Mark,

Yep, I believe samba is the same across most popular distributions,
apart from detailed version numbers.

You also need to setup the firewall. OpenSUSE uses FirewallD,not ufw as
used by Ubuntu and Mint.

Instructions for starting and stopping the samba processes will also
vary with distribution.

OpenSUSE Yast2 can be used for basic setup but I needed to manually
configure /etc/samba/smb.conf.

I have always found samba quite/very tricky to get working plus I find
it is usually  easier to access a samba share from a Linux PC than a
Windows PC. Many times I have changed the samba config file and it has
not worked as expected or at all. You really need to stick with it and
put plenty of time aside. From a diagnostic viewpoint it is best to
first get something that just works and then change one parameter at a
time until it behaves in the way that you want it to. Annoyingly,
virtually all the examples in the text books and online are very
simplistic and therefore to my mind misleading.

I have found that typically smb services are difficult/impossible to
get working on a TV/set-top box. I use minidlna to serve AV data as it
seems to be much better supported and overall less fussy. I reserve
samba for when I need to reliably serve data files. I also use sshfs on
my Mint desktop to access/manipulate documents on my server.

Reluctantly, I needed to enable SMB protocol V1 on Windows before my
W10 machine could see my server. Default is "Disabled" as a virus
protection feature - remember the NHS virus. Hopefully the machines
negotiate to a higher protocol (as they should and the server has been
setup to do) as smbv1 is a pretty inefficient and unsecure protocol. I
could check this but it works well enough for my setup and I really do
not want to spend any more time on it.

I chose not to use AD (did not want it on my network or the extra
complexity) and do not use host files as I don't like hard-coding
server addresses; these decisions probably explain some of my
difficulties.

Nigel can contact me directly if he has any specific questions and we
can feed any generic conclusions to the mailing list if they may be of
more general interest.

Kind Regards,

Clive


-- 
Peterboro mailing list
Peterboro@mailman.lug.org.uk
https://mailman.lug.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/peterboro

Reply via email to