Thanks to Louis for forwarding the article. Unless someone convinces me otherwise, I would recommend great reservation regarding the Peru elections, even though the N. American media is already including it in the "pink tide".

Candidate Ollanta Humala now claims affinity with Chavez and Morales (and even Kirchner or Bachelet) and the only polling firm considered reliable predicts him likely to emerge as the leader in the first round of voting Sunday, and that he will likely face neo-liberal Lourdes Flores in a second round. A losing third place is predicted to go to Alain Garcia of the APRA party, often cited in "standard" textbooks as the historical example of a vaguely leftish popularist party, mixed with corruption/mismanagement and today more like "liberal" in the US sense.

But Humala's political background is of extreme ultra-nationaliasm and racialism -- his father, a lawyer, founded a fringe party that promotes these ideas and Ollanta was an activist for the party until just a few years ago (including an attempted military coup with a handful of followers in 2000). Just when and how far his ideas have changed from the lunatic fringe is unclear (Ollanta's brother is running as the fringe party's candidate against his brother).

Humala's personal background and experience is also quite different. He grew up in a middle class suburb of Lima, went to one of the elite private High Schools and then directly to the national military college. Recently, serious charges have surfaced that the unit he commanded as a Captain engaged in local massacres and other acts during the war against Sendero Luminoso. The charges are only now being investigated...Humala's rise has been a 'bolt from the blue' which also indicates the instability and fragility of Peru's political processes. It is not known what he stands for and he has had no real political experience. As in many developing countries, Peru's policy-based political parties collapsed when power radically shifted to the Bretton Woods institutions and other forces outside of electoral reach.

All this is far from, say, Chavez or Morales (and, as I understand it, even they evolved quite a bit during their many years of building their movements).

Paul

Louis P. forwarded:
NY Times, April 7, 2006
Growth's Caprice Angers Some Peruvians
By JUAN FORERO

ICA, Peru, April 1 — Business has been good for José Chlimper, owner of a vast farm carved into the desert here, where workers churn out 50 tons of asparagus a day for markets in the United States and Europe. Production is expected to double by 2009, and the seasonal work force tripled in just five years.

Reply via email to