tom walker quotes :

Jonathan Nitzan wrote:


"Finance is the only real form of capital. The
notions that machines can have a "quantity" is the
fiction.    Finance, or capitalization, represents the
present value of expected  feature earnings. The
earnings and their discounting mechanism have  nothing
do with the quantity of any "stuff" such as machines,
goods or  services. Rather, they are the numerical
representation of the power of  exclusion. This power
permeates the entire social process, from the
assembly line, through formal politics, to religion,
culture,  consumption and what not. In that sense,
capital represents the  capitalization of power."

^^^^

CB: I believe Marx is explicit in characterizing the quantifiying of
congealed labor as a fiction. Abstract labor is a fiction. There isn't any
material "thing" in a commodity that we can find that corresponds to
abstract labor.

Then, isn't quantifying power a fiction too ? If so, then the problem is not
using fictions, but ,which fiction best helps us overthrow the actuality of
capitalism. A "power" or "power of exclusion" that permeates everything may
very well be a better way to think about it. The argument needs to be made
more clearly from my standpoint.

Reply via email to