Alvaro Herrera wrote:
Andrew Dunstan wrote:

Maybe we should look some more at that. Use of file locking was one
thought I had today after I saw Tom's earlier comments.

Perl provides a moderately portable flock(), which we use in fact in
buildfarm to stop it from running more than one at a time on a given repo

But does it work over NFS?  On my system, the flock manpage claims it
doesn't, lockf doesn't say and fcntl also doesn't say, but the flock
manpage says fcntl does.  A lot of people runs servers on NFS, even
though we recommend they don't.  And there are those strange hybrids
like SANs, NASes or what have you.

One serious problem is that if the lock doesn't work for some reason
like NFSness, it will fail silently, which is not acceptable.

Fair point. Perl in fact uses whatever it can from the underlying system, preferring (I think) flock, then fcntl, then lockf. So its flock is quite possibly not NFS safe in many cases.



---------------------------(end of broadcast)---------------------------
TIP 4: Have you searched our list archives?


Reply via email to