> regarding intervention against Nazi Germany was correct and Dewey’s at >>>>> the time before World War II was incorrect. Mumford’s allowance of the >>>>> emotions was closer to Peirce's outlook, and in that sense Brooks’s >>>>> understanding of “pragmatism,” whatever he meant by using the term, was >>>>> shallow. And the term Mumford was using was "pragmatic liberalism." >>>>> >>>>> Ironically, by the very same logic, Mumford came to condemn the United >>>>> States' use of the atomic bomb at the end of World War II, and became a >>>>> critic of the US military megamachine and political megamachine, and >>>>> turned against the Vietnam War by 1965-6, one year after he had received >>>>> the Presidential Medal of Freedom from President Lyndon Johnson. I would >>>>> like to see what conservative David Brooks would do with that. >>>>> I have quoted some excerpts from my chapter in Bereft of >>>>> Reason, on “Lewis Mumford’s Organic World-View” below. >>>>> >>>>> Gene >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> excerpt from Bereft of Reason: “The second confrontation with Dewey and >>>>> pragmatism occurred on the eve of World War Two, and concerned what >>>>> Mumford termed “The Corruption of Liberalism.” Mumford believed that >>>>> fascism would not listen to reasonable talk and could not be appeased, >>>>> and urged strong measures as early as 1935 against Hitler and in support >>>>> of European nations which might be attacked by Hitler. By 1938 he urged >>>>> in The New Republic that the United States “Strike first against fascism; >>>>> and strike hard, but strike.” His militant position was widely attacked >>>>> by the left, and he lost a number of friends in the process, including >>>>> Frank Lloyd Wright, Van Wyck Brooks, Charles Beard, and Malcolm Cowley >>>>> among others. >>>>> >>>>> To give an idea of the opinions and climate of the prewar debate, just >>>>> consider the titles of commentaries published in the March, 1939 issue of >>>>> Common Sense on the question “If War Comes--Shall We Participate or be >>>>> Neutral?”: >>>>> >>>>> Bertrand Russell, “The Case for U.S. Neutrality;” Max Lerner, “`Economic >>>>> Force’ May Be Enough;” Charles A. Beard, “America Cannot ‘Save’ Europe;” >>>>> John T. Flynn, “Nothing Less Than a Crime;” and Harry Elmer Barnes, “A >>>>> War for ‘Tory Finance’?”. Dewey’s contribution was titled, “No Matter >>>>> What Happens--Stay Out,” and it could not have been more opposed to >>>>> Mumford’s piece, “Fascism is Worse than War.” Mumford believed that the >>>>> inability of the left to see that rational persuasion and appeasement >>>>> were inadequate to stem Hitler’s Hell-bound ambition indicated a >>>>> corruption in the tradition of what Mumford called “pragmatic >>>>> liberalism.” The fatal error of pragmatic liberalism was its gutless >>>>> intellectualism, its endorsement of emotional neutrality as a basis for >>>>> objectivity, which he characterized as “the dread of the emotions.” He >>>>> illustrated why the emotions ought to play a significant part in rational >>>>> decisions with an example of encountering a poisonous snake: “If one >>>>> meets a poisonous snake on one’s path, two things are important for a >>>>> rational reaction. One is to identify it, and not make the error of >>>>> assuming that a copperhead is a harmless adder. The other is to have a >>>>> prompt emotion of fear, if the snake is poisonous; for fear starts the >>>>> flow of adren[al]in into the blood-stream, and that will not merely put >>>>> the organism as a whole on the alert, but it will give it the extra >>>>> strength needed either to run away or to attack. Merely to look at the >>>>> snake abstractedly, without identifying it and without sensing danger and >>>>> experiencing fear, may lead to the highly irrational step of permitting >>>>> the snake to draw near without being on one’s guard against his bite.” >>>>> Emotions, as this example makes clear, are not the opposite of the >>>>> rational in the conduct of life, and therefore should not be neutralized >>>>> in order for rational judgments to be made. The emotion of fear in this >>>>> example is a non-rational inference which provides a means for feeling >>>>> one’s way in a problematic situation to a rational reaction before the >>>>> rationale becomes conscious… >>>>> >>>>> … In my opinion Dewey’s concept that the “context of situation” should >>>>> provide the ground for social inquiries remains an important antidote to >>>>> empty formalism and blind empiricism. Yet the clearest evidence of its >>>>> shortcomings in the practice of life was Dewey’s belief on the eve of >>>>> World War II that the United States should stay out of the impending war >>>>> against Nazi Germany, because it did not involve the American situation. >>>>> As he put it in 1939, “If we but made up our minds that it is not >>>>> inevitable, and if we now set ourselves deliberately to seeing that no >>>>> matter what happens we stay out, we shall save this country from the >>>>> greatest social catastrophe that could overtake us, the destruction of >>>>> all the foundations upon which to erect a socialized democracy.” Dewey >>>>> criticized the idea that American involvement was “inevitable” while >>>>> simultaneously assuming such participation would somehow produce >>>>> inevitable results. >>>>> >>>>> Perhaps American involvement did lead to the military-industrial-academic >>>>> complex and McCarthyism after the war--though the former would likely >>>>> have emerged in any case--but Dewey’s localism blinded him to the fact >>>>> that Western and World civilization were being subjected to a barbaric >>>>> assault, an assault from fascism and from within, which would not listen >>>>> to verbal reasoning. By ignoring the question of civilization as a >>>>> legitimate broader context of the situation and the possibility that the >>>>> unreasonable forces unleashed in Hitler’s totalitarian ambitions could >>>>> not be avoided indefinitely, Dewey was unable to see the larger unfolding >>>>> dynamic of the twentieth-century, and was led to a false conclusion >>>>> concerning American intervention which only the brute facts of Pearl >>>>> Harbor could change. >>>>> >>>>> Was Mumford the reactionary that the pre-war left attacked him for being? >>>>> Consider that by the end of World War two Mumford was attacking the >>>>> allies’ adoption of Nazi saturation bombing, both in the firebombing of >>>>> Dresden and in the nuclear bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He decried >>>>> the fall of military standards and limits in the deliberate targeting of >>>>> civilians. Mumford was among the earliest proponents of nuclear >>>>> disarmament, having written an essay on the nuclear bomb within a month >>>>> of the bombing of Hiroshima and a book within a year, as well as helping >>>>> to organize the first nuclear disarmament movement. He was an early >>>>> critic of the Vietnam War, expressing opinions publicly in 1965 which >>>>> again cost him friendships. Mumford’s last scholarly book, The Pentagon >>>>> of Power (1970) was, among other things, a fierce attack on the >>>>> antidemocratic military-industrial-academic establishment.” >>>>> >>>>> Eugene Halton, Bereft of Reason, University of Chicago Press, 1995, >>>>> pp147f. >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> --- >>>>> >>>>>> On Sun, Oct 12, 2014 at 12:10 PM, Helmut Raulien <[email protected]> >>>>>> wrote: >>>>>> My post was a bit polemic, because I was mad at Mumfords neglection of >>>>>> the value of life and that he called that "universalism". And I was >>>>>> indeed thinking of the nazis. I think, a culture that is not based on >>>>>> the value of life is not universalist, but the opposite: Particularist. >>>>>> Universalism for me is eg. Kants categorical imperative, and Kants other >>>>>> imperative, that humans (so also human life) should be treated as aims, >>>>>> not as means. And scientists like Kohlberg and pragmatists like Peirce >>>>>> were scolars of Kant. So my conclusion was, that, when someone is >>>>>> attacking scientists and pragmatists, his "universalism" is in fact >>>>>> particularism. And his concept of "culture" too, because for him, >>>>>> culture is not based on the value of life, but vice versa. But I was >>>>>> refering to a quote out of its context, maybe. >>>>>> Best, >>>>>> Helmut >>>>>> >>>>>> "Gary Richmond" <[email protected]> >>>>>> >>>>>> Ben, Helmut, Stephen, list, >>>>>> >>>>>> I certainly won't defend Brooks because I think he misuses Mumford. and >>>>>> even in the choice of this early material taken out of context, to >>>>>> support his argument contra Pragmatism in the article cited. I have >>>>>> always had a generally positive take on Mumford's ideas, although I >>>>>> don't believe I have ever read an entire book by him. >>>>>> >>>>>> This evening as I browsed through a selection of quotations from his >>>>>> books I found more which resonated positively with me than did >>>>>> not--which is not to say that I agree with him in each of the ideas >>>>>> expressed. Still, some of his ideas do not seem opposed to philosophical >>>>>> pragmatism, although his critical purposes aren't much attuned to it, at >>>>>> least as I see it at the moment. >>>>>> See: http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Lewis_Mumford >>>>>> >>>>>> Best, >>>>>> >>>>>> Gary >>>>>> >>>>>> >>>>>> Gary Richmond >>>>>> Philosophy and Critical Thinking >>>>>> Communication Studies >>>>>> LaGuardia College of the City University of New York >>>>>> C 745 >>>>>> 718 482-5690 >>>>>> >>>>>>> On Sat, Oct 11, 2014 at 8:13 PM, Benjamin Udell <[email protected]> >>>>>>> wrote: >>>>>>> Helmut, list, >>>>>>> >>>>>>> I seldom am inclined to defend Brooks. I haven't read Mumford, although >>>>>>> I have somewhere his book on Melville that I meant to read. For what >>>>>>> it's worth, I'll point out that Mumford wrote the Brooks-quoted remark >>>>>>> in 1940, when the horrors of WWII had not fully unfolded yet. Maybe he >>>>>>> never backed down from it, I don't know. In a box somewhere I have >>>>>>> another book that I meant to read, about how in the Nazi death camps >>>>>>> sheer survival, fighting just to live, became a kind of heroism. The >>>>>>> higher ideals ought to serve life, not tell it that it's full of crap, >>>>>>> only to replace the crap with other crap, a.k.a. brainwashing and >>>>>>> Mobilization (quick flash of Pink Floyd's marching hammers). "They want >>>>>>> politics and think it will save them. At best, it gives direction to >>>>>>> their numbed desires. But there is no politics but the manipulation of >>>>>>> power through language. Thus the latter’s constant debasement." - >>>>>>> Gilbert Sorrentino in _Splendide-Hôtel_. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Best, Ben >>>>>>> >>>>>>> On 10/11/2014 5:41 PM, Helmut Raulien wrote: >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Hi! I think, that Mumford, to whom Brooks refers, is quite close to the >>>>>>> Isis: "“Life is not worth fighting for: bare life is worthless. Justice >>>>>>> is worth fighting for, order is worth fighting for, culture ... .is >>>>>>> worth fighting for: These universal principles and values give purpose >>>>>>> and direction to human life.” That could be from an islamist >>>>>>> hate-preaching: Your life is worthless, so be a suicide bomber and go >>>>>>> to universalist(?) heaven. Brooks and Mumford are moral zealots and >>>>>>> relativists who project that on the people who have deserved it the >>>>>>> least. They intuitively know that they havent understood anything, the >>>>>>> least the concept of universalism, and bark against those who have, >>>>>>> because they are jealous. