Let us hope the phoney war is over and the battle for Europe has begun
24 May 2001

Frustrated Blair accuses media of ignoring 'real election issues'

Tony Blair: 'The campaign has revolved to a quite ridiculous degree around
personality rather than policy'
For too long, the Labour government's attitude towards Europe has seemed to be a
love that dare not speak its name. Whenever the Conservatives have accused Labour of
an excess of Europhilia, the Government has gone into desperate denial. We found
ourselves drowning in ifs, buts and maybes.

This useless strategy left pro- and anti-Europeans almost equally disgruntled. We
welcome the fact that � as Tony Blair's comments in his interview in today's
Independent make clear � a sea change now seems to be upon us at last.

Lady Thatcher has done the pro-Europeans a sterling service by parachuting the
subject on to the election agenda. Her insistence that the euro is unthinkable �
now, tomorrow, forever � has encouraged Mr Blair to speak out properly for the first
time. Mr Blair is right to point to the "ludicrousness" of existing Tory policy on
the euro, which he describes as "we're against the principle � but only for five
years". (It is, it must be said, a somewhat cheeky accusation. Labour's own policy
till now has been equally eager to prevaricate: "We're in favour of the euro �
unless we're not.") Above all, Mr Blair is right to note: "At least Margaret
Thatcher has the courage of her convictions on that."

We do hope that the Prime Minister will now show that he himself has the courage of
his convictions.

Mr Blair emphasises that it could be possible "to turn public opinion around very
quickly" on the euro. Quite true, if the case is made forcefully enough � which the
Government has until now signally failed to do.

On the question of tax harmonisation, the Labour Party still finds itself on the
back foot. The latest claims from the Conservatives that tax harmonisation is on a
secret Euro-agenda were hotly denied in Brussels yesterday, where the
internal-market commissioner said he was "not in favour, and never will be, of any
harmonisation of income taxes". Despite the denials, the logic of the single market
means that increasing harmonisation of VAT and other taxes is likely to become
inevitable.

In other respects, however, almost-frankness on both sides now seems to be the order
of the day. In his keynote election speech on Europe, Mr Blair seems ready to
assault the Tories' pathological Euroscepticism head-on. Mr Blair's insistence that
"in an economic union, the economics have got to be right", is partly weasel
language. For supporters and opponents of the euro alike, politics is as important
as economics. None the less, we welcome the fact that movement has come into the
debate.

In one respect, this election is a mini-referendum on the euro: one side is broadly
in favour; the other clearly against. Mr Hague is, however, wrong to suggest that
this is the last chance to save the pound. The promised referendum means that
choices will remain open after 7 June. If the British people do not want the euro,
they will say "no". Nor will this vote take place in a void. In contrast to the
referendum on staying in the European Economic Community in 1975, there will be
plenty of chance for opponents of the euro to make themselves heard. If Mr Hague is
confident that the people will oppose the euro, he should welcome the referendum
because of the humiliation that it will bring to the Government.

One of the most obvious differences between Labour and Conservatives remains the
chasm separating them on Europe. We hope that the battle has at last been joined,
instead of the shadow-boxing that we have seen up until now. Europe is Britain's
future. A move away from Europe would be catastrophic for all. One day, even the
Conservative Party will have to understand that simple point.

Reply via email to