Sending this out in response Orin Hargrave’s question. > On Jan 20, 2016, at 11:26 AM, Jeffrey Brian Downard <[email protected]> > wrote: > > List, > > A group that includes Kees de Waal, John Kaag, Terry Moore and myself have > been working on a project called the Scalable Peirce Interpretation Network > (SPIN). We are trying to recruit three sets of people: > > 1. Individual scientists who draw on Peirce's ideas in their work, and who > will help identify outstanding questions concerning logic and semiotics that > arise in their research and discuss the issues. > 2. Groups of Peirce scholars who will transcribe pages in the Logic Notebook > and related manuscripts in logic and semiotics—especially those having higher > degrees of complexity. > 3. A crowdsource group of individuals who would like to transcribe the more > straightforward pages of the manuscripts. > > A short description of the project is attached. Up to this point, we have > recruited 10 groups of scholars to do what is described in (2). These groups > will be lead by Fernando Zalamea (Colombia group), Ahti Pietarinen (Finland > group), Doug Anderson (US-midwest group), Giovanni Maddalena (Italy group), > James Liszka (US-East), Cheryl Misak (Canada group), Shigeyuki Atarashi > (Japan group), and (newly added) Frederik Stjernfeldt. Gary Fuhrman has > offered to help organize a crowdsource group that we are hoping to recruit > from the Peirce-List in the upcoming months. > > If you are a scientist, logician or mathematician who draws on Peirce's ideas > in your work, then I would like to ask if you would write a letter saying > that you are willing to collaborate with others on the project. In order to > participate in SPIN, the scientists do not need to be scholarly experts in > Peirce’s writings. In fact, we are hoping to recruit scientists with a wide > range of interests and experience when it comes to Peirce’s ideas—including > those who are fairly new to his works. The reason we want the scientists in > (1) to collaborate with the scholars in (2) is that we think some progress > can be made by providing extra opportunities for discussions between the two > sets of people. When the scholars have a better understanding of what is > really puzzling to the scientists about how they might use Peirce’s ideas in > their research, then the scholars will be able to focus on interpreting > manuscripts that might shed light on those questions. As the scholars > transcribe the relevant pages and develop alternate lines interpretations, > then they can help to explain to the scientists how Peirce might have been > developing those ideas in the vast trove of his unpublished works. In time, > we hope that such discussions will lead to richer forms of collaboration > between the scientists and the scholars. > > Several people who have heard about the project have asked if we will be > making the manuscripts available online. Here is the answer to that > question: a link to the FromThePage transcription platform that we are > building to support the collaborative research is provided below. At this > point, the platform is set up solely for the purpose of transcribing and > interpreting easier pages, and we only have a relatively small number of > folders containing manuscripts (largely from the Logic Notebook) that are > ready for transcription. In the next several months, however, it will be > extended to include the transcription tools needed to handle the most complex > kinds of symbols and diagrams and the social tools needed to carry on > discussions. If you are interested in participating in (2) or (3) above, > then start by taking the SPIN transcription platform on FromThePage for a > spin. Anyone who would like to try their hand at transcribing some pages is > more than welcome to give it a try. We are running a pilot study to see how > well suited the platform is for these purposes, and we're looking for > feedback. > > http://beta.fromthepage.com/collection/show?collection_id=16 > > We have created links on our FromThePage site to digital scans of the entire > Logic Notebook and to the larger set of manuscripts made from the microfiche. > As far as I know, this is the first time those manuscripts have been made > publicly accessible online. We've checked with Harvard library, and they > have given us permission for this project. Given our current level of > startup funding, we can provide up to 10,000 pages of manuscripts on the > transcription platform at a time--but the links will take you to folders on a > public dropbox account and a picasa page with the full set of images. In the > future, we hope to work our way through larger sets of manuscripts and to > make them available in one place with transcriptions, interpretations and > translations linked to each page. That will take us some time and quite a > bit of funding, but we hope to kickstart the project in earnest this Spring. > Having studied a number of group and crowdsourced efforts to transcribe other > sets of manuscripts it is remarkable to see how many manuscripts can be > transcribed in a fairly short amount of time by a dedicated group of people > working together. In the cases of the Bentham and Darwin manuscript > projects, crowd sourced groups have transcribed tens of thousands of pages in > just a few years. > > I'm not a person who has spent much time doing this kind of transcription > work myself, but the time I've spent working through the Logic Notebook in > the last several weeks has been extremely rewarding. For instance, I've been > digging through the notes he made between 1902-1905 on the development of the > 10-fold classification of types of signs and semiotic relations, and it is > remarkable to see how he sorted out the problems and built up to the larger > 66-fold classification. The pages in the Logic Notebook have shed light on > interpretative questions that have been puzzling to me for a number of years, > so it is proving to be quite eye opening and a lot of fun and to examine the > manuscripts carefully. > > Let me know if you have any questions about the project. A summary of the > SPIN proposal is attached. For those scientists who are willing to write a > letter of commitment saying that they are willing to participate in the SPIN > project, we are very grateful. There is a sample letter attached that might > help to economize on your time. > > Yours, > > Jeff > > > Jeffrey Downard > Associate Professor > Department of Philosophy > Northern Arizona University > (o) 928 523-8354 > <Sample letter of commitment for SPIN Project--Scientists.docx> > <SPIN proposal for scientists.pdf> > > ----------------------------- > PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON > PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] > . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] > with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at > http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm . > > > >
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
