"James Daly" <[email protected]> wrote: 

> Marx never wrote the 15 galley sheets he famously calculated necessary for an 
> expose of Hegel's method, and it seems strange he left the task to Engels, 
> who did not have Marx's professional background in philosophy. 

I think that there were a number of people that would have liked Marx to 
exclude 
Hegel's ideas, but Marx considered him to be great. Marx claimed to be using 
the scientific method, and left the rest of us to decide on how he was applying 
it. 

> The notion of dialectics seems often to reduce to claiming something turns 
> into its opposite. 

I think that Engels has it pretty close to right in that there are opposing 
factors in nature 
and human society and that we just need to sort those out. 

Lenin and the Russian Communists seem to use the idea of contradiction to an 
idea 
instead making dialectics into a word game. 

-- 
Ron 

_______________________________________________
pen-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.csuchico.edu/mailman/listinfo/pen-l

Reply via email to