List,
In a draft of a 1905 letter to Lady Welby, Peirce analyzes the tetradic relationship of A gives up B to C in exchange for D (Semiotic and Significs, 190). I am interested in his remarks about the exchange of goods for the sake of better understanding his account of the relations that hold between signs, objects and interpretants. Peirce argues that any tetradic or higher order relationship (i.e., valency >3) is complex and can be analyzed into elementary monadic, dyadic and triadic relations. Here is the upshot of his analysis of exchanging goods: The tetradic relationship is reducible to, at most, 10 elementary triadic relations. Here they are: a. λ is an exchange of property (B and D) between A and C b. ι is a transposition of ownership of B and D c. L is an accomplishment of λ through ι d. μ is the surrender by A of B e. m is the surrender by C of D f. Μ<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%9C> is the performance of μ in reciprocal consideration of m (Note the error in the transcription, which has M instead of m at the end.) g. ν is the acquisition by A of D h. η is the acquisition by C of B i. Ν<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%9D> is the performance of μ in reciprocal consideration of η (Note the error in the transcription, which has N instead of η at the end.) j. L is carried out by the union of M and N. On the basis of this type of analysis, Peirce generalizes to relationships of higher adicity. He claims there is a power law that holds for relations of adicity four or greater. 1. Tetradic relations such as exchanging appear to be reducible to, at most, 10 triadic relations. 2. Pentadic relations are reducible to, at most, 100 triadic relations. 3. Hexadic relations are reducible to, at most, 1,000 triadic relations. 4. Enneadic relations are reducible to, at most, 1,000,000 triadic relations. I'd like to ask two questions. First, what is the basis of this claim concerning the power law that seems to govern higher-order relations? Second, how does this analysis apply to Peirce's paradigmatic case of giving--offered as an example of a genuinely triadic relation. Following the analysis of exchange offered above, giving is reducible to, at most, three triadic relations. A gives B to C: a. μ is the surrender by A of B b. η is the acquisition by C of B c. Μ<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%CE%9C> is the performance of μ with the intent of bringing about η I'd like to flag two points that can be made about this analysis. First, I'd like to note that the performance of μ with the intent of bringing about η has the implied condition that, if C does not accept B as a gift, then A may reassert ownership. Second, each of the relations might be understood as having the following condition: _____ in accordance with property laws R in legal system S. My hunch is that Peirce is, in this analysis, ignoring the relevance of the property laws that would, typically, govern exchanges and gifts. Let me end by restating the question posed above: is this a fair analysis of the more elementary triadic relations that are involved in a genuinely triadic relation, such as giving? Yours, Jeff Jeffrey Downard Associate Professor Department of Philosophy Northern Arizona University (o) 928 523-8354
----------------------------- PEIRCE-L subscribers: Click on "Reply List" or "Reply All" to REPLY ON PEIRCE-L to this message. PEIRCE-L posts should go to [email protected] . To UNSUBSCRIBE, send a message not to PEIRCE-L but to [email protected] with the line "UNSubscribe PEIRCE-L" in the BODY of the message. More at http://www.cspeirce.com/peirce-l/peirce-l.htm .