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Gesendet: Samstag, 11. Oktober 2014 um 20:38 Uhr >>>>>>> Von: "Gary Richmond" <[email protected]> >>>>>>> An: Peirce-L <[email protected]> >>>>>>> Betreff: [PEIRCE-L] "More Pragmatism, Not Less" >>>>>>> List, >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Joseph Esposito responded to David Brooks' Oct.3 New York Times column, >>>>>>> "The Problem with Pragmatism," with this letter to the editor today. >>>>>>> http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/11/opinion/more-pragmatism-not-less.html?ref=opinion >>>>>>> >>>>>>> To the Editor: >>>>>>> >>>>>>> David Brooks paints an all too convenient caricature of American >>>>>>> pragmatism (“The Problem With Pragmatism,” column, Oct. 3). Even the >>>>>>> slightest reading of Charles Peirce, William James, John Dewey and >>>>>>> Sidney Hook will reveal pragmatists who were passionate about values as >>>>>>> well as the means of realizing them in enduring democratic social >>>>>>> institutions. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> The problem the United States confronts in the Middle East is not >>>>>>> paralysis or doubt but the adherence to many years of contradictory and >>>>>>> self-defeating values and policies that will make matters worse. What >>>>>>> is needed is more pragmatism, not less. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> JOSEPH L. ESPOSITO >>>>>>> Tucson, Oct. 4, 2014 >>>>>>> >>>>>>> >>>>>>> >>>>>>> The writer is a lawyer, philosopher and former student of Sidney Hook. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Brooks >>>>>>> ' article, >>>>>>> http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/03/opinion/david-brooks-the-problem-with-pragmatism.html?module=Search&mabReward=relbias%3Ar%2C%7B%221%22%3A%22RI%3A10%22%7D >>>>>>> which quotes heavily from some of Lewis Mumford's critiques of >>>>>>> Liberalism, may have a different kind of Pragmatism in mind than that >>>>>>> which Esposito points to, perhaps what Susan Haack in Evidence and >>>>>>> Inquiry terms "vulgar Pragmatism" >>>>>>> (182-202) by which she means especially Richard Rorty's version. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Apropos of the theme Brooks takes up, near the end of the chapter >>>>>>> "Vulgar Pragmatism: An Unedifying Prospect," she quotes Peirce as >>>>>>> writing: ". . . if I should ever tackle that excessively difficult >>>>>>> problem, 'What is for the true interest of society?' I should feel that >>>>>>> I stood in need of a great deal of help from the science of legitimate >>>>>>> inferences. . ." ( >>>>>>> op. cit. >>>>>>> 201). Here, as everywhere, Peirce shows himself to be essentially a >>>>>>> logician. >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Best, >>>>>>> >>>>>>> Gary >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> ----------------------------- >>>>> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >>>>> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >>>>> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >>>>> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the >>>>> BODY of the message. More at >>>>> http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> ----------------------------- >>>> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >>>> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >>>> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >>>> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the >>>> BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm >>>> . >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> ----------------------------- >>>> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >>>> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >>>> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >>>> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the >>>> BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm >>>> . >> ----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or >> "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go >> to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY >> of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . >> >> >> >> >> >> ----------------------------- >> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but >> to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of >> the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . >> >> >> >> >> ----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or >> "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go >> to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L >> but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY >> of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . >> >> >> ----------------------------- >> PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON >> PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to >> [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but >> to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of >> the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . > > > ----------------------------- > PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON > PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] > . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] > with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at > http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . > > > >
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
